每十年都重要:肾部分切除术后功能恢复的叙述性综述
该叙述性综述回顾了肾部分切除术中缺血与功能恢复的主要进展及持续争议,重点纳入改变手术管理视角的文献及钳夹与非钳夹队列的随机试验。综述指出,将肾实质体积变化纳入分析后缺血失去统计学意义,保留的肾实质体积百分比成为主要决定因素,非钳夹与钳夹随机试验显示缺血对功能恢复影响极小。
要点
- 将肾实质体积变化纳入分析后,缺血与功能恢复的统计学关联消失,保留的肾实质体积百分比成为主要决定因素。
- 冷缺血被证实具有高度保护作用,有限的热缺血也被证明是安全的。
- 肾部分切除术的重建阶段、避免肾实质血供中断,对功能结局似乎最为重要。
核心结论
- 过去十年肾部分切除术后功能恢复取得很大进展,但仍有无未解问题:不可逆缺血性损伤开始出现的热缺血阈值是多少、哪些队列急性肾损伤或不可逆缺血性损伤风险增加、哪些患者应优先考虑零缺血肾部分切除术。
研究设计与样本
- 叙述性综述,识别反映肾部分切除术后缺血与功能恢复主要进展的关键文献,特别关注改变手术管理视角的贡献,并优先纳入钳夹与非钳夹队列的随机试验。
主要发现
- 十年前发表的「每一分钟都重要」显示钳夹肾部分切除术中缺血持续时间与急性肾损伤及慢性肾病发展强相关。
- 减少或零缺血肾部分切除术与强功能恢复相关并伴有一些围手术期风险,但在有经验者手中总体安全。
- 将肾实质体积变化纳入分析后,缺血失去统计学意义,保留的肾实质体积百分比被证明是主要决定因素。
- 冷缺血被确认具有高度保护作用,有限的热缺血也被证明是安全的。
- 肾部分切除术的重建阶段、避免肾实质血供中断,对功能结局似乎最为重要;钳夹与非钳夹肾部分切除术的随机试验显示缺血对功能恢复影响极小。
局限性
- 原文指出仍有无未解问题,包括不可逆缺血性损伤开始出现的热缺血阈值、哪些队列急性肾损伤或不可逆缺血性损伤风险增加、哪些患者应优先考虑零缺血肾部分切除术。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To provide a narrative review of the major advances regarding ischaemia and functional recovery after partial nephrectomy (PN), along with the ongoing controversies. METHODS: Key articles reflecting major advances regarding ischaemia and functional recovery after PN were identified. Special emphasis was placed on contributions that changed perspectives about surgical management. Priority was also placed on randomized trials of off-clamp vs on-clamp cohorts. RESULTS: A decade ago, 'Every minute counts' was published, showing strong correlations between duration of ischaemia and development of acute kidney injury (AKI) and chronic kidney disease after clamped PN. This reinforced perspectives that ischaemia was the main modifiable factor that could be addressed to improve functional outcomes and helped spur efforts towards reduced or zero ischaemia PN. These approaches were associated with strong functional recovery and some peri-operative risk, although they were generally safe in experienced hands. Further research demonstrated that, when parenchymal volume changes were incorporated into the analyses, ischaemia lost statistical significance, and percent parenchymal volume saved proved to be the main determinant. Cold ischaemia was confirmed to be highly protective, and limited warm ischaemia also proved to be safe. The reconstructive phase of PN, with avoidance of parenchymal devascularization, appears to be most important for functional outcomes. Randomized trials of on-clamp vs off-clamp PN have shown minimal impact of ischaemia on functional recovery. CONCLUSIONS: The past decade has witnessed great progress regarding functional recovery after PN, with many lessons learned. However, there are still unanswered questions, including: What is the threshold of warm ischaemia at which irreversible ischaemic injury begins to develop? Are some cohorts at increased risk for AKI or irreversible ischaemic injury? and Which patients should be prioritized for zero-ischaemia PN?
引用
- Campbell SC, Campbell JA, Munoz-Lopez C, et al. Every decade counts: a narrative review of functional recovery after partial nephrectomy. BJU Int. 2022. PMID: 35835519. doi:10.1111/bju.15848
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。