心力衰竭中医辨证循证问卷的验证及专家共识评价
本研究基于专家共识、文献综述和临床指南设计心力衰竭中医辨证问卷(SDQHF),并在661例心衰患者中开展多中心临床试验验证其信效度。结果显示问卷具有良好的收敛与区分效度及内部一致性,91%的模型辨证结果与舌象特征匹配,气虚证为心衰主导证型,血瘀与痰饮常兼夹,阴阳两虚证应纳入辨证标准。
要点
- SDQHF问卷包含气虚、阳虚、阴虚、血瘀、痰饮五个证候要素,信效度良好。
- 91%的模型辨证结果与舌象特征匹配,支持辨证标准的准确性。
- 气虚证为心衰主导证型,血瘀与痰饮常相兼为患,阴阳两虚证应纳入辨证标准。
核心结论
- 所提出的SDQHF问卷及辨证标准可作为心衰中医辨证的可靠有效工具,准确度较高。
研究设计与样本
- 基于专家共识、文献综述和多种临床指南设计心衰中医辨证问卷(SDQHF)。
- 开展大规模多中心临床试验,共招募661例心衰患者。
- 采用Cronbach's alpha评估内部一致性,专家评审进行内容效度检验,主成分分析(PCA)评估结构效度。
- 通过舌象分析验证模型辨证与专家共识辨证的准确性。
主要发现
- 辨证标准由气虚、阳虚、阴虚、血瘀、痰饮五个证候要素构成。
- 问卷显示良好的收敛效度与区分效度、满意的内部一致性及可行性。
- 91%的模型辨证结果与证型对应的舌象特征匹配。
- 气虚证为心衰患者主导证型,其后依次为阳气亏虚证、气阴两虚证,最后为阴阳两虚证。
- 多数心衰患者兼有血瘀证与痰饮证;阴阳两虚证为心衰有效证型,应纳入辨证标准。
关键数值与推荐
- SDQHF包含气虚、阳虚、阴虚、血瘀、痰饮五个证候要素。
- 91%的模型辨证结果与舌象特征匹配。
- 气虚证为心衰主导证型,阳气亏虚证、气阴两虚证次之,阴阳两虚证再次之。
- 多数心衰患者兼见血瘀证与痰饮证。
- 阴阳两虚证应纳入心衰辨证标准。
临床怎么用
- 推荐使用所提出的SDQHF模型开展心衰中医辨证的循证研究。
- 临床辨证时可参考五个证候要素及气虚主导、血瘀痰饮常兼夹的证型分布特点。
- 专家共识验证后提出了若干提高心衰辨证准确性的建议。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM) is widely used to treat heart failure (HF). Syndrome differentiation is a unique and crucial component in TCM practice for guiding disease diagnosis and treatment strategies as well as clinical research. The major bottlenecks in TCM syndrome differentiation are the diversity of the syndrome differentiation criteria and the broad spectrum of syndrome patterns, hindering evidence-based studies for clinical research. In the present study, we aim to develop an evidence-based questionnaire for the diagnosis of HF and establish a definitive set of criteria for syndrome differentiation. METHODS: We designed a TCM syndrome differentiation questionnaire for heart failure (SDQHF) based on the "TCM expert consensus for diagnosis and treatment of heart failure" (expert consensus), literature review, and various clinical guidelines. To test the reliability and efficiency of the questionnaire, we performed a large-scale multiple-center clinical trial with the recruitment of 661 HF patients. Cronbach's alpha was used to assess the internal consistency of the SDQHF. Content validity was conducted through expert review. Principal component analysis (PCA) was applied to evaluate the construct validity. We constructed a proposed model for syndrome differentiation for HF based on the PCA results. Tongue analysis was performed to verify the accuracy of syndromes derived from the proposed model and the expert consensus. An evidence-based practical questionnaire for TCM syndrome differentiation patients was developed and validated with the data from 661 HF patients. RESULTS: The syndrome differentiation criteria were constructed with five syndrome elements (qi-deficiency, yang-deficiency, yin-deficiency, blood stasis, and phlegm retention). The results revealed good convergent and discriminant validity, satisfactory internal consistency, and feasibility. The significant discoveries include: (1) A total of 91% of the derived TCM syndromes from the proposed model matched with the characterized tongue images of the syndrome patterns; (2) Qi Deficiency Syndrome is the dominant syndrome pattern for HF patients, followed by Yang-Qi Deficiency Syndrome and Qi-yin deficiency Syndrome, and finally, Yin-Yang Dual Deficiency Syndrome; (3) The majority of the HF patients had the combination of Blood Stasis and Phlegm Retention Syndromes; (4) The "Yin-Yang Dual Deficiency" Syndrome was a valid syndrome for HF, suggesting that this syndrome pattern should be included in the criteria for syndrome differentiation; and (5) Through the validation of the expert consensus, several recommendations were proposed to improve the accuracy of syndrome differentiation of HF. CONCLUSIONS: The proposed SDQHF and the criteria could be a reliable and valid tool for syndrome differentiation of heart failure with high accuracy. It is recommended to use the proposed model for evidence-based study on Chinese Medicine to diagnose and treat HF. TRIAL REGISTRATION NUMBER: The trial was registered at the Chinese Clinical Trial Registry, http://www.chictr.org.cn . (Registration No.: ChiCTR1900021929); Date: 2019-03-16.
引用
- Leung AYL, Zhang J, Chan CY, et al. Validation of evidence-based questionnaire for TCM syndrome differentiation of heart failure and evaluation of expert consensus. Chin Med. 2023. PMID: 37296429. doi:10.1186/s13020-023-00757-1
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。