指南与共识中医内科针灸推拿中药与中成药合理使用

针灸、生物反馈、按摩、气功、放松疗法、设备引导呼吸、瑜伽和太极能否用于降压?基于高质量系统评价的建议

Should acupuncture, biofeedback, massage, Qi gong, relaxation therapy, device-guided breathing, yoga and tai chi be used to reduce blood pressure?: Recommendations based on high-quality systematic reviews.
指南 / 共识 · Complement Ther Med · 2018-10-26

本综述旨在对非药物疗法高质量系统评价中的证据质量和推荐强度进行评级,最终纳入13项系统评价,涉及14种非药物疗法。证据质量普遍较低,除按摩和针灸联合降压药外,多数疗法为弱推荐。基于分析证据,按摩和针灸联合降压药可能使希望降压且无禁忌证的患者获益。

要点

  • 证据质量普遍较低,多数非药物疗法为弱推荐。
  • 按摩和针灸联合降压药可能使无禁忌证患者获益。
  • 许多非药物疗法因系统评价方法学质量低而被排除。

核心结论

  • 除按摩和针灸联合降压药外,多数非药物疗法为弱推荐。
  • 按摩和针灸联合降压药可能使希望降压且无禁忌证的患者获益。

研究设计与样本

  • 纳入13项系统评价,涉及14种非药物疗法,采用GRADE标准评级证据质量。

主要发现

  • 证据质量普遍较低,弱推荐大多数疗法,仅按摩和针灸联合降压药例外。

关键数值与推荐

  • 采用GRADE标准,考虑6个因素(包括偏倚风险)评级证据质量。
  • 纳入的14种疗法包括针灸、湿罐、八段锦、放血、耳针、音乐、按摩、气功、艾灸、放松疗法、生物反馈、设备引导呼吸、瑜伽和太极。

临床怎么用

  • 对于希望降压且无禁忌证的患者,可考虑按摩或针灸联合降压药。

局限性

  • 许多非药物疗法因系统评价方法学质量低而被排除,仅评估了14种疗法。
  • 未评价患者重要结局,使用替代结局评级推荐强度。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: This review aims to rate the quality of evidence and the strength of recommendations in high-quality systematic reviews of non-drug therapies. Hypertensive patients who are resistant or non-adherent to antihypertensive drugs may be easier to manage if they choose alternative non-drug therapies for hypertension, based on this review. METHODS: P: Adults (>18 years), except pregnant women, with essential hypertension. I: Cupping, moxibustion, acupuncture, acupoint stimulation, yoga, meditation, tai chi, Qi gong, Chinese massage, massage, spinal manipulation, biofeedback, device-guided breathing therapy, aromatherapy, music therapy, and relaxation approaches. C: 1. No treatment. 2. Sham therapy. 3. Conventional treatment, including antihypertensive drugs and lifestyle modification (e.g., exercise). O: 1. Change in the incidence of cardiovascular death. 2. Change in the incidence of myocardial infarction. 3. Change in the incidence of stroke. 4. Change in blood pressure (BP). 5. Efficacy rate of BP lowering. 6. Adverse effects (review specific). S: Systematic reviews of randomized controlled trials, including meta-analyses and assessments of the methodological quality/risk of bias. INFORMATION SOURCES: Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, Database of Abstracts of Reviews of Effects, Cochrane library, PubMed, Web of Science, China National Knowledge Infrastructure, and Chinese Scientific Journal Database were searched. The bibliographies of the included articles were also searched for relevant systematic reviews. GRADE criteria were used to rate the quality of evidence in systematic reviews considering 6 factors, including risk of bias. RESULTS: This review ultimately included 13 systematic reviews of 14 non-drug therapies (acupuncture, wet cupping, Baduanjin, blood letting, auricular acupuncture, music, massage, Qi gong, moxibustion, relaxation therapies, biofeedback, device-guided breathing, yoga and tai chi) based on the inclusion criteria. The quality of evidence was generally low, and weak recommendations were given for most therapies except massage and acupuncture plus antihypertensive drug. Based on the analyzed evidence, massage and acupuncture plus antihypertensive drug could benefit people who want to lower their BP and do not have contraindications for massage and acupuncture plus antihypertensive drug. DISCUSSION/STRENGTH: The GRADE approach makes this review a unique reference for people who are considering the grade of quality of evidence in systematic reviews, the balance of desirable and undesirable consequences and the strength of recommendations to decide which intervention should be used to reduce BP. LIMITATIONS: Many non-drug therapies were excluded due to the low methodological quality of their systematic reviews, and only 14 therapies were evaluated in this review. As no patient-important outcomes were reviewed, surrogate outcomes were used to rate the strength of recommendations. This approach may cause a decrease in evidence quality according to GRADE, but we argue that this is appropriate in the context of this review.

来源:Complement Ther Med,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Niu JF, Zhao XF, Hu HT, et al. Should acupuncture, biofeedback, massage, Qi gong, relaxation therapy, device-guided breathing, yoga and tai chi be used to reduce blood pressure?: Recommendations based on high-quality systematic reviews. Complement Ther Med. 2018. PMID: 30670261. doi:10.1016/j.ctim.2018.10.017

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。