针灸相关疗法治疗癌症相关失眠的系统评价再评价
该研究对10篇针灸治疗癌症相关失眠(CRI)的系统评价/Meta分析进行再评价,采用AMSTAR-2、ROBIS和GRADE工具评估方法学质量、偏倚风险与证据质量。结果显示多数系统评价/Meta分析存在方法学缺陷、偏倚风险高、证据等级低且重叠度高;探索性分析提示针灸可能有效但需谨慎解读,安全性多被认可。
要点
- 现有针灸治疗CRI的系统评价方法学质量存在明显缺陷,证据可信度低
- 探索性分析提示针灸可能改善CRI,但偏倚风险高,结果需谨慎解读
- 多数系统评价认可针灸的安全性,但仍需高级别证据验证疗效
核心结论
- 当前针灸治疗癌症相关失眠的证据可信度低,方法学、偏倚风险与报告质量均需改进。
- 针灸显示出潜在疗效但缺乏足够支持,需要高级别证据阐明其有效性。
研究设计与样本
- 本研究为系统评价与Meta分析的再评价(overview)。
- 由两名评价者检索八个数据库,纳入针对随机对照试验的系统评价/Meta分析,最终纳入10篇。
- 采用AMSTAR-2、ROBIS和GRADE工具评估方法学质量、偏倚风险与证据质量,并用GROOVE工具计算校正覆盖面积(CCA)。
主要发现
- AMSTAR-2结果显示系统评价/Meta分析存在显著方法学缺陷,主要问题在于未提供排除清单。
- 超过半数系统评价/Meta分析因检索不完整和未遵循方案而存在高偏倚风险。
- 多数系统评价/Meta分析在报告质量上完整性较好,但总体证据水平低,且高重叠提示存在冗余。
- 探索性分析提示针灸治疗CRI可能有效,但偏倚风险高;敏感性分析结果稳定,漏斗图提示无发表偏倚。
- 多数系统评价/Meta分析认可针灸的安全性。
关键数值与推荐
- 共纳入10篇系统评价/Meta分析。
- 采用AMSTAR-2、ROBIS、GRADE和GROOVE(CCA)工具进行评价。
- 超过半数系统评价/Meta分析存在高偏倚风险。
- 总体证据水平为低。
临床怎么用
- 临床可参考针灸作为CRI的潜在辅助疗法,但应告知患者现有证据可信度低。
- 解读相关系统评价结论时需结合其方法学缺陷与高偏倚风险,避免过度采信。
- 关注针灸安全性信息,多数系统评价认可其安全性。
局限性
- 纳入的系统评价/Meta分析存在方法学缺陷、检索不完整及未遵循方案等问题。
- 原始研究偏倚风险高,总体证据水平低,结论可靠性受限。
- 系统评价/Meta分析间重叠度高,存在冗余。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The number of systematic reviews and meta-analyses (SRs/MAs) on acupuncture therapy for CRI is increasing; however, the credibility of the evidence remains unclear with controversial results, necessitating a comprehensive evaluation. OBJECTIVE: We aimed to critically assess the evidence in SRs/MAs regarding the effectiveness of acupuncture therapy for CRI from various aspects and conduct an exploratory analysis to identify potential issues. METHOD: Two reviewers conducted comprehensive searches in eight databases. SRs/MAs of randomized controlled trials are included. After screening according to inclusion and exclusion criteria, two reviewers extracted data from eligible SRs/MAs and conducted a detailed assessment of methodological quality, risk of bias, and quality of evidence using AMSTAR-2, ROBIS, and GRADE tools. Meanwhile, we calculated the Corrected Covered Area (CCA) leveraging the GROOVE tool. After manually excluding duplicate studies, we assess the risk of bias of primary studies extracted from SRs/MAs and conducted exploratory meta-analysis. RESULT: The comprehensive analysis included 10 SRs/MAs. The AMSRAT-2 results indicate significant methodological flaws in SRs/MAs, with the main issues focusing on the lack of provision of exclusion checklist for the studies. Furthermore, over half of the SRs/MAs have a high risk of bias due to incomplete retrieval and failure to follow the protocol. Most SRs/MAs demonstrated considerable completeness in reporting quality. Notably, the overall level of evidence is low. High overlap indicates redundant SRs/MAs. Exploratory analysis suggests that acupuncture therapy may be effective for CRI; however, with a high risk of bias, caution is needed in interpreting the results. Sensitivity analysis results are stable, and the funnel plot indicates no publication bias. Most SRs/MAs acknowledge the safety of acupuncture. CONCLUSION: Currently, the credibility of acupuncture therapy for treating CRI is low and improvements are needed in methodology, risk of bias, and quality of reporting. Acupuncture therapy shows potential but lacks sufficient support; high-level evidence is warranted to elucidate the effectiveness of acupuncture in treating CRI.
引用
- Guo Z, Wang Y, Liu W, et al. Acupuncture-related therapy for cancer-related insomnia: An overview of systematic reviews and meta-analysis. Complement Ther Med. 2024. PMID: 39128532. doi:10.1016/j.ctim.2024.103074
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。