针灸疗效是否因针灸师而异:个体患者数据荟萃分析
该研究基于39项高质量针灸试验的个体患者数据,其中13项试验的1206名针灸师可识别,比较假针灸或非针灸对照。针灸师间效应存在统计学显著异质性(p<0.0001),但变异程度很小,观察到的效应分布几乎与随机期望重叠。
要点
- 针灸师间疗效差异虽具统计学意义,但变异程度很小。
- 非针灸对照试验中,效应量偏离均值半个标准差的针灸师比例观察值为37%,期望值为34%。
- 未发现证据支持进一步标准化针灸实践可改善结局。
核心结论
- 针灸师间疗效差异大于随机期望,但变异程度很小,多数慢性疼痛患者临床实践结果可能与高质量试验相似。
研究设计与样本
- 研究基于39项高质量针灸试验的个体患者数据,其中13项试验的1206名针灸师可识别,对照为假针灸或非针灸对照。
- 采用荟萃分析方法评估针灸师间异质性。
主要发现
- 假针灸对照试验中针灸师间异质性 statistically significant(p<0.0001)。
- 非针灸对照试验中针灸师间异质性 statistically significant(p<0.0001)。
- 非针灸对照试验中,效应量高于或低于平均值半个标准差的针灸师比例期望为34%,观察为37%。
临床怎么用
- 多数慢性疼痛患者临床实践中可期望获得与高质量试验相似的针灸疗效。
- 未发现证据支持通过进一步标准化针灸实践来改善结局。
局限性
- 纳入试验的针灸师范围相对有限,主要为医师针灸师。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: The degree to which the effects of acupuncture treatment vary between acupuncturists is unknown. We used a large individual patient dataset of trials of acupuncture for chronic pain to assess practitioner heterogeneity. METHODS: Individual patient data linked to identifiable acupuncturists were drawn from a dataset of 39 high-quality trials of acupuncture, where the comparators were either sham acupuncture or non-acupuncture controls, such as standard care or waitlist. Heterogeneity among acupuncturists was assessed by meta-analysis. RESULTS: A total of 1206 acupuncturists in 13 trials were included. Statistically significant heterogeneity was found in trials with sham-control groups (p < 0.0001) and non-acupuncture control groups (p <0.0001). However, the degree of heterogeneity was very small, with the observed distribution of treatment effects virtually overlapping that expected by chance. For instance, for non-acupuncture-controlled trials, the proportion of acupuncturists with effect sizes half a standard deviation greater or less than average was expected to be 34%, but was observed to be 37%. A limitation is that the trials included a relatively limited range of acupuncturists, mainly physician-acupuncturists. DISCUSSION: Although differences in effects between acupuncturists were greater than expected by chance, the degree of variation was small. This suggests that most chronic pain patients in clinical practice would have similar results to those reported in high-quality trials; comparably, we did not find evidence to suggest that greater standardization of acupuncture practice would improve outcomes. Further research needs to be conducted exploring variability using a sample of acupuncturists with a broader range of practice styles, training and experience.
引用
- Vickers AJ, Vertosick EA, Lewith G, et al. Do the effects of acupuncture vary between acupuncturists? Analysis of the Acupuncture Trialists' Collaboration individual patient data meta-analysis. Acupunct Med. 2020. PMID: 33300369. doi:10.1177/0964528420959089
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。