文献速递针灸推拿中药与中成药合理使用

针灸疗法相关不良事件:535篇系统评价的证据图谱

Adverse effects associated with acupuncture therapies: An evidence mapping from 535 systematic reviews.
PubMed 文献 · Chin Med · 2023-04-10

该证据图谱基于535篇系统评价,检索至2022年6月15日,识别针灸相关33种不良反应,涉及19种针灸技术和23种疾病。多数纳入研究方法学质量低或极低,不良反应多为轻症,提示需更高质量研究全面评估针灸安全性。

要点

  • 针灸相关不良反应类型多样,以晕厥、器官或组织损伤、全身反应等为主,多为轻症。
  • 不良反应主要关联电针、手针和穴位埋线等19种针灸技术。
  • 多数系统评价方法学质量为低或极低,临床决策需结合证据质量谨慎判断。

核心结论

  • 针灸相关不良反应类型多样,症状多较轻,但多数纳入系统评价方法学质量为低或极低,需未来随机对照试验和系统评价全面分析以提供可靠证据。

研究设计与样本

  • 证据图谱研究,全面检索PubMed、Embase、Web of Science和Cochrane Library四个公共数据库,截至2022年6月15日,并补充检索Epistemonikos数据库和参考文献列表。
  • 共纳入535篇系统评价(SRs)和/或荟萃分析(MAs),采用AMSTAR-2工具评估方法学质量,Excel 2019提取编码数据,生成热图和气泡图展示疾病类型、作者国家、样本量、干预类别、不良反应类型和证据等级。

主要发现

  • 535篇SRs共涉及33种不良反应,包括晕厥(86篇SRs)、器官或组织损伤(233篇SRs)、全身反应(113篇SRs)、感染(19篇SRs)和其他不良事件(373篇SRs)。
  • 不良反应主要关联19种针灸技术,其中电针(n=67)、手针(n=47)和穴位埋线(n=41)报道较多。
  • 535篇SRs涉及23种疾病,症状、体征或临床发现(83篇SRs)、精神、行为或神经发育障碍(67篇SRs)和神经系统疾病(66篇SRs)发生率最高。
  • 方法学质量评估显示22篇高质量、28篇中等质量、106篇低质量,其余为极低质量。

临床怎么用

  • 临床使用针灸时需关注晕厥、器官或组织损伤、全身反应、感染等不良反应,尤其电针、手针和穴位埋线等常用技术。
  • 因多数系统评价方法学质量低或极低,临床决策应结合证据质量谨慎解读不良反应发生率,并优先参考高质量研究。

局限性

  • 多数纳入系统评价方法学质量为低或极低,可能影响不良反应评估的可靠性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE: Considering that physicians and patients widely use acupuncture, it is necessary to explore its adverse effects during treatment. Herein, an evidence map was generated based on published studies to identify acupuncture-induced adverse effects and assess their severity, with the overarching goal of providing references for safe and effective implementation. METHODS: A comprehensive literature search was performed in four public databases (PubMed, Embase, Web of science, and the Cochrane Library) to identify relevant studies published up to 15th June 2022. In addition, relevant studies were explored in the Epistemonikos database and reference lists were retrieved as a supplement. A MeaSurement Tool to Assess systematic Reviews, Version 2 (AMSTAR-2) quality assessment tool was applied to determine the methodological quality of included systematic reviews (SRs) and/or meta-analysis (MAs), whereas Microsoft Excel 2019 tool was used for data extraction and coding. Heatmaps were generated to display disease type, countries of origin for the first authors, and the sample sizes of original studies. Moreover, bubble charts comprehensively presented intervention categories, adverse reaction types, and evidence levels. RESULTS: A total of 535 SRs involving 33 adverse reactions were included. Among them, 22 studies were rated as high quality, 28 as moderate, 106 as low, and the rest were of critically-low quality. Numerous adverse effects were described in the studies, including syncope (86 SRs), organ or tissue injury (233 SRs), systemic reactions (113 SRs), infection (19 SRs), and other adverse events (373 SRs). Importantly, these adverse reactions were mainly associated with 19 acupuncture techniques, including electroacupuncture (n = 67), manual acupuncture (n = 47) and acupoint catgut embedding (n = 41). Furthermore, the 535 SRs described 23 diseases, among which symptoms, signs or clinical findings (83 SRs), mental, behavioral or neurodevelopmental disorders (67 SRs), and diseases of the nervous system (66 SRs) had the highest incidence. CONCLUSION: This evidence mapping explores the adverse effects of acupuncture, showing that there are multiple types of adverse reactions to acupuncture, with milder symptoms. The methodological assessment revealed that most of the included studies were of low- or critically low-quality. Therefore, there is a need for future randomized controlled trials and SRs to comprehensively analyze acupuncture-related adverse events in order to provide reliable and credible evidence.

来源:Chin Med,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Xu M, Yang C, Nian T, et al. Adverse effects associated with acupuncture therapies: An evidence mapping from 535 systematic reviews. Chin Med. 2023. PMID: 37038228. doi:10.1186/s13020-023-00743-7

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。