文献速递针灸推拿

Cochrane系统评价中针灸Meta分析结果的稳健性:脆弱指数分析

Robustness of meta-analysis results in Cochrane systematic reviews: A case for acupuncture trials.
PubMed 文献 · Integr Med Res · 2022-10-07

本研究采用脆弱指数(FI)评估Cochrane系统评价中针灸Meta分析的稳健性,检索PubMed、Embase和CENTRAL,纳入以穿透针与假针灸、常规护理或阳性对照比较的随机或半随机试验的Meta分析。共分析12篇Cochrane系统评价中的48项Meta分析,显著性Meta分析的中位FI为7(IQR 3-12),非显著性Meta分析为6(IQR 3-10),脆弱商(FQ)与统计学显著性无关,假针灸对照的Meta分析FI和FQ范围最宽。结论认为针灸Meta分析的稳健性与统计学显著性相似,对照干预的影响无法确定,FI直观解读对补充与整合医学领域有用。

要点

  • 显著性针灸Meta分析中位FI为7,非显著性为6,稳健性相似。
  • FQ与统计学显著性无关,假针灸对照的FI和FQ范围最宽。
  • FI可直观解读,适用于补充与整合医学领域证据评估。

核心结论

  • Cochrane系统评价中针灸Meta分析的稳健性与统计学显著性相似。
  • 对照干预类型对FI和FQ的影响在本研究中无法确定。
  • FI具有直观解读优势,可应用于补充与整合医学领域。

研究设计与样本

  • 研究检索PubMed、Embase和CENTRAL中针灸Cochrane系统评价的Meta分析,纳入二分类疗效指标。
  • 纳入随机或半随机试验,治疗采用穿透针,对照包括假针灸、常规护理或阳性对照。
  • 共分析12篇Cochrane系统评价中的48项Meta分析,FI通过在线工具计算,FQ为FI除以Meta分析总样本量。

主要发现

  • 显著性Meta分析的中位FI为7(IQR 3-12),非显著性Meta分析的中位FI为6(IQR 3-10)。
  • FQ在显著性与非显著性Meta分析间相似。
  • 假针灸对照的Meta分析显示FI和FQ范围最宽。

临床怎么用

  • 临床解读针灸Meta分析时,可结合FI评估结果稳健性,避免仅依赖统计学显著性。
  • 对假针灸对照的Meta分析结果需谨慎解释,因其FI和FQ变异范围较宽。

局限性

  • 研究无法确定对照干预对稳健性的影响。
  • 仅纳入二分类疗效指标的Meta分析,可能限制普适性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

INTRODUCTION: Fragility index (FI) refers to the smallest value that change statistical significance of study results. Meta-analyses of Cochrane systematic reviews are considered as the best evidence for stake holders because they enable effect size estimation that cannot be derived by individual studies, particularly in the field of complementary and integrative medicine (CIM). Thus, this study aimed to evaluate robustness of meta-analysis in Cochrane systematic reviews of acupuncture, one of the most used CIM treatment, using FI of meta-analysis. METHODS: Meta-analyses of acupuncture Cochrane systematic reviews with binary benefit outcome measures were searched in PubMed, Embase, and CENTRAL and subject to analysis. Randomized clinical trials (RCTs) or quasi RCTs adopted penetrating needles as treatment and compared with controls such as sham acupuncture, usual care, and active control were included. FI of meta-analyses was calculated in web (https://clinicalepidemio.fr/fragility_ma/); and fragility quotient (FQ) was calculated by dividing FI by total sample size of meta-analysis. RESULTS: Of 248 retrieved studies, 12 Cochrane systematic reviews with 48 meta-analyses were analyzed. The median FI for statistically significant and non-significant meta-analyses was 7 [interquartile range: 3 - 12] and 6 [interquartile range: 3 - 10]. FQ was similar irrespective of statistical significance. Among controls, meta-analyses adopting sham acupuncture displayed the widest range of FI and FQ. CONCLUSION: Robustness of meta-analyses in Cochrane systematic reviews for acupuncture was similar irrespective of statistical significance. Impact of control intervention cannot be determined in this study. As FI enables intuitive interpretation, applications for CIM field can be useful.

来源:Integr Med Res,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Won J. Robustness of meta-analysis results in Cochrane systematic reviews: A case for acupuncture trials. Integr Med Res. 2022. PMID: 36338607. doi:10.1016/j.imr.2022.100890

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。