针灸治疗骨质疏松症的系统评价与Meta分析
Meta分析显示温针灸可提高腰椎和股骨骨密度、血清钙和雌二醇水平,缓解疼痛并降低血清碱性磷酸酶,电针和针刺也可缓解疼痛。结论提示针灸可能是治疗骨质疏松的有效疗法,温针灸似优于电针和针刺。
要点
- 温针灸较单纯西药可提高腰椎和股骨骨密度、血清钙及雌二醇水平。
- 温针灸、电针和针刺均可较单纯西药缓解骨质疏松疼痛。
- 温针灸在改善骨质疏松指标上似优于电针和针刺。
核心结论
- 针灸可能是治疗骨质疏松症的有效疗法。
- 与单纯西药相比,温针灸似比电针和针刺更有效。
研究设计与样本
- 系统评价与Meta分析,检索6个英文和4个中文数据库至2017年4月。
- 比较温针灸、针刺或电针与单纯西药治疗骨质疏松。
- 采用Cochrane协作网偏倚风险评估工具评价质量,RevMan 5.3进行Meta分析。
主要发现
- 温针灸较单纯西药提高腰椎骨密度(SMD 0.93,95%CI 0.65~1.21,P<0.00001)。
- 温针灸较单纯西药提高股骨骨密度(MD 0.11,95%CI 0.05~0.16,P=0.0002)。
- 温针灸较单纯西药提高血清钙(MD 0.18,95%CI 0.13~0.24,P<0.00001)和雌二醇(SMD 0.65,95%CI 0.32~0.98,P=0.0001)。
- 温针灸较单纯西药缓解疼痛(MD -1.64,95%CI -2.69~-0.59,P=0.002)并降低血清碱性磷酸酶(MD -7.8,95%CI -14.17~-0.84,P=0.03)。
- 电针较单纯西药缓解疼痛(MD -1.32,95%CI -2.15~-0.48,P=0.002)、提高血清钙(MD -0.12,95%CI -0.16~-0.09,P<0.00001)并降低血清碱性磷酸酶(MD -3.63,95%CI -6.60~-0.66,P=0.02);针刺较单纯西药缓解疼痛(MD -2.27,95%CI -3.11~-1.43,P<0.00001)。
临床怎么用
- 临床可考虑将温针灸作为骨质疏松的辅助治疗,尤其针对骨密度下降和疼痛。
- 电针和针刺可作为缓解骨质疏松疼痛的备选方案。
- 应用时需结合患者具体情况,并参考原始研究质量。
局限性
- 检索截止2017年4月,未纳入此后发表的研究。
- 纳入研究存在异质性,部分指标采用SMD合并。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
To summarize the existing evidence and evaluate the efficacy of acupuncture as a clinical treatment for osteoporosis. Six English and four Chinese databases were searched from their inception to April 2017. Randomized controlled trials were included, in which warm acupuncture, needling or electroacupuncture were compared with sole Western medicine with osteoporosis. All the data were assessed and extracted by two authors independently. The bias risk assessment recommended by the Cochrane Collaboration's tool was used to assess the quality of the selected studies. This meta-analysis was conducted by using RevMan 5.3. Pooled analyses were calculated by standardized mean difference (SMD) and 95% confidence interval (CI). Heterogeneity was assessed by I2 test. Thirty-five studies involving 3014 patients were located. Meta-analysis showed that warm acupuncture could increase the bone mineral density of lumar (SMD [Formula: see text] 0.93, 95% CI [Formula: see text] 0.65, 1.21, [Formula: see text][Formula: see text]0.00001) and femur (MD[Formula: see text][Formula: see text][Formula: see text]0.11, 95% CI[Formula: see text][Formula: see text][Formula: see text]0.05, 0.16, P[Formula: see text][Formula: see text][Formula: see text]0.0002), the level of serum calcium (MD[Formula: see text][Formula: see text][Formula: see text]0.18, 95% CI[Formula: see text][Formula: see text][Formula: see text]0.13, 0.24, [Formula: see text][Formula: see text]0.00001) and estradiol (SMD[Formula: see text][Formula: see text][Formula: see text]0.65, 95% CI[Formula: see text][Formula: see text][Formula: see text]0.32, 0.98, P[Formula: see text][Formula: see text][Formula: see text]0.0001), relieve pain (MD[Formula: see text][Formula: see text][Formula: see text]-1.64, 95% CI[Formula: see text][Formula: see text][Formula: see text]-2.69, -0.59, P[Formula: see text][Formula: see text][Formula: see text]0.002), decrease the level of serum alkaline phosphatase (MD[Formula: see text][Formula: see text][Formula: see text]-7.8, 95% CI[Formula: see text][Formula: see text][Formula: see text]-14.17, -0.84, P [Formula: see text] 0.03) compared with sole Western medicine. Electroacupuncture could relieve pain (MD[Formula: see text][Formula: see text] -1.32, 95% CI[Formula: see text][Formula: see text][Formula: see text]-2.15, -0.48, P[Formula: see text][Formula: see text][Formula: see text]0.002), increase the level of serum calcium (MD[Formula: see text][Formula: see text][Formula: see text]-0.12, 95% CI [Formula: see text] -0.16,-0.09, [Formula: see text][Formula: see text]0.00001) and decrease the level of serum alkaline phosphatase (MD [Formula: see text] -3.63, 95% CI [Formula: see text] -6.60, -0.66, P [Formula: see text] 0.02) compared with sole Western medicine. Needling could relieve pain (MD [Formula: see text] -2.27, 95% CI [Formula: see text] -3.11, -1.43, [Formula: see text][Formula: see text]0.00001) compared with sole Western medicine. This present systematic review indicated that acupuncture could be an effective therapy for treating osteoporosis. Warm acupuncture seemed to more effective than electroacupuncture and needling for osteoporosis in comparison to sole Western medicine.
引用
- Pan H, Jin R, Li M, et al. The Effectiveness of Acupuncture for Osteoporosis: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. Am J Chin Med. 2018. PMID: 29614884. doi:10.1142/S0192415X18500258
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。