文献速递针灸推拿中药与中成药合理使用中医康复

艾灸系统评价报告质量评估:基于PRISMA与艾灸相关信息条目

Reporting quality of systematic reviews with moxibustion.
PubMed 文献 · Chin Med · 2020-09-29

结果显示PRISMA条目总体报告依从性尚可,但艾灸干预细节(如艾灸类型、材料、操作、选穴标准、安全评价、治疗环境)报告严重不足,建议制定艾灸干预PRISMA扩展版报告规范。

要点

  • 艾灸系统评价对艾灸类型、材料、操作、选穴标准等干预细节报告不足。
  • 94.8%的系统评价未报告治疗环境,69.1%未提供安全评价信息。
  • 55.4%的Meta分析因艾灸干预报告不充分而无法评估其执行是否恰当。

核心结论

  • 艾灸系统评价在艾灸干预措施和艾灸相关理论依据方面报告不足,需进一步改进报告质量。
  • 建议制定「艾灸干预PRISMA扩展版」报告指南以提升该类系统评价的质量。

研究设计与样本

  • 采用PRISMA 27条目和根据中医理论及STRICTOM设计的14条目艾灸相关信息评估报告质量,并做描述性统计。

主要发现

  • PRISMA 27条目中,除条目5、8、16、23外,其余23条目报告依从性高于55%,条目20和26报告率为100%。
  • 69.1%(67/97)的系统评价未提供艾灸的具体类型。
  • 39.2%(38/97)缺乏艾灸材料、操作过程和技术的细节。
  • 67.0%(65/97)未报告艾灸选穴标准,28.9%(28/97)未提供治疗次数或疗程时长。
  • 69.1%(67/97)未提供任何安全评价信息,94.8%(92/97)未报告治疗环境。

关键数值与推荐

  • PRISMA 27条目中23项报告依从性高于55%,2项(条目20、26)为100%。
  • 艾灸相关信息中,未报告艾灸类型者占69.1%(67/97),未报告选穴标准者占67.0%(65/97),未报告安全评价者占69.1%(67/97),未报告治疗环境者占94.8%(92/97)。
  • 92篇纳入Meta分析的系统评价中,51篇(55.4%)因艾灸干预报告不充分而无法评估Meta分析是否恰当执行。

临床怎么用

  • 临床解读艾灸系统评价时,需注意其干预细节报告常不充分,谨慎看待其结论。
  • 开展艾灸系统评价时应详细报告艾灸类型、材料、操作、选穴标准、安全评价及治疗环境等信息。
  • 建议参照即将制定的艾灸干预PRISMA扩展版规范来设计和报告艾灸系统评价。

局限性

  • 艾灸相关信息评估条目为自行设计,可能影响评估的标准化程度。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Moxibustion is one of the major interventions of Chinese medicine (CM). The systematic reviews (SRs) are essential references for evaluating the efficacy and safety of moxibustion interventions. This study aimed to assess the reporting quality of these SRs, particularly whether necessary information related to moxibustion was adequately reported. METHODS: Seven databases (including four English and three Chinese databases) were systematically searched for SRs of moxibustion that were published up to 31 December 2019. The primary analysis was to assess their reporting quality based on 27-item of the Preferred Reporting Items for SRs and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) and 14-item of moxibustion-related information designed according to CM theory and the STandards for Reporting Interventions in Clinical Trials Of Moxibustion (STRICTOM). Descriptive statistics were also used to analyze their baseline characteristics. RESULTS: A total of 97 SRs of moxibustion were identified from 2011 to 2019. For 27-item of PRISMA, except item 5, 8, 16 and 23, the remaining 23 items had the reporting compliances higher than 55%, of which 2 items (item 20 and 26) were fully reporting (100%). However, for moxibustion-related information, 69.1% (67/97) SRs did not provide the specific type of moxibustion, 39.2% (38/97) lacked details regarding the materials, procedure and technique used for moxibustion, 67.0% (65/97) did not report the selection criteria of acupoints for moxibustion, 28.9% (28/97) did not provide the number or duration of treatment sessions, 69.1% (67/97) did not provide any information about safety evaluation, and 94.8% (92/97) SRs did not report the treatment environment. For 51 (55.4%) of 92 SRs that included meta-analysis, it was impossible to assess whether meta-analysis had been properly conducted due to inadequate reporting of moxibustion interventions. CONCLUSION: The reporting quality of SRs of moxibustion need further improvements in terms of adequate reporting of moxibustion interventions and of moxibustion-related rationales. Reporting guideline of "PRISMA extension for moxibustion interventions" should be developed thus to improve their quality.

来源:Chin Med,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Tian R, Zhang X, Li SY, et al. Reporting quality of systematic reviews with moxibustion. Chin Med. 2020. PMID: 33005215. doi:10.1186/s13020-020-00385-z

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。