文献速递中医骨伤中医康复针灸推拿

中药膏摩、推拿及联合针刺治疗膝骨关节炎的24个月多中心真实世界研究:长期症状复发与功能结局

Long-term symptom recurrence and functional outcomes with Chinese ointment massage, Tuina, and combined acupuncture for knee osteoarthritis: A 24-month multicenter real-world study in China.
PubMed 文献 · Complement Ther Med · 2025-08-06

多中心前瞻性真实世界研究纳入2143例膝骨关节炎患者,按偏好分入中药膏摩、推拿、膏摩+针刺或推拿+针刺组,治疗5-10次。各组治疗后WOMAC、VAS、Lequesne评分均显著下降;2年总体最高复发率33.97%,18个月后趋稳。KL II级患者长期结局最佳,无严重不良事件。

要点

  • 中药膏摩组2-10个月VAS评分最低,早期疼痛改善最优。
  • 2年复发率由低到高:膏摩组、推拿组、推拿+针刺组、膏摩+针刺组。
  • KL分级0-III级患者接受≥10次疗程获益更持久,疗效维持可达2年。

核心结论

  • 中药膏摩、推拿及联合针刺等中医保守治疗用于膝骨关节炎管理具有安全性。
  • KL分级较低(0-III级)患者从更长疗程(≥10次)中获益更大,效果维持可达2年。
  • 膏摩或联合针刺方案对疼痛和活动度的早期改善(前5次内)最优。

研究设计与样本

  • 多中心、前瞻性、观察性真实世界研究,在中国多个城市开展。
  • 共纳入2143例膝骨关节炎患者(女性83.76%),按偏好分入膏摩组(n=312)、推拿组(n=403)、膏摩+针刺组(n=237)、推拿+针刺组(n=1362)。
  • 治疗涉及5-10次,采用VAS评估膝关节平均疼痛程度,WOMAC和Lequesne指数评估膝关节功能障碍与严重程度,并计算2年复发率。

主要发现

  • 所有组治疗后WOMAC、VAS和Lequesne评分均显著下降。
  • 膏摩组在2-10个月时VAS评分最低。
  • 复发率由低到高依次为膏摩组、推拿组、推拿+针刺组、膏摩+针刺组。
  • 2年总体最高复发率为33.97%,18个月后趋于稳定。
  • KL II级患者长期结局最佳,2-24个月复发率为16.16%-30.85%。

关键数值与推荐

  • 2年总体最高复发率为33.97%。
  • KL II级患者2-24个月复发率为16.16%-30.85%。
  • KL分级0-III级患者接受≥10次疗程可获得更持久获益,效果维持可达2年。
  • 膏摩或联合针刺方案在前5次治疗内对疼痛和活动度提供最优早期改善。
  • 强化联合方案对轻度症状患者未提供额外累积获益。

临床怎么用

  • 对膝骨关节炎患者可考虑中药膏摩、推拿或联合针刺等中医保守治疗,关注其安全性。
  • KL分级0-III级患者可建议接受≥10次疗程以获取更持久疗效。
  • 追求早期疼痛和活动度改善可优先选择膏摩或联合针刺方案。
  • 轻度症状患者无需采用强化联合方案,以避免无额外获益的治疗。

局限性

  • 为观察性真实世界研究,患者按偏好分组,可能存在选择偏倚。
  • 原文未报告盲法、混杂因素控制等细节。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

PURPOSE: Compare long-term efficacy and recurrence of Chinese ointment(Co) massage, Tuina, and combined acupuncture for knee osteoarthritis (KOA). METHOD: A multicenter, prospective, observational real-world study was conducted in multiple cities in China. 2143 KOA patients (83.76 % female) were prospectively assigned by preference to Co (n = 312), Tuina (n = 403), Co+acupuncture (n = 237), or Tuina+acupuncture (n = 1362) groups. Treatments involved 5-10 sessions. The Visual Analog Scale (VAS) assessed the average degree of knee joint pain, while the Western Ontario and McMaster University Osteoarthritis Index (WOMAC) and Lequesne Index evaluated knee joint dysfunction in terms of functionality and severity. The 2 years recurrence rate of KOA was also calculated. RESULTS: All groups showed significant post-treatment WOMAC, VAS, and Lequesne score reductions. The Co group had the lowest VAS scores at 2-10 months. Recurrence rates (lowest to highest) were Co group, Tuina group, Tuina+acupuncture group, Co+acupuncture group. The overall maximum recurrence rate was 33.97 % at 2 years, stabilizing after 18 months. KL grade II patients had the best long-term outcomes (recurrence 16.16 %-30.85 % over 2-24 months). No serious adverse events occurred. CONCLUSIONS: Traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) conservative treatments (Co therapy, Tuina, and combined acupuncture) demonstrated safety for KOA management. Patients with lower KL grades (0-III) derived greater clinical benefit from longer courses (≥10 sessions), with effects sustained for up to 2 years. Co therapy or acupuncture-integrated regimens provided optimal early improvement (within the first 5 sessions) for pain and mobility. Intensive combination protocols offered no additional cumulative benefit for patients with mild symptoms.

来源:Complement Ther Med,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Bai X, Zhu Q, Tian Y, et al. Long-term symptom recurrence and functional outcomes with Chinese ointment massage, Tuina, and combined acupuncture for knee osteoarthritis: A 24-month multicenter real-world study in China. Complement Ther Med. 2025. PMID: 40780641. doi:10.1016/j.ctim.2025.103220

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。