不同非药物中医治法对癌症幸存者疗效的贝叶斯网络Meta分析
结果显示穴位按压和太极/气功分别在镇痛和改善生活质量方面表现最佳,混合疗法对睡眠改善最优,但所有干预对疲劳的疗效均不优于对照组,证据需谨慎解读。
要点
- 穴位按压对癌痛控制效果最佳(SMD=-1.1),太极/气功次之。
- 太极/气功在改善生活质量方面具有优势(SMD=1.87)。
- 混合疗法对改善睡眠质量效果最显著(SMD=-1.36)。
核心结论
- 穴位按压和太极/气功分别推荐为缓解疼痛和改善生活质量最有效的非药物中医疗法。
- 这些疗法对疲劳的疗效尚不明确。
研究设计与样本
- 系统检索PubMed、Embase、Web of Science、CNKI和万方数据库,纳入截至2025年2月的随机对照试验。
主要发现
- 所有五种干预疗法在癌症患者疼痛控制中均显示显著性。
- 穴位按压(SMD=-1.1 [-1.55, -0.66])和太极/气功(SMD=-1.08[-1.64, -0.53])镇痛效果最佳,其次为中医情志疗法(SMD=-0.93 [-1.42, -0.44])和针灸(SMD=-0.54 [-0.93, -0.15])。
- 混合疗法改善睡眠质量效果最大(SMD=-1.36[-2.56, -0.28])。
- 太极/气功改善生活质量有一定优势(SMD=1.87 [0.96, 2.83])。
- 针灸和中医情志疗法对睡眠质量或整体生活质量无显著效果。
关键数值与推荐
- 疼痛控制:穴位按压SMD=-1.1 [-1.55, -0.66],太极/气功SMD=-1.08[-1.64, -0.53],中医情志疗法SMD=-0.93 [-1.42, -0.44],针灸SMD=-0.54 [-0.93, -0.15]。
- 睡眠质量:混合疗法SMD=-1.36[-2.56, -0.28]。
- 生活质量:太极/气功SMD=1.87 [0.96, 2.83]。
临床怎么用
- 癌症幸存者疼痛管理可优先考虑穴位按压或太极/气功。
- 改善生活质量可推荐太极/气功,改善睡眠可考虑混合疗法。
- 不推荐单独使用针灸或中医情志疗法改善睡眠或生活质量。
局限性
- 纳入研究数量有限且偏倚风险高,结果需谨慎解读。
- 未来需更多严格设计的高质量随机对照试验确认长期疗效和安全性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: Several studies have demonstrated the positive impact of non-pharmacological Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM) therapies on pain, fatigue, sleep quality, and quality of life in cancer survivors. However, no research has compared the effectiveness of these therapies. This study aims to compare various interventions and identify the most effective non-pharmacological TCM therapies to provide evidence-based recommendations for cancer survivors. METHODS: A systematic search was conducted in PubMed, Embase, Web of Science, CNKI, and Wanfang Data. RCTs investigating the effects of Taichi, Qigong, acupuncture, acupressure, TCM emotional therapy, and mixed therapies as interventions for cancer survivors were screened was conducted. Data from the creation of the database to February 2025 were included. Two independent reviewers evaluated the study quality. A Bayesian Network Meta-analysis was conducted to carry out a random effects model. RESULTS: Seventy-one RCTs involving 6473 patients were included in the analysis. Network meta-analysis showed significance for all five intervention therapies in pain control in cancer patients. The best efficacy was observed for acupressure (SMD=-1.1 [-1.55, -0.66]) and Taichi/Qigong (SMD=-1.08[-1.64, -0.53]), followed by TCM emotional therapy (SMD=-0.93 [-1.42, -0.44]) and acupuncture (SMD=-0.54 [-0.93, -0.15]), with the latter showing comparatively lower efficacy. None of the interventions demonstrated superior efficacy in improving fatigue compared to the control group. Mixed therapies (SMD=-1.36[-2.56, -0.28]) demonstrated the greatest effect in improving sleep quality. Taichi/Qigong (SMD=1.87 [0.96, 2.83]) demonstrated certain advantages in improving quality of life. However, acupuncture and TCM emotional therapy had no significant effect on sleep quality or overall quality of life. CONCLUSION: The evidence from this study suggests that acupressure and Taichi/Qigong are recommended as the most effective therapies for pain relief and quality of life improvement, respectively. The efficacy of these therapies for fatigue remains inconclusive. However, due to the limited number of included studies and the high risk of bias, these results should be interpreted with caution. Future studies should include more rigorously designed high-quality randomized controlled trials to confirm their long-term efficacy and safety. REGISTRATION: PROSPERO CRD42024601976.
引用
- Zhang S, Li Y, Liang Z, et al. Comparing the effects of different non-pharmacological traditional Chinese medicine therapies on cancer survivors: A Bayesian Network Meta-analysis. Complement Ther Med. 2025. PMID: 40157553. doi:10.1016/j.ctim.2025.103164
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。