一项欺骗性研究避免回忆偏倚,证实三种经验证问卷在诊室或电话中对伴或不伴尿失禁的女性评分相似
本研究采用欺骗性设计避免回忆偏倚,前瞻性对40例尿失禁女性和46例对照女性先后通过电话和约2周后现场填写三种经验证问卷。14个问题中仅2个问题评分差异有统计学意义但幅度很小。总体上电话与现场问卷评分可比,尿失禁女性可从远程问卷评估中获益。
要点
- 在伴或不伴尿失禁女性中,电话与现场填写三种问卷的评分总体可比。
- 14个问题中仅UDI-6第1题(P=0.033)和IIQ-7第7题(P=0.036)评分差异有统计学意义。
- 尿失禁女性中仅IIQ-7第7题(P=0.012)评分差异有统计学意义。
核心结论
- 三种问卷通过电话或现场获得的评分总体可比,尿失禁女性可从远程问卷评估中获益。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性研究,经机构审查委员会批准并做效力计算,纳入86例女性,其中尿失禁40例(30-85岁)、对照46例(30-85岁),人口学参数相似。
- 三种问卷为尿路困扰量表6简表(UDI-6)、国际尿失禁7简表(IIQ-7)和生活质量调查,先电话填写、约2周后现场再次填写。
- 采用欺骗模型避免回忆偏倚,电话中不告知研究,现场完成问卷后才告知研究并邀请知情同意比较电话与现场评分。
- 排除非英语者、活动性尿路感染、精神能力受损或流质饮食者。
- 研究时间为2021年6月至9月。
主要发现
- 14个问题中仅2个问题评分差异有统计学意义:UDI-6第1题(P=0.033)和IIQ-7第7题(P=0.036),差异幅度很小。
- 尿失禁女性中仅IIQ-7第7题(P=0.012)评分差异有统计学意义。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为,尿失禁女性可能失访或仅能通过远程医疗电话联系,可从这三种问卷的远程评估中获益。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
PURPOSE: With increasing telehealth technology, confirming the validity of non-office administration of questionnaires intended for office use only is important. We studied 3 validated questionnaires: the Urinary Distress Inventory 6-Short Form, the International Incontinence 7-Short Form, and a quality of life survey using a deception model. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Following Institutional Review Board approval and power calculations, these 3 questionnaires were prospectively administered in women with and without incontinence by phone and then again in person about 2 weeks later. To avoid recall bias, participants were not informed of the study over the phone. After completing their office visit questionnaire scores, they were told about the study and invited to consent for comparison of their phone and in-person questionnaire scores. Non-English speakers and those with an active urinary tract infection, with impaired mental competency, or on a fluid diet were excluded. RESULTS: From June to September 2021, 86 women, including 40 incontinent (30-85 years old) and 46 control (30-85 years old), with similar demographic parameters met all study criteria. Of the 14 questions studied, only 2, ie, Question 1 on the Urinary Distress Inventory 6-Short Form (P = .033) and Question 7 on the International Incontinence 7-Short Form (P = .036), showed rather minimal but statistically significant differences in scores. For incontinent women, only Question 7 on the International Incontinence 7-Short Form (P = .012) showed a significant score difference. CONCLUSIONS: The 3 questionnaire scores were overall comparable when obtained over the phone or during office visits. Women with incontinence, who may otherwise be lost to follow-up or only reachable by telehealth calls, can benefit from the remote administration of these 3 questionnaires.
引用
- Reddy M, Kusin S, Christie A, et al. A Deception Study to Avoid Recall Bias Confirms Similar Scores for 3 Validated Questionnaires in the Office or Over the Phone in Women With or Without Urinary Incontinence. J Urol. 2022. PMID: 36036901. doi:10.1097/JU.0000000000002891
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。