牙科补充与替代疗法的使用及推荐者特征
该研究对德国执业牙医开展前瞻性匿名横断面调查(n=250,男55%、女45%,平均年龄49.1±11.4岁),分析其在临床中提供或推荐补充与替代医学(CAM)疗法的情况及对疗效的评价,并描绘推荐者特征。结果显示植物提取物、放松疗法、顺势疗法等被较多整合,CAM支持者对疗效评分显著高于反对者,支持者多为女性且工作投入与自我效能更高。
要点
- 德国牙医常推荐植物提取物、放松疗法与顺势疗法等CAM疗法。
- CAM支持者对特定疗法疗效评分显著高于反对者(p<0.0001)。
- 支持者多为女性,经验年限更长、工作投入与自我效能更高。
核心结论
- 多种CAM疗法被德国牙医推荐且患者有需求,但其科学证据常较低或至少不明确。
- CAM支持者多为女性,自我效能期望与工作投入更高。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性、探索性、匿名横断面调查,通过会议、牙科期刊及网络发放给德国执业牙医,n=250,男55%、女45%,平均年龄49.1±11.4岁。
主要发现
- 31种预设CAM疗法中,牙医整合了山金车(64%)、洋甘菊(64%)、丁香(63%)、鼠尾草(54%)植物提取物,以及放松疗法(62%)、顺势疗法(57%)、骨病医学(50%)和饮食疗法(50%)。
- CAM支持者对特定治疗疗效评分显著高于反对者(p<0.0001);反对者也把耳针、骨病医学和丁香评为高效,耳针评分两组无显著差异。
- 支持者平均年龄(50.4±0.9 vs 47.0±0.9岁)与从业年限(24.2±1.0 vs 20.0±1.0年)显著高于反对者(p<0.0001)。
- 支持者工作更少(p<0.0001)、感知工作量更低(p=0.008),自我效能期望(p≤0.01)与工作投入(p<0.0001)显著更高。
- 逻辑回归探索性显示,CAM支持与UWES奉献子量表、从业年限呈正关联,男性较女性更不可能成为CAM支持者。
关键数值与推荐
- 31种预设CAM疗法;山金车64%、洋甘菊64%、丁香63%、鼠尾草54%、放松疗法62%、顺势疗法57%、骨病医学50%、饮食疗法50%。
- 疗效评分组间差异p<0.0001;年龄与从业年限组间差异p<0.0001;工作量p=0.008;SEE p≤0.01;UWE p<0.0001。
临床怎么用
- 牙医在临床中可接触患者对CAM的需求,但应知晓多数CAM疗法科学证据较低或不清楚。
- 对耳针、骨病医学和丁香等被双方均评为高效的疗法,仍需结合证据谨慎沟通与使用。
局限性
- 为探索性横断面调查,仅限德国执业牙医,样本量250,结果不能直接推断因果或推广至其他地区。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: The aims of this study were to analyse whether dentists offer or recommend complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) remedies in their clinical routine, and how effective these are rated by proponents and opponents. A second aim of this study was to give a profile of the dentists endorsing CAM. DESIGN: A prospective, explorative, anonymised cross-sectional survey was spread among practicing dentists in Germany via congresses, dental periodicals and online (n=250, 55% male, 45% female; mean age 49.1±11.4years). RESULTS: Of a set of 31 predefined CAM modalities, the dentists integrated plant extracts from Arnica montana (64%), chamomile (64%), clove (63%), Salvia officinalis (54%), but also relaxation therapies (62%), homeopathy (57%), osteopathic medicine (50%) and dietetics (50%). The effectiveness of specific treatments was rated significantly higher (p<0.0001) by CAM proponents than opponents. However also CAM opponents classified some CAM remedies as highly effective, namely ear acupuncture, osteopathic medicine and clove. For ear acupuncture these scores did not significantly differ between both groups. With respect to the characteristic of the proponents, the majority of CAM endorsing dentists were women. The mean age (50.4±0.9 vs 47.0±0.9years) and number of years of professional experience (24.2±1.0 vs 20.0±1.0years) were significantly higher for CAM proponents than the means for opponents (p<0.0001 respectively). CAM proponents worked significantly less (p<0.0001) and their perceived workload was significantly lower (p=0.008). Their self-efficacy expectation (SEE) and work engagement (Utrecht work engagement, UWE) were significantly higher (p≤0.01 and p<0.0001) compared to dentists who abandoned these treatment options. The logistic regression model showed (exploratively) an increased association from CAM proponents with the UWES subscale dedication, with years of experience, and that men are less likely to be CAM proponents than women. CONCLUSION: Various CAM treatments are recommended by German dentists and requested by their patients, but the scientific evidence for these treatments are often low or at least unclear. CAM proponents are often female, have higher SE and work engagement.
引用
- Baatsch B, Zimmer S, Rodrigues Recchia D, et al. Complementary and alternative therapies in dentistry and characteristics of dentists who recommend them. Complement Ther Med. 2017. PMID: 29154070. doi:10.1016/j.ctim.2017.08.008
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。