针灸临床实践指南与技术操作规范的方法学质量评价:AGREE II与STAR工具评估
指南在AGREE II多数领域得分中等,STAR总体得分64.4%;技术操作规范各领域得分普遍偏低,STAR总体仅15.3%。提示现有评价工具可能无法充分反映中医技术文档特色,需开发针对性评价工具。
要点
- 针灸临床实践指南方法学质量中等,技术操作规范质量普遍偏低。
- AGREE II与STAR可能不适用于评价中医技术操作规范的独特性。
- 未来需开发中医特异性评价工具并促进指南实施。
核心结论
- 针灸临床实践指南方法学质量总体为中等水平,而技术操作规范在多个领域得分持续偏低,有较大改进空间。
- 常用评价工具AGREE II和STAR可能无法充分捕捉中医技术文档的独特特征,未来应开发中医特异性评价工具并改善实施。
主要发现
- AGREE II评价显示,29部指南在6个领域中的4个领域得分超过50%,而仅7部技术操作规范达到该标准。
- STAR评价显示,指南的总体得分为64.4%,技术操作规范的总体得分为15.3%。
临床怎么用
- 临床选用针灸指南或技术操作规范时,应关注其方法学质量,优先参考AGREE II和STAR评价较高的文档。
- 对技术操作规范的低质量现状需保持警惕,使用时应结合临床经验审慎判断。
局限性
- 原文未报告评价者间一致性、具体领域得分细节及检索策略的局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The methodological quality of current acupuncture and moxibustion clinical practice guidelines and technical operation norms remain unclear. Given their potential impact on clinical decision-making and health policy, this study aimed to evaluate their quality using the AGREE II and STAR tools, and to explore the need for a tailored appraisal tool for Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM) technical operation norms. METHODS: A methodological evaluation was conducted using standardized appraisal instruments. A systematic search across 14 databases identified guidelines and norms related to acupuncture and moxibustion published up to December 31, 2025. Two independent reviewers assessed the included documents using Appraisal of Guidelines for Research and Evaluation II (AGREE II) and Scientific, Transparent, Applicable Rating (STAR) tools. RESULTS: Seventy-six publications were included: 31 clinical practice guidelines and 45 technical operation norms. AGREE II results showed that 29 guidelines scored >50% in 4 out of 6 domains, while 7 norms met the criterion. STAR evaluation showed an overall score of 64.4% for guidelines versus 15.3% for norms. CONCLUSIONS: This study found that acupuncture and moxibustion clinical practice guidelines generally demonstrate moderate methodological quality, whereas technical operation norms consistently show low scores across multiple domains, indicating substantial room for improvement. These findings also suggest that commonly used appraisal tools, such as AGREE II and STAR, may not fully capture the unique characteristics of TCM technical documents. Future work should develop TCM-specific appraisal tools and improve implementation.
引用
- Loh PY, Ba D, Zhao X, et al. Methodological quality of clinical practice guidelines and technical operation norms in acupuncture and moxibustion: Evaluation using AGREE II and STAR. Integr Med Res. 2026. PMID: 42500458. doi:10.1016/j.imr.2026.101307
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。