气功临床研究证据的文献计量学分析
该文献计量学研究系统梳理了截至2018年12月10日的中外数据库气功临床研究,共纳入886项研究,覆盖14个国家,涉及糖尿病、慢阻肺、高血压等15种主要疾病。八段锦研究最多(492项,55.5%),97%的研究报告了有益结果,但研究类型、干预和结局报告异质性大,亟需制定报告标准并开展高质量试验。
要点
- 气功临床研究以八段锦为主(492项,55.5%),其次为健身气功、导引术、五禽戏和易筋经。
- 研究最多的疾病包括糖尿病、慢阻肺、高血压、中风、颈椎病等15种。
- 97%的研究报告气功练习有益,但研究类型和结局报告异质性大,需规范报告标准。
核心结论
- 气功临床研究出版物逐渐增多,但研究类型、参与者、气功干预和结局报告多样且不一致,亟需制定气功各种干预的报告标准,并需要方法学质量高、样本量充足的高质量试验和真实世界研究来验证气功在健康和疾病管理中的效果。
研究设计与样本
- 文献计量学分析,检索中国生物医学文献数据库、中国知网、中国科技期刊数据库、中国学术会议论文数据库、中国学位论文数据库、PubMed和Cochrane Library,检索时间从建库至2018年12月10日。
- 纳入所有类型的人体原始和二次研究:系统评价、随机临床试验、非随机对照临床研究、病例系列和病例报告。
- 共纳入886项临床研究,包括47项系统评价、705项随机临床试验、116项非随机对照临床研究、12项病例系列和6项病例报告;研究在14个国家开展。
主要发现
- 研究最多的前15种疾病/病症为:糖尿病、慢性阻塞性肺疾病、高血压、中风、颈椎病、腰椎间盘突出症、失眠、膝骨关节炎、下背痛、骨质疏松、冠心病、乳腺癌、肩周炎、抑郁、代谢综合征。
- 在886项临床研究中,八段锦研究最多,为492项(55.5%),其次为健身气功107项(12.1%)、导引术85项(9.6%)、五禽戏67项(7.6%)和易筋经66项(7.4%)。
- 随机试验中最常用的对照为维持正常生活方式不变149项(18.1%),其余对照包括常规治疗(主要为西药)、中药、针灸、健康教育、心理治疗、瑜伽、太极和其他非药物疗法。
- 最常报告的结局为身体功能、生活质量、症状、疼痛和心理健康指标。
- 97%的研究报告了练习气功的有益结果。
临床怎么用
- 临床可参考气功研究较多的疾病领域(如糖尿病、慢阻肺、高血压、中风、颈椎病等)及常用功法(八段锦等)作为辅助干预思路,但需注意研究异质性大、报告不一致,应结合高质量证据和个体情况谨慎应用。
局限性
- 研究类型、参与者和结局报告多样且不一致。
- 需要制定气功各种干预的报告标准。
- 需要方法学质量高、样本量充足的高质量试验和真实世界研究来验证效果。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: This bibliometric study aimed to systematically and comprehensively summarize the volume, breadth and evidence for clinical research on Qigong. And this bibliometric analysis also can provide the evidence of this field. DESIGN: Bibliometric analysis. METHODS: All types of primary and secondary studies on humans were included: systematic reviews, randomized clinical trials, non-randomized controlled clinical studies, case series and case reports. Chinese Biomedical Literature Database, China National Knowledge Infrastructure, Chinese Scientific Journal Database, Chinese Academic Conference Papers Database and Chinese Dissertation Database, PubMed and the Cochrane Library were searched from the date of inception to December 10, 2018. Bibliometric information, such as publication information, disease/condition, Qigong intervention and research results were extracted and analyzed. RESULTS: A total of 886 clinical studies were identified: including 47 systematic reviews, 705 randomized clinical trials, 116 non-randomized controlled clinical studies, 12 case series and 6 case reports. The studies were conducted in 14 countries. The top 15 diseases/conditions studied were: diabetes, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, hypertension, stroke, cervical spondylosis, lumbar disc herniation, insomnia, knee osteoarthritis, low back pain, and osteoporosis, Coronary heart disease, breast cancer, periarthritis of shoulder, depression, metabolic syndrome. Of the various Qigong exercises reported in these 886 clinical studies, Ba Duan Jin was the most frequently researched in 492 (55.5%) studies, followed by Health Qigong 107 (12.1%), Dao Yin Shu 85 (9.6%), Wu Qin Xi 67 (7.6%) and Yi Jin Jing 66 (7.4%). The most frequently used comparisons in randomized trials were maintaining normal way of life unchanged 149 (18.1%), the remaining controls included conventional treatment, mainly western medicine, Chinese herbal medicine, acupuncture, health education, psychological therapy, Yoga, Tai Chi and other non-drug therapy. The most frequently reported outcomes were physical function, quality of life, symptoms, pain and mental health indicators. Beneficial results from practicing Qigong were reported in 97% of studies. CONCLUSIONS: Qigong research publications have been increasing gradually. Reports on study types, participants, Qigong Intervention, and outcomes are diverse and inconsistent. There is an urgent need to develop a set of reporting standards for various interventions of Qigong. Further trials of high methodological quality with sufficient sample size and real world studies are needed to verify the effects of Qigong in health and disease management.
引用
- Zhang YP, Hu RX, Han M, et al. Evidence Base of Clinical Studies on Qi Gong: A Bibliometric Analysis. Complement Ther Med. 2020. PMID: 32444061. doi:10.1016/j.ctim.2020.102392
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。