文献速递男科与性医学

在线症状检查器是诊断男性健康疾病的劣质工具

Online Symptom Checkers are Poor Tools for Diagnosing Men's Health Conditions.
PubMed 文献 · Urology · 2022-09-14

本研究用160个人工去标识化门诊病例摘要测试4款最常用在线症状检查器对勃起功能障碍、阴囊疼痛、佩罗尼病和低睾酮的诊断准确性。结果显示没有一款工具能准确诊断全部疾病,总体准确性较差;作者提醒患者和医生注意在线症状检查器的准确性。

要点

  • WebMD对低睾酮准确性95%,对勃起功能障碍和佩罗尼病均为0%。
  • MedicineNet对勃起功能障碍和佩罗尼病准确性分别为100%和98%,对低睾酮为0%。
  • SutterHealth对勃起功能障碍准确性100%,对低睾酮80%,对阴囊疼痛20%。

核心结论

  • 没有一款在线症状检查器能准确诊断所有 tested 疾病,平均而言对勃起功能障碍、佩罗尼病、低睾酮和阴囊疼痛的精确诊断建议较差。
  • 作者提醒患者和医生注意在线症状检查器的准确性。

研究设计与样本

  • 研究创建了160个人工病例摘要,来自近期门诊初诊讨论勃起功能障碍(40)、阴囊疼痛(40)、佩罗尼病(40)和低睾酮(40)的去标识化记录。
  • 将病例摘要输入通过网站流量分析工具确定的4款最常用在线症状检查器:WebMD、MedicineNet、EverydayHealth和SutterHealth。
  • 记录并评分在线症状检查器鉴别诊断中列出的前5种疾病。

主要发现

  • WebMD对勃起功能障碍、阴囊疼痛、佩罗尼病和低睾酮的准确性分别为0%、22.5%、0%和95%。
  • EverydayHealth仅能诊断阴囊疼痛20%的时间,对所有病例均未能诊断勃起功能障碍、佩罗尼病或低睾酮。
  • MedicineNet对勃起功能障碍、佩罗尼病、阴囊疼痛和低睾酮的诊断率分别为100%、98%、27.5%和0%。
  • SutterHealth对勃起功能障碍、阴囊疼痛和低睾酮的正确诊断率分别为100%、20%和80%。
  • 累计来看,在线症状检查器在Top 1(37.5% vs 6.9%)和Top 5(50% vs 24.5%)建议疾病中,对勃起功能障碍诊断最准确,对阴囊疼痛诊断最不准确。

临床怎么用

  • 原文未据此给出推荐。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVE: To analyze the accuracy of the 4 most commonly used online symptom checkers (OSCs) in diagnosing erectile dysfunction (ED), scrotal pain (SP), Peyronie's disease (PD), and low testosterone (LT). METHODS AND OUTCOMES: One-hundred and sixty artificial vignettes were created by de-identifying recent initial outpatient consults presenting to discuss ED (40), SP (40), PD (40), and LT (40). The vignettes were entered into the 4 most frequently used OSCs (WebMD, MedicineNet, EverydayHealth, and SutterHealth) as determined by web traffic analysis tools. The top 5 conditions listed in the OSC differential diagnosis were recorded and scored. RESULTS: WebMD's accuracy for ED, SP, PD, and LT vignettes was 0%, 22.5%, 0%, and 95%, respectively. EverydayHealth was only able to diagnose SP 20% of the time, and failed to diagnose ED, PD, or LT on all occasions. MedicineNet diagnosed ED, PD, SP, and LT in 100%, 98%, 27.5%, and 0% of vignettes, respectively. SutterHealth correctly diagnosed ED, SP, and LT in 100%, 20%, and 80% of patients, respectively. Cumulatively, the OSCs were most accurate in diagnosing ED and least accurate in diagnosing SP when using the Top 1 (37.5% vs 6.9%) and Top 5 (50% vs 24.5%) of the suggested conditions. CONCLUSION: No OSC could accurately diagnose all the conditions tested. The OSCs, on average, were poor at suggesting precise diagnoses for ED, PD, LT, SP. Patients and practitioners should be cautioned regarding the accuracy of OSCs.

来源:Urology,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Patel RD, Swanton AR, Gross MS, et al. Online Symptom Checkers are Poor Tools for Diagnosing Men's Health Conditions. Urology. 2022. PMID: 36115428. doi:10.1016/j.urology.2022.08.032

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。