文献速递针灸推拿

Cochrane针灸综述过时且未考虑假针刺特异性效应,可能低估针灸疗效

Cochrane reviews of acupuncture are dated, do not account for the specific effects of sham controls and likely underestimate the efficacy of acupuncture therapy.
PubMed 文献 · Integr Med Res · 2025-06-21

该研究将Cochrane针灸综述导入Covidence,筛选出至少纳入一项手针与假针刺比较研究的综述,进行双人数据提取。40篇纳入综述中28篇发表于2018年或更早,多数未评估干预充分性、少用STRICTA指南、假针刺方法报告常缺失或不严谨;20/40篇承认假针刺争议但未纳入结论。作者认为多数Cochrane针灸综述过时,对假针刺对照的处理及缺乏对真针刺干预充分性的评估违背明确研究标准,提示针灸疗效可能被低估。

要点

  • 多数Cochrane针灸综述发表于2018年或更早,未反映针灸生物机制与假针刺效应新认识。
  • 仅少数综述评估真针刺干预充分性或使用STRITCA指南,假针刺方法报告常缺失或不严谨。
  • 20/40篇综述承认假针刺争议但未纳入结论,作者认为针灸疗效可能被低估。

核心结论

  • 多数Cochrane针灸综述过时,未反映针灸生物机制及活性假针刺对照的影响。
  • 对假针刺对照的处理及缺乏真针刺干预充分性评估违背明确研究标准,提示针灸疗效可能被低估。

研究设计与样本

  • 将Cochrane针灸综述记录导入Covidence,独立筛选至少纳入一项手针与假针刺比较研究的综述。
  • 对纳入综述进行双人数据提取,提取内容包括作者专业程度、干预充分性评估、STRICTA指南使用、假针刺方法特征及是否讨论假针刺特异性效应。
  • 56篇标题含针灸的综述中16篇不符合纳入标准,最终纳入40篇综述。

主要发现

  • 40篇纳入综述中28篇发表于2018年或更早。
  • 多数综述有具备针灸试验专业知识的作者,但很少评估干预充分性,很少使用STRICTA指南,假针刺方法报告常缺失或不严谨。
  • 20/40篇综述承认假针刺作为活性对照的争议,但无一篇将其纳入结论。

临床怎么用

  • 解读Cochrane针灸综述结论时需考虑其发表年份及对假针刺对照的处理方式。
  • 评估针灸疗效证据时应关注真针刺干预是否充分及假针刺方法是否严谨。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Because Cochrane reviews represent a quality standard for systematic reviews, we sought to clarify to what extent Cochrane reviews of acupuncture characterize the potential and problematic specific effects of sham acupuncture. METHODS: We imported records of Cochrane acupuncture reviews into Covidence and independently selected reviews with at least one included study comparing manual acupuncture to sham acupuncture. Dual data extraction for eligible reviews included review author expertise, evaluation of intervention adequacy, use of STRICTA guidelines, characterization of sham methods, and whether specific effects of sham were discussed relative to needle penetration, point selection or use of a sham device. RESULTS: Of the 56 reviews with acupuncture in the title, 16 were ineligible. Of the 40 included reviews, 28 were published in or before 2018. Most reviews had an author with acupuncture trial expertise; however, assessment of intervention adequacy was rarely conducted, STRICTA guidelines were rarely utilized, and reporting of sham acupuncture methods was commonly either missing or lacking rigor. While 20/40 reviews acknowledged the controversy regarding sham as an active and therefore inadequate control, no reviews incorporated this into their conclusions. CONCLUSION: Most Cochrane reviews of acupuncture therapy are dated and are also not current relative to the science of acupuncture biomechanism and the impact of 'active' sham arms. The handling of sham controls, combined with a lack of evaluation of verum intervention adequacy, contravenes a clear research standard and indicates that the efficacy of acupuncture is likely underestimated in Cochrane reviews.

来源:Integr Med Res,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Nielsen A, Wieland LS. Cochrane reviews of acupuncture are dated, do not account for the specific effects of sham controls and likely underestimate the efficacy of acupuncture therapy. Integr Med Res. 2025. PMID: 40689021. doi:10.1016/j.imr.2025.101195

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。