针刺治疗重度抑郁症:临床实践指南推荐意见综述
该范围综述纳入2014年1月至2018年5月发表的、以针刺为评价问题的成人抑郁症临床实践指南,共5部(美国3部、加拿大1部、中国1部)。多数指南未就针刺给出明确推荐,仅2部持支持态度,且推荐形成方法差异大、论证细节不足。
要点
- 5部指南中3部未对针刺治疗抑郁症给出推荐,2部持支持态度。
- 多数指南未清晰陈述评价问题,推荐依据的论证细节不足。
- 临床使用指南推荐前应仔细评估其形成方法的可靠性。
核心结论
- 成人抑郁症指南对针刺的推荐意见差异较大,多数未给出明确推荐,仅2部支持使用。
- 指南推荐形成的方法学质量参差,推荐依据的论证通常不够详细。
研究设计与样本
- 范围综述,检索2014年1月至2018年5月发表的、以针刺为评价问题的成人抑郁症临床实践指南,限英文或西班牙文。
- 共纳入5部指南:美国3部、加拿大1部、中国1部。
- 采用AMSTAR-2评估指南中系统评价的质量,并描述针刺推荐的形成方式。
主要发现
- 5部指南中4部仅满足AMSTAR-2的2至3个条目,1部满足7个条目。
- 各指南形成推荐的方法不一致。
- 3部指南未就针刺发布任何推荐(其中1部提及不应使用),2部指南支持使用针刺。
关键数值与推荐
- 4部指南满足AMSTAR-2的2至3个条目,1部满足7个条目。
- 5部指南中2部支持针刺、3部未给出推荐(其中1部提及不应使用)。
临床怎么用
- 临床医生在采用指南中的针刺推荐前,应仔细阅读并评估其推荐形成方法的可靠性。
局限性
- 多数指南未清晰陈述评价问题,读者难以理解指南制定组试图回答的问题。
- 支持决策的论证通常不够详细,导致对推荐意见的评估极为困难。
- 检索仅限英文和西班牙文发表的文章。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The use of acupuncture to treat depression is not uncommon. However, recommendations regarding acupuncture issued by clinical practice guidelines (CPG) vary widely. OBJECTIVE: To describe the recommendations regarding acupuncture in CPGs for depression in adults, and to assess the methodology used to reach them. METHODS: We conducted a scoping review of CPGs for depression management in adults, which performed systematic reviews (SRs) to answer their review questions, were published between January 2014 and May 2018, and assessed the use of acupuncture as a review question. We limited out search to articles published in English/Spanish. We assessed the SRs quality using the "A MeaSurement Tool to Assess Systematic Reviews-2" (AMSTAR-2), and described how the recommendation regarding acupuncture was reached. FINDINGS: We found five CPGs that fulfilled our inclusion criteria: three from the US, one from Canada, and one from China. Four CPGs fulfilled between two and three items of AMSTAR-2, and one CPG fulfilled seven items. The methodology used to formulate the recommendations varied between CPGs. Regarding acupuncture use recommendations: three CPGs did not issue any recommendation (although one mentions that it should not be used), whilst two were in favor. DISCUSSIONS: The lack of a clearly stated review question presented in the majority of CPGs prevents the reader from understanding what the CPG developing group was trying to answer. Moreover, the arguments presented to support a decision are usually not detailed enough. Therefore, the assessment of the recommendations was extremely difficult. CLINICAL IMPLICATIONS: Given that the formulation of recommendations is not always reliable, clinicians should carefully read and assess the recommendations presented in CPGs before implementing them.
引用
- Fernandez-Chinguel JE, Goicochea-Lugo S, Villarreal-Zegarra D, et al. Acupuncture for major depressive disorder: A review of the recommendations stated at clinical practice guidelines. Complement Ther Med. 2020. PMID: 32147048. doi:10.1016/j.ctim.2020.102321
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。