针灸、假针灸或标准护理对放化疗患者呕吐的影响:一项随机对照研究
结果显示真针灸组较假针灸组抗呕吐药使用更少(47% vs 85%,p=0.019,RR 1.81,CI 1.06-3.09),且恶心程度更低(p=0.049);但研究样本量小,多项分析统计效能不足。
要点
- 真针灸组抗呕吐药使用比例(47%)显著低于假针灸组(85%)。
- 真针灸组恶心程度评分显著低于其他组(p=0.049)。
- 假针灸或标准护理组恶心发生率有高于真针灸组趋势(68% vs 53%,p=0.074)。
核心结论
- 接受真针灸的患者较假针灸或标准护理患者需要更少的抗呕吐药,且恶心程度更轻。
主要发现
- 假针灸组抗呕吐药使用比例85%(17/20)显著高于真针灸组47%(8/17),p=0.019,RR 1.81,CI 1.06-3.09。
- 标准护理组抗呕吐药使用比例为63%(7/11)。
- 真针灸组恶心程度显著低于其他患者(p=0.049)。
- 假针灸或标准护理组恶心发生率68%(21/31)有高于真针灸组53%(9/17)的趋势,p=0.074,RR 1.58,CI 0.91-2.74。
临床怎么用
- 在盆腔放疗同步化疗期间,可考虑将针灸作为辅助措施以减少抗呕吐药需求和减轻恶心。
局限性
- 研究样本量小,许多分析缺乏统计效能以检测差异。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To study nausea, vomiting and need for rescue antiemetics in patients receiving antiemetic acupuncture, sham acupuncture or standard care during concomitant chemotherapy during pelvic radiotherapy. METHODS: In total, 68 patients participated (75% women, mean age 56 years, 53% had gynecological, 43% colorectal, and 4% other cancer types). Fifty-seven of them were blinded randomized to verum (n=28) or sham (n=29) acupuncture, median 10 sessions. During the study period of four weeks, the patients daily registered their nausea, vomiting and consumption of antiemetics. They were compared to a reference group (n=11) receiving standard care only, who delivered these data once (after receiving mean 27Gy radiotherapy dose). RESULTS: More patients in the sham acupuncture group (17 of 20; 85%, p=0.019, RR 1.81, CI 1.06-3.09) consumed antiemetics, compared to the verum acupuncture group (8 of 17; 47%). In the standard care group, 7 of 11 (63%) consumed antiemetics. The verum acupuncture treated patients experienced lower intensity of nausea than the other patients (p=0.049). There was a non-significant tendency that more patients receiving either sham acupuncture or standard care experienced nausea (21 of 31; 68%) than patients receiving verum acupuncture (9 of 17; 53%: p=0.074, RR 1.58, CI 0.91-2.74). CONCLUSION: Patients treated with verum acupuncture needed less antiemetics and experienced milder nausea than other patients. Our study was small and many analyses lacked statistical power to detect differences; we welcome further sham-controlled efficacy studies and studies regarding the role of non-specific treatment components for experiencing antiemetic effects of acupuncture.
引用
- Widgren Y, Enblom A. Emesis in patients receiving acupuncture, sham acupuncture or standard care during chemo-radiation: A randomized controlled study. Complement Ther Med. 2017. PMID: 28917369. doi:10.1016/j.ctim.2017.07.003
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。