安慰针装置盲法可信度系统综述
该系统综述纳入15项健康受试者研究,评估Streitberger、Park与Takakura三种安慰针装置的盲法可信度、刺痛感与得气感。综合分析显示,在敏感穴位LI4上Streitberger与Park装置可能无法成功盲化受试者,且与真针刺在刺痛感上存在显著差异;Takakura装置是唯一可能盲化针灸师的装置,但各结局指标的盲法分析不一致。总体数据不足以确认这些皮肤接触式安慰针装置的盲法效果。
要点
- 在LI4穴位测试时,Streitberger与Park装置可能无法成功盲化受试者。
- Takakura装置是唯一可能盲化针灸师的安慰针装置。
- 现有数据不足以确认皮肤接触式安慰针装置的盲法效果。
核心结论
- 总体数据不足以确认这些皮肤接触式安慰针装置的盲法效果,每种装置均存在局限,需要进一步改进设计。
研究设计与样本
- 纳入研究比较真手针与Streitberger、Park或Takakura安慰针装置,评估盲法可信度、刺痛感或得气感。
主要发现
- 在敏感穴位LI4测试时,Streitberger与Park安慰针装置可能无法成功盲化受试者。
- 在LI4穴位上,Streitberger与Park装置与真针刺在刺痛感方面存在显著差异。
- Takakura装置是唯一可能盲化针灸师的安慰针装置,但所有结局指标的盲法分析不一致。
临床怎么用
- 选用安慰针装置时需考虑其盲法局限,尤其在LI4等敏感穴位测试时。
- 若研究需盲化针灸师,Takakura装置是现有装置中唯一可能的选择。
局限性
- 纳入研究仅针对健康受试者,结论外推至患者群体需谨慎。
- 各装置盲法分析结果不一致,且数据不足以确认盲法效果。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: An ideal placebo design in clinical research should resemble the intervention under investigation to facilitate blinding, yet remain clinically inert. With regard to physical interventions such as acupuncture, a true placebo device has not been developed and validated. Since 1998, researchers have designed several placebo acupuncture devices (PADs). The three most widely used PADs are the Streitberger, the Park and the Takakura device. AIM: This review focuses on evaluating studies of these devices, in the context of credibility of blinding (COB), assessment of penetrating pain or sensation, and de qi sensation. METHODS: Electronic database searches were conducted in four English and two Chinese databases from their inception until November 2016. All studies included in the review were conducted on healthy participants and compared verum manual acupuncture with any of the aforementioned PADs with respect to one or more of the above three outcomes related to blinding effect. RESULTS: The synthesised analyses of the 15 included studies showed that the Streitberger and Park placebo devices may not blind participants successfully when tested at a sensitive acupuncture point (LI4). In terms of penetrating sensation, there were significant differences between these two placebo devices and verum acupuncture when applied at this point. The Takakura device was the only PAD that had the potential to blind the acupuncturist. However, the blinding analyses of all outcome measures were inconsistent. CONCLUSION: Overall, there were insufficient data to confirm the blinding effects of these skin-contact PADs as each device was associated with limitations that warrant further design improvements.
引用
- Zhang GS, Zhang CS, Tan HY, et al. Systematic review of acupuncture placebo devices with a focus on the credibility of blinding of healthy participants and/or acupuncturists. Acupunct Med. 2018. PMID: 29669794. doi:10.1136/acupmed-2017-011484
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。