文献速递前列腺癌

评估前列腺癌治疗咨询中的患者健康状况

Estimating patient health in prostate cancer treatment counseling.
PubMed 文献 · Prostate Cancer Prostatic Dis · 2021-11-03

研究评估泌尿外科医生对局限性前列腺癌患者健康四分位判断的一致性,并比较依据NCCN指南采用精算寿命表与Kent模型估算的预期寿命及治疗推荐。结果显示医生判断与验证模型假定真实四分位仅41%一致,NCCN方法在最佳四分位低估死亡风险、最差四分位高估死亡风险。作者认为基于医生评估健康四分位的预期寿命估算方法过于粗糙,不适用于治疗咨询。

要点

  • 医生对健康四分位的判断与验证模型假定真实四分位仅41%一致。
  • 无病例达到四分之三医生正确分配健康四分位,半数病例正确分配医生不足50%。
  • NCCN方法在最佳四分位低估死亡风险、最差四分位高估死亡风险。

核心结论

  • 基于医生评估健康四分位的预期寿命估算方法,如NCCN指南所建议,与验证预测模型如Kent模型相比似乎过于粗糙,不适用于局限性前列腺癌男性的治疗咨询。

研究设计与样本

  • 研究评估泌尿外科医生对局限性前列腺癌患者健康四分位判断的一致性,并比较遵循NCCN指南基于精算寿命表与Kent模型(一种验证的预期寿命预测模型)的预期寿命及治疗推荐。
  • NCCN建议使用精算寿命表并依赖外科医生对患者健康的评估,将预期寿命增加(最佳四分位)或减少(最差四分位)50%。
  • 11名泌尿外科医生为10个患者病例分配健康四分位并推荐治疗。
  • 使用Kent模型计算10年生存概率,并与基于外科医生共识健康四分位的寿命表估计进行比较。

主要发现

  • 医生评估与基于验证模型的假定真实健康四分位在41%的病例中一致。
  • 无病例达到四分之三医生正确分配健康四分位;半数病例中,正确分配四分位的医生不足50%。
  • 与Kent模型相比,NCCN合并症调整的预期寿命估计在最佳健康四分位低估死亡风险,在最差健康四分位高估死亡风险。
  • NCCN估计预期寿命>10年的患者更常被推荐手术(81%),预期寿命≤10年的患者更常被推荐放疗(57%)或观察(29%)。

关键数值与推荐

  • NCCN建议使用精算寿命表并依赖外科医生对患者健康的评估,将预期寿命增加(最佳四分位)或减少(最差四分位)50%。
  • 医生评估与验证模型假定真实健康四分位一致率为41%。
  • NCCN估计预期寿命>10年的患者推荐手术比例为81%,预期寿命≤10年的患者推荐放疗比例为57%、观察比例为29%。

临床怎么用

  • 作者认为基于医生评估健康四分位的预期寿命估算方法似乎过于粗糙,不适用于局限性前列腺癌男性的治疗咨询。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: We assessed the concordance among urologists' judgment of health quartiles for patients with localized prostate cancer, and compared the life expectancy (LE) and ensuing treatment recommendations when following National Comprehensive Cancer Network (NCCN) guidelines based on actuarial life tables versus the Kent model, a validated LE prediction model. METHODS: NCCN suggests using actuarial life tables and relying on surgeon assessment of patient health to increase (for the best quartile) or decrease (for the worst quartile) LE by 50%. Eleven urologic surgeons allocated quartile of health and recommended treatments for ten patient vignettes. The 10-year survival probability was calculated using the Kent model and compared to the life-table estimate based on health quartile by surgeon consensus. RESULTS: Surgeon assessment agreed with the presumed true quartile of health based on a validated model in 41% of cases. For no case did three-quarters of surgeons assign health quartile correctly; in half of cases, <50% of surgeons assigned the correct quartile. The NCCN comorbidity-adjusted LE estimates underestimated risk of death in the best health quartile and overestimated risk of death in the worst health quartile, compared to the Kent model. Patients with LE > 10 years on NCCN estimation were recommended more frequently for surgery (81%) and those with ≤10 years estimated LE were more commonly recommended for radiation (57%) or observation (29%). CONCLUSIONS: A method based on physician-assessed health quartiles for LE estimation, as suggested by the NCCN guidelines, appears too crude to be used in the treatment counseling of men with localized prostate cancer, as compared to a validated prediction model, such as the Kent model.

来源:Prostate Cancer Prostatic Dis,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Chesnut GT, Tin AL, Fleshner KA, et al. Estimating patient health in prostate cancer treatment counseling. Prostate Cancer Prostatic Dis. 2021. PMID: 34732855. doi:10.1038/s41391-021-00467-5

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。