传统印度医学与传统韩医学:基于体质概念的比较
本文通过同行评议文献、政府机构报告和世界卫生组织报告,比较传统印度医学(TIM)与传统韩医学(TKM)的异同。两者均基于体质概念和相似的诊断方法(听诊、触诊、视诊、问诊),治疗均涉及草药、艾灸、针灸、拔罐和手法治疗,但TKM因广泛的国家保险覆盖而更普及,TIM(尤其阿育吠陀)全球认可度更高。
要点
- TIM与TKM均以体质概念为核心,诊断方法相似,治疗手段重叠。
- TKM因广泛的国家保险覆盖而更普及,TIM保险覆盖较少。
- TIM(尤其阿育吠陀)全球认可度更高,TKM的体质医学正兴起。
核心结论
- TIM与TKM虽起源历史不同,但共享体质概念、诊断方法和治疗模式,TKM的普及得益于国家保险覆盖,TIM全球认可度更高。
研究设计与样本
- 比较研究,数据来源于同行评议文章、各自政府机构报告和世界卫生组织报告。
主要发现
- 除顺势疗法外,TIM与TKM均基于体质概念,诊断主要采用听诊、触诊、视诊和问诊。
- 治疗均使用草药、艾灸、针灸、拔罐和手法治疗。
- TKM医生平均接受6-7年专业培训,在完善医院执业,且国家保险覆盖广泛。
- TIM保险覆盖较少,但阿育吠陀全球认可度高于TKM,TKM的体质医学(Sasang)正逐渐流行。
临床怎么用
- 可借鉴TIM与TKM的体质概念和诊断方法,丰富中医体质辨识与诊疗思路。
- 关注TKM的保险覆盖模式对中医服务推广的启示。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Traditional and complementary medicine (T&CM) plays an integral role in providing health care worldwide. It is based on sound fundamental principles and centuries of practices. This study compared traditional Indian medicine (TIM) and traditional Korean medicine (TKM) basing on data obtained from peer reviewed articles, respective government institutional reports and World Health Organization reports. Despite the fact that TIM and TKM have individual qualities that are unique from each other including different histories of origin, they share a lot in common. Apart from Homeopathy in TIM, both systems are hinged on similar principle of body constitutional-based concept and similar disease diagnosis methods of mainly auscultation, palpation, visual inspection, and interrogation. Similarly, the treatment methods of TIM and TKM follow similar patterns involving use of medicinal herbs, moxibustion, acupuncture, cupping, and manual therapy. Both T&CM are majorly practiced in well-established hospitals by T&CM doctors who have undergone an average of 6-7 years of specialized trainings. However, unlike TIM which has less insurance coverage, the popularity of TKM is majorly due to its wide national insurance coverage. These two medical traditions occupy increasingly greater portion of the global market. However, TIM especially Ayurveda has gained more global recognition than TKM although the emergence of Sasang Constitutional Medicine in TKM is beginning to become more popular. This comparative analysis between TIM and TKM may provide vital and insightful contribution towards constitutional-based concept for further development and future studies in T&CM.
引用
- Kang YM, Komakech R, Karigar CS, et al. Traditional Indian medicine (TIM) and traditional Korean medicine (TKM): aconstitutional-based concept and comparison. Integr Med Res. 2017. PMID: 28664134. doi:10.1016/j.imr.2016.12.003
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。