文献速递中医康复针灸推拿

按摩随机对照试验报告质量评估

Assessment of the reporting quality of randomised controlled trials of massage.
PubMed 文献 · Chin Med · 2021-07-28

该研究系统检索8个电子数据库,纳入2447项按摩随机对照试验,使用CONSORT 2010、CONSORT NPT扩展2017和自拟按摩专用清单评估报告质量。结果显示CONSORT、NPT扩展和按摩专用清单的平均报告率分别为50%、10%和45%,68个评估条目中42个报告不充分,提示按摩RCT报告质量参差不齐,亟需制定「CONSORT按摩扩展」报告指南。

要点

  • 按摩RCT报告质量整体欠佳,NPT扩展条目报告率仅10%。
  • 96.8%的按摩RCT来自中国,国际英文期刊CONSORT/NPT评分更高。
  • 建议制定「CONSORT按摩扩展」以规范按摩干预的报告。

核心结论

  • 已发表的按摩RCT报告质量参差不齐,亟需改进。
  • 应制定「CONSORT按摩扩展」报告指南。

研究设计与样本

  • 系统检索8个电子数据库,纳入英文和中文按摩RCT,检索截止2020年6月22日。
  • 共纳入2447项按摩RCT,其中96.8%分布在中国。
  • 使用CONSORT 2010清单(37条)、CONSORT NPT扩展2017清单(18条)和自拟按摩专用清单(16条)进行质量评估。

主要发现

  • CONSORT、NPT扩展和按摩专用清单的平均报告率分别为50%、10%和45%。
  • 68个评估条目中42个报告不充分,包括18个CONSORT条目、15个NPT条目和9个按摩专用条目。
  • 2010年后发表的文章报告质量略有改善;国际英文期刊CONSORT和NPT条目得分更高,中文期刊按摩专用条目得分更高。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVE: To assess the reporting quality of randomised controlled trials (RCTs) of massage, particularly whether necessary elements related to massage interventions were adequately reported. METHODS: A total of 8 electronic databases were systematically searched for massage RCTs published in English and Chinese from the date of their inception to June 22, 2020. Quality assessment was performed using three instruments, namely the CONSORT (Consolidated Standards of Reporting Trials) 2010 Checklist (37 items), the CONSORT Extension for NPT (Nonpharmacologic Treatments) 2017 checklist (18 items), and a self-designed massage-specific checklist (16 items) which included massage rationale, intervention and control group details. Descriptive statistics were additionally used to analyse the baseline characteristics of included trials. RESULTS: A total of 2,447 massage RCTs were identified, of which most (96.8%) were distributed in China. For the completeness of CONSORT, NPT Extension, and massage-specific checklists, the average reporting percentages were 50%, 10% and 45%, respectively. Of 68 assessed items in total (exclusion of 3 repeated items on intervention), 42 were poorly presented, including 18 CONSORT items, 15 NPT items, and 9 massage-specific items. Although the overall quality of reporting showed slightly improvement in articles published after 2010, the international (English) journals presented a higher score of the CONSORT and NPT items, while the Chinese journals were associated with the increased score of massage-specific items. CONCLUSION: The quality of reporting of published massage RCTs is variable and in need of improvement. Reporting guideline "CONSORT extension for massage" should be developed.

来源:Chin Med,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Zhang X, Zhang L, Xiong W, et al. Assessment of the reporting quality of randomised controlled trials of massage. Chin Med. 2021. PMID: 34321044. doi:10.1186/s13020-021-00475-6

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。