文献速递针灸推拿

插入式假针刺的特异效应对针刺疗效估计的影响:一项系统调查

Specific effect of inserted sham acupuncture and its impact on the estimation of acupuncture treatment effect in randomized controlled trials: A systematic survey.
PubMed 文献 · J Integr Med · 2025-07-30

该系统调查纳入32项随机对照试验共5492例患者,评估插入式假针刺的特异效应大小及其对针刺疗效估计的影响。结果显示,假针刺插入特异效应占针刺总效应的18.90%,若控制该效应,45.45%的纳入RCT和40.91%的外部验证RCT的针刺疗效从无统计学差异变为有统计学差异。提示使用插入式假针刺作为安慰剂需谨慎。

要点

  • 插入式假针刺特异效应占针刺总效应的18.90%,显著影响疗效评估。
  • 控制该效应后,超过40%的RCT结论发生改变。
  • 使用插入式假针刺安慰剂时需谨慎解读针刺疗效。

核心结论

  • 插入式假针刺的特异效应占针刺总效应的18.90%,显著影响针刺治疗效果的评估。
  • 若控制该特异效应,超过40%的RCT会得出不同结论。
  • 在RCT中使用插入式假针刺作为安慰剂时应谨慎。

研究设计与样本

  • 纳入比较针刺与假针刺及无治疗的RCT,共纳入32项研究、5492例患者。
  • 采用随机效应模型Meta分析汇总比例,并进行外部验证。

主要发现

  • 自然病程和/或回归均值效应(PNE)占针刺总效应的0.335(95%CI 0.255-0.415)。
  • 针刺情境效应(PCE)占针刺总效应的0.639(95%CI 0.567-0.710)。
  • 安慰剂效应占针刺总效应的比例为0.191,插入式假针刺特异效应(PIES)为0.189。
  • 排除插入式假针刺特异效应后,45.45%的纳入RCT和40.91%的外部验证RCT的针刺疗效从无统计学差异变为有统计学差异。

关键数值与推荐

  • 针刺总效应设为1,PNE为0.335(95%CI 0.255-0.415),PCE为0.639(95%CI 0.567-0.710)。
  • 安慰剂效应比例为0.191,PIES为0.189(即18.90%)。
  • 控制PIES后,45.45%的纳入RCT和40.91%的外部验证RCT结论改变。

临床怎么用

  • 在解读使用插入式假针刺的RCT结果时,应考虑其特异效应可能低估针刺疗效。
  • 设计针刺RCT时,需谨慎选择假针刺对照,并考虑插入特异效应的影响。
  • 临床决策参考针刺证据时,应关注假针刺对照类型及其潜在偏倚。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: The use of inserted sham acupuncture as a placebo in randomized controlled trials (RCTs) is controversial, because it may produce specific effects that cause an underestimation of the effect of acupuncture treatment. OBJECTIVE: This systematic survey investigates the magnitude of insert-specific effects of sham acupuncture and whether they affect the estimation of acupuncture treatment effects. SEARCH STRATEGY: PubMed, Embase and Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials were searched to identify acupuncture RCTs from their inception until December 2022. INCLUSION CRITERIA: RCTs that evaluated the effects of acupuncture compared to sham acupuncture and no treatment. DATA EXTRACTION AND ANALYSIS: The total effect measured for an acupuncture treatment group in RCTs were divided into three components, including the natural history and/or regression to the mean effect (controlled for no-treatment group), the placebo effect, and the specific effect of acupuncture. The first two constituted the contextual effect of acupuncture, which is mimicked by a sham acupuncture treatment group. The proportion of acupuncture total effect size was considered to be 1. The proportion of natural history and/or regression to the mean effect (PNE) and proportional contextual effect (PCE) of included RCTs were pooled using meta-analyses with a random-effect model. The proportion of acupuncture placebo effect was the difference between PCE and PNE in RCTs with non-inserted sham acupuncture. The proportion of insert-specific effect of sham acupuncture (PIES) was obtained by subtracting the proportion of acupuncture placebo effect and PNE from PCE in RCTs with inserted sham acupuncture. The impact of PIES on the estimation of acupuncture's treatment effect was evaluated by quantifying the percentage of RCTs that the effect of outcome changed from no statistical difference to statistical difference after removing PIES in the included studies, and the impact of PIES was externally validated in other acupuncture RCTs with an inserted sham acupuncture group that were not used to calculate PIES. RESULTS: This analysis included 32 studies with 5492 patients. The overall PNE was 0.335 (95% confidence interval [CI], 0.255-0.415) and the PCE of acupuncture was 0.639 (95% CI, 0.567-0.710) of acupuncture's total effect. The proportional contribution of the placebo effect to acupuncture's total effect was 0.191, and the PIES was 0.189. When we modeled the exclusion of the insert-specific effect of sham acupuncture, the acupuncture treatment effect changed from no difference to a significant difference in 45.45% of the included RCTs, and in 40.91% of the external validated RCTs. CONCLUSION: The insert-specific effect of sham acupuncture in RCTs represents 18.90% of acupuncture's total effect and significantly affects the evaluation of the acupuncture treatment effect. More than 40% of RCTs that used inserted sham acupuncture would draw different conclusions if the PIES had been controlled for. Considering the impact of the insert-specific effect of sham acupuncture, caution should be taken when using inserted sham acupuncture placebos in RCTs. Please cite this article as: Luo XC, Liu JL, Yao MH, Chen YM, Fan AY, Liang FR, Zhao JP, Zhao L, Zhou X, Zhong XY, Yang JH, Li B, Zhang Y, Sun X, Li L. Specific effect of inserted sham acupuncture and its impact on the estimation of acupuncture treatment effect in randomized controlled trials: A systematic survey. J Integr Med. 2025; 23(6):630-640.

来源:J Integr Med,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Luo XC, Liu JL, Yao MH, et al. Specific effect of inserted sham acupuncture and its impact on the estimation of acupuncture treatment effect in randomized controlled trials: A systematic survey. J Integr Med. 2025. PMID: 40796482. doi:10.1016/j.joim.2025.07.011

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。