文献速递前列腺增生与排尿功能障碍泌尿系感染男科与性医学

LEARN:英国医学院泌尿外科教学的多中心横断面评估

LEARN: A multi-centre, cross-sectional evaluation of Urology teaching in UK medical schools.
PubMed 文献 · BJU Int · 2022-04-29

LEARN是一项全国多中心横断面研究,于2020年10月3日至12月20日邀请二年级至五年级医学生及第一年基础培训医生回顾性填写问卷,评估迄今接受的泌尿外科教学。共纳入来自全部39所英国医学院的7063/8346份回复(84.6%),其中1127/7063份(16.0%)来自第一年基础培训医生。结论认为按英国泌尿外科医师协会本科教学大纲评估教学似乎令人满意,但许多学生报告无泌尿外科临床实习,部分新晋医生报告从未插过导尿管,作者建议加强本科泌尿外科临床暴露并更严格遵循英国医学总会规定的操作要求。

要点

  • 调查覆盖全部39所英国医学院,回复率84.6%(7063/8346),其中第一年基础培训医生1127/7063份(16.0%)。
  • 第一年基础培训医生报告本科期间最常教的主题为尿路感染(96.5%)、急性肾损伤(95.9%)和血尿(94.4%)。
  • 最不常教的主题为男性尿失禁(59.4%)、男性不育(52.4%)和勃起功能障碍(43.8%)。

核心结论

  • LEARN是有史以来规模最大的本科泌尿外科教学评估。
  • 在英国,按英国泌尿外科医师协会本科教学大纲评估,教学似乎令人满意。
  • 然而,许多学生报告无泌尿外科临床实习,部分新晋医生报告从未插过导尿管,而这是英国医学总会规定的必备要求。
  • 作者建议更加重视本科泌尿外科临床暴露,并更严格遵循英国医学总会规定的操作要求。

研究设计与样本

  • LEARN为全国多中心横断面研究,邀请二年级至五年级医学生及第一年基础培训医生于2020年10月3日至12月20日完成问卷,回顾性评估迄今接受的泌尿外科教学。
  • 结果按互联网电子调查结果报告清单(CHERRIES)报告。
  • 共纳入来自全部39所英国医学院的7063/8346份回复(84.6%),其中第一年基础培训医生1127/7063份(16.0%)。

主要发现

  • 第一年基础培训医生报告本科培训中最常教的主题为尿路感染(96.5%)、急性肾损伤(95.9%)和血尿(94.4%)。
  • 最不常教的主题为男性尿失禁(59.4%)、男性不育(52.4%)和勃起功能障碍(43.8%)。
  • 作为本科生在患者身上完成男性导尿的第一年基础培训医生占92.1%,完成女性导尿的占73.0%。
  • 16.9%的第一年基础培训医生曾考虑以泌尿外科为职业。
  • 理论教学主要在医学院早期进行,临床技能教学和临床实习主要在医学院后期进行;20.1%的第一年基础培训医生报告本科期间无泌尿外科临床实习。

关键数值与推荐

  • 评估对照英国泌尿外科医师协会本科泌尿外科教学大纲。
  • 英国医学总会规定的泌尿外科操作要求:本科期间在患者身上完成男性和女性导尿。

临床怎么用

  • 作者建议更加重视本科泌尿外科临床暴露。
  • 作者建议更严格遵循英国医学总会规定的操作要求。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the status of UK undergraduate urology teaching against the British Association of Urological Surgeons (BAUS) Undergraduate Syllabus for Urology. Secondary objectives included evaluating the type and quantity of teaching provided, the reported performance rate of General Medical Council (GMC)-mandated urological procedures, and the proportion of undergraduates considering urology as a career. MATERIALS AND METHODS: LEARN was a national multicentre cross-sectional study. Year 2 to Year 5 medical students and FY1 doctors were invited to complete a survey between 3rd October and 20th December 2020, retrospectively assessing the urology teaching received to date. Results are reported according to the Checklist for Reporting Results of Internet E-Surveys (CHERRIES). RESULTS: 7,063/8,346 (84.6%) responses from all 39 UK medical schools were included; 1,127/7,063 (16.0%) were from Foundation Year (FY) 1 doctors, who reported that the most frequently taught topics in undergraduate training were on urinary tract infection (96.5%), acute kidney injury (95.9%) and haematuria (94.4%). The most infrequently taught topics were male urinary incontinence (59.4%), male infertility (52.4%) and erectile dysfunction (43.8%). Male and female catheterisation on patients as undergraduates was performed by 92.1% and 73.0% of FY1 doctors respectively, and 16.9% had considered a career in urology. Theory based teaching was mainly prevalent in the early years of medical school, with clinical skills teaching, and clinical placements in the later years of medical school. 20.1% of FY1 doctors reported no undergraduate clinical attachment in urology. CONCLUSION: LEARN is the largest ever evaluation of undergraduate urology teaching. In the UK, teaching seemed satisfactory as evaluated by the BAUS undergraduate syllabus. However, many students report having no clinical attachments in Urology and some newly qualified doctors report never having inserted a catheter, which is a GMC mandated requirement. We recommend a greater emphasis on undergraduate clinical exposure to urology and stricter adherence to GMC mandated procedures.

来源:BJU Int,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Ng A, Wai-Shun Chan V, Asif A, et al. LEARN: A multi-centre, cross-sectional evaluation of Urology teaching in UK medical schools. BJU Int. 2022. PMID: 35488402. doi:10.1111/bju.15758

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。