针体表面纹理对穴位组织力学效应的影响
该研究通过有限元模拟不同表面纹理的针灸针(光滑、纵纹、环纹、左旋螺纹、右旋螺纹)在足三里穴的插入、提插和捻转操作,比较组织损伤与刺激强度。结果显示光滑针和纵纹针插入时损伤最小,左旋和右旋螺纹针损伤最大;环纹针提插刺激最强,纵纹针捻转刺激最强。结论提示垂直于操作方向的纹理可增强刺激,为针具设计提供依据。
要点
- 光滑针和纵纹针插入时组织损伤最小,螺纹针损伤最大
- 环纹针提插刺激最强,纵纹针捻转刺激最强
- 垂直于操作方向的纹理可增强刺激,可用于针具设计
核心结论
- 环纹图案在提插操作中增强刺激最佳,纵纹图案在捻转操作中增强刺激最佳。
- 左旋和右旋螺纹图案在提插和捻转中均有增强作用,但产生较好刺激的扭转方向相反。
- 垂直于针刺操作运动方向的纹理产生更多刺激。
研究设计与样本
- 研究采用五种不同表面图案的针灸针模型(光滑针、纵纹针、环纹针、左旋螺纹针、右旋螺纹针)和足三里穴分层模型进行模拟。
- 模拟了皮肤穿刺、提插和捻转针法操作,比较不同表面图案针具造成的损伤程度和刺激力。
主要发现
- 光滑针和纵纹针在插入时造成组织损伤最小,左旋螺纹针和右旋螺纹针造成损伤最大。
- 环纹针、左旋螺纹针和右旋螺纹针在提插操作中对穴位组织刺激较大,纵纹针和光滑针刺激较小。
- 捻转操作中纵纹针对穴位组织刺激最大,左旋螺纹针和右旋螺纹针效果较小。
- 提插和捻转操作中,左旋螺纹针和右旋螺纹针均提供较多刺激,但产生较好刺激的扭转方向相反。
临床怎么用
- 根据模拟结果,提插操作宜选用环纹针以增强刺激,捻转操作宜选用纵纹针以增强刺激。
- 需减少插入损伤时可考虑光滑针或纵纹针,螺纹针可能增加组织损伤。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: This study aims to clarify how the stimulation of acupuncture points is achieved by needles with different surface texture during acupuncture; it also seeks to lessen injury at the insertion site and increase the therapeutic efficacy of acupuncture, by simulating the mechanical effects of various needle surface patterns on Zusanli (ST36) without changing the radius of acupuncture needles. METHODS: Five acupuncture needle models with different surface patterns, including the smooth needle, the lined needle, the ringed needle, the left-hand threaded needle and the right-hand threaded needle, and a layered model of the Zusanli acupoint were used to investigate how to reduce tissue damage and increase stimulation during acupuncture treatment. Puncturing of the skin as well as lifting-inserting and twisting needle manipulations were simulated using these models, and the degree of damage and force of stimulation caused by the acupuncture needles with different surface patterns during acupuncture were compared. RESULTS: The smooth needle and the lined needle caused the least tissue damage during insertion, while the left-hand threaded and the right-hand threaded needles caused the most damage. The ringed needle, the left-hand threaded needle and the right-hand threaded needle stimulated the acupoint tissue more during lifting-inserting manipulations, while the lined needle and the smooth needle produced less stimulation. The stimulation of the lined needle on the acupoint tissue was the largest during twisting manipulation, whereas the left-hand threaded needle and the right-hand threaded needle had smaller effects. In lifting-inserting and twisting manipulations, both the left-hand threaded needle and right-hand threaded needle provided more stimulation, but the torsion direction in which they produced better stimulation was the opposite. CONCLUSION: According to the simulation results, the ringed pattern enhances stimulation best in the lifting-inserting manipulation, whereas the lined pattern enhances stimulation best in the twisting manipulation. Both the right-hand and left-hand thread patterns have certain enhancing effects in these two operations. Taking the geometric properties of the pattern into account, the left-hand thread pattern and the right-hand thread pattern have the geometric characteristics of both the lined pattern and the ringed pattern. To conclude, a pattern perpendicular to the movement direction during the acupuncture manipulation creates more stimulation. These results have significance for future needle design. Please cite this article as: Sun MZ, Wang X, Li YC, Yao W, Gu W. Mechanical effects of needle texture on acupoint tissue. J Integr Med. 2023; 21(3): 254-267.
引用
- Sun MZ, Wang X, Li YC, et al. Mechanical effects of needle texture on acupoint tissue. J Integr Med. 2023. PMID: 37003857. doi:10.1016/j.joim.2023.03.005
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。