何首乌炮制减毒的化学计量学与药理学评价
该研究以斑马鱼模型比较生何首乌与黑豆汁九蒸九晒品的肝毒性与功效差异,结合HPLC指纹图谱、谱效关系与网络药理学,验证「生首乌泻下、制首乌补益」的传统认识,并识别蒽醌类成分与ESR1等靶点。
要点
- 生何首乌肝毒性与致泻作用明显,九蒸九晒后减弱并转为补血、增强免疫。
- 大黄素、大黄素甲醚及其苷类与肝毒性和泻下相关,TSG与大黄素与补益相关。
- 炮制降低结合蒽醌含量,调控靶点由毒性网络转向补益网络。
核心结论
- 生何首乌肝毒性与泻下作用突出,黑豆汁炮制后可减毒并增强补血与免疫功效。
- 炮制降低结合蒽醌含量,使调控靶点由毒性网络转向补益网络,为「生泻制补」提供现代证据。
研究设计与样本
- 采用HPLC建立生何首乌及三蒸三晒、六蒸六晒、九蒸九晒品的化学指纹图谱。
- 用斑马鱼肝损伤、肠推进、贫血、免疫抑制模型比较不同炮制次数样品的肝毒性与功效,每组10尾幼鱼,采用单因素方差分析及Tukey事后检验。
- 以灰色关联分析结合熵权法构建谱效关系,并用网络药理学与分子对接预测和验证靶点与机制。
主要发现
- 与对照组相比,生何首乌使肝脏面积与体侧面积比(LA/BA)降低29%、肝细胞凋亡增加72.5%,H&E见肝细胞肿胀、空泡变性及灶性坏死。
- 九蒸九晒品未见凋亡显著增加,LA/BA升高15.5%;生首乌使胃肠平均荧光强度(GI FI)降低31.2%,九蒸九晒品仅降低5.7%。
- 九蒸九晒品使红细胞染色强度增加203%、巨噬细胞数增加82.5%,明显优于生首乌。
- 谱效分析显示峰5(EmG)、峰7(Emo)、峰6(PhG)、峰8(Phys)与肝毒性和泻下密切相关,峰4(TSG)与峰7(Emo)与补益作用相关性更强。
- 网络药理学识别28个与何首乌肝损伤相关的共同靶点,PPI分析以ESR1为枢纽靶点,KEGG富集于PI3K-Akt、MAPK和雌激素信号通路;分子对接显示EmG与ESR1、EGFR等核心靶点结合能<-7.0 kcal/mol。
关键数值与推荐
- 活性验证显示Emo、Phys及其苷类有不同程度肝毒性,Emo与Phys有明显泻下作用,TSG与Emo有明显补血活性。
- 生何首乌使LA/BA降低29%、凋亡增加72.5%、GI FI降低31.2%;九蒸九晒品LA/BA升高15.5%、GI FI仅降低5.7%、红细胞染色强度增加203%、巨噬细胞数增加82.5%。
- 分子对接结合能阈值为<-7.0 kcal/mol。
临床怎么用
- 提示临床使用何首乌应重视炮制,生品偏泻下且肝毒性风险较高,补益宜用九蒸九晒制品。
- 对需长期服用何首乌者应关注肝功能,并可将炮制程度作为减毒增效的考量因素。
- 大黄素、大黄素甲醚及其苷类、TSG等成分可作为质量与安全性评价的潜在指标。
局限性
- 研究主要基于斑马鱼模型,尚需哺乳动物与临床研究验证。
- 谱效关系与网络药理学结果为相关性预测,机制仍需实验确证。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
ETHNOPHARMACOLOGICAL RELEVANCE: Polygonum multiflorum (P. multiflorum) is the dried root tuber of P. multiflorum Thunb., a perennial herbaceous plant belonging to the Polygonaceae family. Traditionally, it is believed to possess effects such as nourishing blood, replenishing yin, and moistening the intestines to relieve constipation. Research indicates that the processing procedure significantly alters the chemical composition, pharmacological activity, and hepatotoxicity of substances; however, the underlying mechanisms responsible for attenuating toxicity and enhancing efficacy remain to be clarified. Traditional experience suggests that with an increase in the number of processing cycles (e.g., nine-time processing), their properties shift from purgative to tonic, yet a systematic comparison of the specific differences among samples subjected to varying processing cycles is still lacking. AIM OF THE STUDY: Based on the central hypothesis that processing alters the chemical composition profile of P. multiflorum and thereby synergistically regulates its toxicity and efficacy, this study established the fingerprint profiles of samples subjected to different processing cycles (0, 3, 6, and 9 times). It systematically compared the hepatotoxicity and efficacy differences between the raw product and its processed products, and focused on identifying the key bioactive components and potential mechanisms responsible for the distinct toxicity and efficacy between the raw product and the nine-steamed-nine-dried product (9x-P. multiflorum) using spectrum-effect relationship analysis. MATERIALS AND METHODS: High-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) was first employed to establish the chemical fingerprints of the raw P. multiflorum and its processed products after 3, 6, and 9 cycles of steaming with black bean juice (three-steamed-three-dried product, 3x-P. multiflorum; six-steamed-six-dried product, 6x-P. multiflorum; 9x-P. multiflorum), to characterize the dynamic changes in chemical constituents during processing. Zebrafish models of liver injury, intestinal peristalsis, anemia, and immunosuppression were used to systematically compare the hepatotoxicity and efficacy of samples with different processing cycles, with a focus on the toxicity-efficacy shift between raw P. multiflorum (0 cycles) and 9x-P. multiflorum. Hematoxylin and eosin (H&E) staining was performed to observe histopathological changes and evaluate liver injury. Each group contained 10 zebrafish larvae, and data were statistically analyzed using one-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) followed by Tukey's post hoc test. Furthermore, a spectrum-effect relationship model was constructed using grey relational analysis (GRA) combined with the entropy weight method (EWM), to correlate common chemical constituents with hepatotoxicity and efficacy indicators. Finally, network pharmacology and molecular docking were integrated to systematically predict and verify the targets and molecular mechanisms of the screened potential active components, especially those that differed significantly between raw P. multiflorum and 9x-P. multiflorum. RESULTS: Compared with the control group, raw P. multiflorum significantly decreased the liver area-to-lateral body area ratio (LA/BA) by 29% and increased hepatocyte apoptosis by 72.5%, indicating marked hepatotoxicity. H&E staining revealed hepatocyte swelling, vacuolar degeneration, and focal necrosis. In contrast, 9x-P. multiflorum caused no significant increase in apoptosis and increased the LA/BA by 15.5%. Raw P. multiflorum exerted a strong pro-peristaltic effect, reducing the mean gastrointestinal fluorescence intensity (GI FI) by 31.2%, whereas 9x-P. multiflorum decreased it by only 5.7%. For tonic effects, 9x-P. multiflorum increased red blood cell staining intensity by 203% and macrophage count by 82.5%, which was significantly superior to raw P. multiflorum. Spectrum-effect analysis showed that Peak 5 (emodin-8-O-glucoside, EmG), Peak 7 (emodin, Emo), Peak 6 (physcion-8-O-β-D-glucoside, PhG), and Peak 8 (physcion, Phys) were closely correlated with hepatotoxicity and purgative activity. Peak 4 (2,3,5,4'-tetrahydroxystilbene-2-O-β-D-glucoside, TSG) and Peak 7 (Emo) exhibited stronger correlations with tonic effects. Activity validation confirmed that Emo, Phys, and their glucosides showed varying degrees of hepatotoxicity; Emo and Phys displayed significant purgative effects; while TSG and Emo exerted obvious blood-tonifying activity, verifying the reliability of the spectrum-effect analysis. Network pharmacology identified 28 common targets associated with P. multiflorum-induced liver injury, and protein-protein interaction (PPI) network analysis recognized Estrogen Receptor 1 (ESR1) as a hub target. Kyoto Encyclopedia of Genes and Genomes (KEGG) enrichment revealed significant enrichment in the PI3K-Akt, mitogen-activated protein kinase (MAPK), and estrogen signaling pathways. Molecular docking confirmed that EmG binds strongly to core targets including ESR1 and epidermal growth factor receptor (EGFR) (binding energy < -7.0 kcal/mol). CONCLUSIONS: This study verified the central hypothesis: raw P. multiflorum exhibits prominent hepatotoxicity and purgative effects, whereas processing with black bean juice achieves detoxification and enhances blood-tonifying and immune-enhancing efficacy. Emo, Phys, and their glycosides are the main material basis for hepatotoxicity and purgation, while TSG and Emo mediate the tonic effects. Network pharmacology and molecular docking further revealed that conjugated anthraquinones may synergistically disrupt liver-protective pathways via multiple targets such as ESR1 and EGFR. Processing reduces conjugated anthraquinone content and rewires the regulatory targets from a toxicity network toward a tonic network. These findings provide modern scientific evidence for the traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) theory that "raw P. multiflorum purges while processed P. multiflorum tonifies", and demonstrate the value of integrating spectrum-effect-toxicity correlation with network pharmacology in the mechanistic study of Chinese herbal medicine processing.
引用
- Zhang MY, Yue GY, Hao LJ, et al. Integrated chemometric and pharmacological evaluation of processing-induced attenuation of hepatotoxicity in Polygonum multiflorum. J Ethnopharmacol. 2026. PMID: 41935648. doi:10.1016/j.jep.2026.121622
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。