PC6穴位针刺的副作用类型与频率:来自临床疗效试验的观察
该研究纳入221名接受PC6针刺的受试者,共1298次治疗,数据来自两项随机对照试验。结果显示无严重并发症,治疗中轻微出血5.0%、疲劳4.9%、麻木4.5%、头晕1.4%;治疗后每周平均疲劳25.8%、感觉冷17.8%等。近90%受试者认为针刺无痛或仅轻度疼痛。
要点
- PC6针刺无严重并发症,副作用轻微。
- 治疗中轻微出血、疲劳、麻木、头晕发生率低。
- 近90%受试者认为针刺无痛或仅轻度疼痛。
核心结论
- PC6针刺副作用少且轻微,无严重并发症。
- 近90%受试者认为针刺无痛或仅轻度疼痛。
研究设计与样本
- 研究纳入221名参与者(77%女性,平均年龄52.5岁,范围18-91岁),共1298次PC6针刺治疗。
- 数据来自两项先前随机对照试验,分别旨在诱导止吐(n=100)或放松(n=121)效果。
- 副作用通过结构化治疗记录和研究日记登记。
主要发现
- 治疗中副作用:轻微出血5.0%、疲劳4.9%、麻木4.5%、头晕1.4%(基于1298次治疗)。
- 治疗后每周平均报告副作用比例:疲劳25.8%、感觉冷17.8%、头晕9.7%、出汗9.3%、血肿8.8%、针刺部位酸痛4.3%。
- 针刺疼痛感知:47.4%无痛、39.1%轻度、11.6%中度、1.4%非常疼痛。
临床怎么用
- 医护人员可参考这些副作用发生率向患者说明PC6针刺的副作用。
- PC6针刺副作用轻微,可用于共享决策。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Many therapists practise PC6 acupuncture for emesis (nausea and vomiting) during pregnancy, different cancer therapies, palliative care, after surgery, or to induce relaxing effects in general. Knowledge of side effects is central to shared decision-making. AIM: To describe the type and frequency of side effects and the level of needle-induced pain during PC6 acupuncture. METHODS: We included 1298 PC6 acupuncture treatments, delivered to 221 participants (77% women, mean age 52.5, range 18-91 years). The subjects had received genuine PC6 acupuncture, in one of two previous randomised controlled trials, aimed at inducing antiemetic (n=100, with 100 providing data on side effects and 94 on needle-induced pain, respectively) or relaxing (n=121, with 120 providing data) effects. Side effects during and after the acupuncture treatments were registered in structured treatment protocols and study diaries. RESULTS: No serious complications occurred. Side effects during the acupuncture sessions included minor bleeding in 5.0%, tiredness in 4.9%, numbness in 4.5% and dizziness in 1.4% of the 1298 treatments. After treatment, the mean proportions of participants reporting side effects each week were: tiredness 25.8%; feeling cold 17.8%; dizziness 9.7%; sweating 9.3%; haematoma 8.8%; and soreness at the needling sites 4.3%. Participants perceived the needling to be not painful (47.4% of participants), or mildly (39.1%), moderately (11.6%) or very painful (1.4%). CONCLUSIONS: Few side effects occurred and those that did were mild. Nearly 90% found PC6 acupuncture to be not painful or only mildly painful. Healthcare professionals may consider the observed levels of side effects when informing patients about side effects of PC6 acupuncture.
引用
- Enblom A, Johnsson A. Type and frequency of side effects during PC6 acupuncture: observations from therapists and patients participating in clinical efficacy trials of acupuncture. Acupunct Med. 2017. PMID: 29222203. doi:10.1136/acupmed-2016-011270
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。