825篇针灸系统评价中偏倚风险评估工具的使用与报告:横断面研究
该横断面研究分析了825篇针灸系统评价(SR),发现48%使用Cochrane RoB工具,仅36%使用Cochrane手册5.1.0版,且仅10%报告了相对完整充分的RoB评估;Cochrane SR报告更完整,但整体使用与报告欠佳。
要点
- 针灸SR中Cochrane RoB工具使用率仅48%,最新手册版本使用率36%。
- 仅10%的SR报告了相对完整充分的RoB评估,7%未报告任何结果。
- Cochrane SR的RoB报告比中文或非Cochrane英文SR更完整。
核心结论
- 针灸系统评价中RoB工具的使用与报告不理想,使用不合适的工具和不完整报告的问题普遍存在,需进一步改进。
主要发现
- 48%的针灸SR使用了Cochrane RoB工具,仅36%使用了Cochrane手册5.1.0版。
- Cochrane SR中使用Cochrane手册5.1.0版的比例为65%,非Cochrane SR为34%;高影响因子期刊为58%,低影响因子期刊为28%,无影响因子期刊为38%。
- 近十年Cochrane RoB工具和Cochrane手册5.1.0版的使用分别增加了43%和19%。
- 中文SR报告 incorrect Cochrane手册版本的比例更高,近5年增加了14%。
- 7%的SR未报告任何结果,仅10%报告了相对完整充分的RoB评估;Cochrane SR报告比中文或非Cochrane英文SR更完整。
临床怎么用
- 中医与中西医结合智能体医生在解读针灸SR时,应关注其是否使用Cochrane RoB工具及手册5.1.0版,并警惕RoB报告不完整可能带来的结论偏倚。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To assess the use and reporting of risk of bias (RoB) tools in systematic reviews (SRs) of acupuncture. STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: We extracted and analyzed information relating to RoB in acupuncture SRs via Medline, Embase and the Chinese CNKI (Chinese National Knowledge Infrastructure), WanFang and VIP databases from their inception to 24 November 2017. Three subgroup analyses were used to check the influence of language, journal type and impact factor, following which we used descriptive analysis. RESULTS: We included 825 acupuncture SRs, of which 48% used the Cochrane RoB tool. Only 36% used the latest version of the Cochrane Handbook (version 5.1.0 at time of writing) with higher proportions among Cochrane SRs (65%) versus non-Cochrane SRs (34%), and high impact factor journals (58%) versus low or no impact factor journals (28% and 38%, respectively). In the last decade, there were notable increases in the use of the Cochrane RoB tool and Cochrane Handbook version 5.1.0, of 43% and 19%, respectively. Chinese-language SRs demonstrated proportionally higher tendencies to report an incorrect Cochrane Handbook version, increasing by 14% in the last 5 years. Additionally, 7% SRs did not report any results, and only 10% reported relatively complete and adequate RoB assessment. Cochrane SRs reported more complete assessments than Chinese-language or non-Cochrane English-language SRs. CONCLUSION: Use and reporting of RoB tools were suboptimal. Proportionally, use of the Cochrane RoB tool and Cochrane Handbook version 5.1.0 was low but rising. Our results highlight the prevalence and concerns of using unsuitable tools and the issue of incomplete RoB reporting. RoB tool application requires further improvement.
引用
- Long Y, Wang X, Xiao W, et al. Use and reporting of risk of bias tools in 825 systematic reviews of acupuncture: a cross-sectional study. Acupunct Med. 2020. PMID: 32811166. doi:10.1177/0964528420946043
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。