针刺疗效影响因素:针刺随机对照试验的Meta回归分析
该Meta回归分析纳入2015至2019年7个数据库的针刺RCT,比较针刺与不针刺、假针刺或等待名单,并报告至少1项患者重要结局。采用三水平稳健混合模型进行多水平Meta回归。疼痛结局中高频针刺效应更大(调整SMD差0.46,95%CI 0.07~0.84,P=0.02);非疼痛症状中穿透针刺效应中等更大(0.30,95%CI 0.06~0.53,P=0.01);功能结局中穿透针刺和灵活方案分别中等更大(0.40,95%CI 0~0.80,P=0.05;0.29,95%CI 0.06~0.53,P=0.01)。
要点
- 高频针刺对疼痛症状可能更有效。
- 穿透针刺对非疼痛症状效应中等更大。
- 穿透针刺和灵活方案对功能结局有显著效应。
核心结论
- 高频针刺 sessions 似乎是管理疼痛症状更有效的方法。
- 穿透针刺在缓解非疼痛症状方面显示更大效应。
- 穿透针刺类型和灵活针刺方案均与功能结局的显著治疗效应相关。
研究设计与样本
- 检索Medline(PubMed)、Embase、Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials、中国知网、万方数据库、维普数据库和中国生物医学文献数据库共7个数据库。
- 采用三水平稳健混合模型进行多水平Meta回归,对所有独立变量进行单变量分析。
- 使用SMD差值阈值0.2和0.4,将效应分为小(<0.2)、中(0.2-0.4)、大(>0.4)。
主要发现
- 疼痛结构分析涉及153项研究的211个效应估计和14个独立变量。
- 高频针刺治疗 sessions 相比低频 sessions 产生更大效应(大效应,调整SMD差0.46,95%CI 0.07~0.84,P=0.02)。
- 非疼痛症状结构分析涉及231项研究的323个效应估计和15个独立变量。
- 穿透针刺相比非穿透针刺显示中等更大效应(0.30,95%CI 0.06~0.53,P=0.01)。
- 功能结构分析涉及274项研究的495个效应估计和14个独立变量;穿透针刺和灵活针刺方案分别相比非穿透针刺和固定方案显示中等更大效应(0.40,95%CI 0~0.80,P=0.05;0.29,95%CI 0.06~0.53,P=0.01)。
关键数值与推荐
- 疼痛结局:高频针刺相比低频针刺,调整SMD差0.46(95%CI 0.07~0.84,P=0.02),为大效应。
- 非疼痛症状结局:穿透针刺相比非穿透针刺,SMD差0.30(95%CI 0.06~0.53,P=0.01),为中等效应。
- 功能结局:穿透针刺相比非穿透针刺,SMD差0.40(95%CI 0~0.80,P=0.05),为中等效应。
- 功能结局:灵活针刺方案相比固定方案,SMD差0.29(95%CI 0.06~0.53,P=0.01),为中等效应。
- 效应大小分类阈值:SMD差值<0.2为小效应,0.2-0.4为中等效应,>0.4为大效应。
临床怎么用
- 管理疼痛症状时可优先考虑高频针刺治疗 sessions。
- 缓解非疼痛症状时可考虑使用穿透针刺。
- 改善功能结局时可考虑穿透针刺或灵活针刺方案。
- 未来研究应关注与针刺患者重要结局显著相关的因素。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The effects of acupuncture have varied in different randomized controlled trials (RCTs), and there are many factors that influence treatment effect of acupuncture in different outcomes, with conflicting results. OBJECTIVE: To identify factors and their impact on the treatment effect of acupuncture in different outcomes. METHODS: Acupuncture RCTs were searched from 7 databases including Medline (PubMed), Embase, Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials, China National Knowledge Infrastructure, Wanfang Database, VIP Database, and China Biology Medicine disc between January 1st, 2015 and December 31st, 2019. Eligible studies must compare acupuncture to no acupuncture, sham acupuncture, or waiting lists, and report at least 1 patient-important outcome. A multi-level meta-regression was conducted using a 3-level robust mixed model and univariate analyses were performed for all independent variables, even those excluded from the multivariable model due to collinearities. We used thresholds of 0.2 and 0.4 for the difference of standardized mean differences (SMDs), categorising them as small (<0.2), moderate (0.2-0.4), or large (>0.4) effects. RESULTS: The pain construct analysis involved 211 effect estimates from 153 studies and 14 independent variables. High-frequency acupuncture treatment sessions produced larger effects compared to low-frequency sessions [large magnitude, the difference of adjusted SMDs 0.46, 95% confidence interval (CI) 0.07 to 0.84; P=0.02]. The non-pain symptoms construct analysis comprised 323 effect estimates from 231 studies and 15 independent variables. Penetrating acupuncture showed moderately larger effects when compared to non-penetrating acupuncture (0.30, 95% CI 0.06 to 0.53; P=0.01). The function construct analysis included 495 effect estimates from 274 studies and 14 independent variables. Penetrating acupuncture and the flexible acupuncture regimen showed moderately larger effects, compared to non-penetrating acupuncture and fixed regimen, respectively (0.40, 95% CI 0 to 0.80; P=0.05; 0.29, 95% CI 0.06 to 0.53; P=0.01). CONCLUSIONS: High-frequency acupuncture sessions appear to be a more effective approach to managing painful symptoms. Penetrating acupuncture demonstrated greater effect in relieving non-painful symptoms. Both penetrating acupuncture type and flexible acupuncture regimen were linked to significant treatment effects in function outcomes. Future studies should consider the factors that are significantly associated with the effects of acupuncture in patient-important outcomes.
引用
- Xiu WC, Gang WJ, Zhou Q, et al. Factors and Their Impact on Treatment Effect of Acupuncture in Different Outcomes: A Meta-Regression of Acupuncture Randomized Controlled Trials. Chin J Integr Med. 2024. PMID: 38212500. doi:10.1007/s11655-023-3617-0
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。