英国私人针灸诊所临床审计:患者人口学、疗效与体验评估
该临床审计评估英国私人针灸诊所患者的人口学特征、疗效与体验。7年病历提取数据显示306例患者共376项健康主诉,58%为肌肉骨骼问题。MYMOP与PGIC随访显示多数主诉临床显著改善,93% PGIC为改善,79% MYMOP变化>1分,MYMOP严重度评分1-4周降低近50%(p<0.001)并维持中长期。
要点
- 肌肉骨骼问题占主诉58%,但患者寻求针灸的慢性健康问题范围广泛。
- 93% PGIC为改善,79% MYMOP变化>1分,MYMOP严重度评分1-4周降低近50%。
- 85/255例问卷受访者报告118项健康主诉,超84%认为治疗有效。
核心结论
- 肌肉骨骼问题最常见,但患者因多种以慢性为主的健康问题寻求针灸,其中许多缺乏高质量证据支持针灸使用。
- 对结局问卷应答的小样本患者报告临床有意义且持续的改善。
研究设计与样本
- 英国私人针灸诊所的临床审计,提取7年患者病历人口学与临床数据。
- 使用MYMOP问卷与改编PGIC量表在18个月内常规监测结局,并以回顾性问卷评估患者对疗效、不良事件与整体体验的看法。
- 排除未提供知情同意或已知死亡的患者;共收集306例患者、376项独立健康主诉的数据。
主要发现
- 376项健康主诉中58%为肌肉骨骼问题。
- 随访结局(MYMOP评分n=51,PGIC应答n=50)显示多数健康主诉较基线临床显著改善:93% PGIC评分为「改善」,79% MYMOP显示>1分变化。
- MYMOP总平均严重度评分在1-4周后降低近50%(p<0.001),并在中至长期维持。
- MYMOP与PGIC评分呈强负相关(r=-0.767,p<0.001)。
- 85/255例回顾性问卷应答者报告118项健康主诉;超过84%患者认为所接受治疗对其健康主诉「有效」。
关键数值与推荐
- 93% PGIC评分为「改善」。
- 79% MYMOP显示>1分变化。
- MYMOP总平均严重度评分1-4周降低近50%(p<0.001)。
- MYMOP与PGIC评分强负相关(r=-0.767,p<0.001)。
- 超过84%问卷应答患者认为治疗「有效」。
临床怎么用
- 在私人针灸实践中可常规使用MYMOP与PGIC监测患者报告结局。
- 应关注肌肉骨骼以外慢性主诉的就诊需求,并认识其证据基础可能不足。
- 需常规记录不良事件与负面治疗结局,本审计报告7例轻微不良事件与4例负面结局。
局限性
- 为单家英国私人诊所的临床审计,样本量小且结局问卷应答者有限(MYMOP n=51,PGIC n=50,回顾问卷85/255)。
- 缺乏对照组,无法区分针灸特异性效应与非特异性效应。
- 许多就诊健康主诉目前缺乏高质量证据支持针灸使用。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: The aim of this clinical audit was to assess patient demographics, outcomes and experience with care in patients who received acupuncture in a private practice setting in the United Kingdom. METHODS: Demographic and clinical data were extracted from patients' records over a 7-year period. The Measure Yourself Medical Outcomes Profile (MYMOP) questionnaire and an adapted Patient Global Impression of Change (PGIC) scale were used routinely to monitor patient outcomes over an 18-month period. Finally, a retrospective questionnaire was used to assess patient beliefs regarding treatment effectiveness, adverse events and overall experience with care. Patients not providing consent or known to be deceased were excluded. RESULTS: Data were collected for 306 patients presenting with 376 separate health complaints, 58% of which were musculoskeletal. Follow-up outcomes (MYMOP scores (n = 51) and PGIC scale responses (n = 50)) showed a clinically significant improvement compared to baseline for the majority of health complaints (93% of PGIC scores were 'improved' and 79% MYMOP demonstrated > 1 point change). Total mean MYMOP severity scores were reduced by almost 50% (p < 0.001) after 1-4 weeks, and this was sustained in the medium-to-long term. There was a strong negative correlation (r = -0.767, p < 0.001) between the MYMOP and PGIC scores. A total of 118 health complaints were reported by 85/255 patients who responded to a retrospective questionnaire. Over 84% of patients believed that the treatments they received were 'effective' at addressing their health complaints. Seven minor adverse events were reported and four patients experienced negative treatment outcomes. CONCLUSIONS: Although musculoskeletal conditions were the most common, this audit found that patients sought treatment for a wide range of predominantly chronic health complaints, for many of which there is a currently a lack of quality evidence to support the use of acupuncture. Overall, the small sample of patients who responded to outcome questionnaires reported clinically meaningful and sustained improvements.
引用
- Lowe N, Permyakova N, Dutton R, et al. A clinical audit in a UK-based acupuncture private practice: assessing patient demographics, outcomes and experience. Acupunct Med. 2024. PMID: 38702874. doi:10.1177/09645284241248470
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。