针灸剂量组分与量效关系的系统综述
37.5%的研究显示高剂量条件下针灸反应显著增强,刺激强度差异最常出现显著量效差异。
要点
- 针灸研究已初步显示量效关系,但证据有限。
- 刺激强度可能是影响针灸临床反应的重要剂量组分。
- 不同针数或治疗次数/频率的量效差异证据较少。
核心结论
- 针灸研究已初步建立量效关系,高剂量条件在部分研究中显示显著增强的反应。
- 刺激强度是影响针灸临床反应的重要剂量组分。
研究设计与样本
- 将针灸剂量组分分为针数、刺激强度、治疗总次数/频率三组,比较低剂量与高剂量条件的反应。
主要发现
- 37.5%的纳入研究显示高剂量条件较低剂量条件有统计学显著增强的反应。
- 高剂量与低剂量条件间显著差异最常出现在使用不同刺激强度的研究(6项中4项),其次为不同针数的研究(7项中2项),不同治疗次数/频率的研究无显著差异(3项中0项)。
- 反应分为症状变化、生理变化、实验诱发的疼痛/刺激感知和针刺感觉四类。
临床怎么用
- 临床可考虑刺激强度作为影响针灸疗效的重要剂量参数。
- 针对不同剂量组分(针数、刺激强度、治疗次数/频率)需个体化权衡。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
The dose-response relationship is a hallmark of pharmacological studies. However, this relationship has not been fully established in acupuncture research. This systematic review aims to provide the characteristics of the dose-response relationship in acupuncture research. We further summarized the differences in acupuncture effects according to dose components. Dose components of acupuncture were categorized into three groups: number of needles, stimulation intensity, and total number/frequency of treatments. The PubMed database was used to identify studies examining the effects of different doses of acupuncture from the establishment of the database to August 13, 2020. Dose components and responses were extracted from each study, and the results of low- and high-dose conditions were compared. Fourteen studies were included in this study. Of the included studies, 37.5% showed statistically significant enhanced responses to acupuncture treatment under high-dose conditions compared to low-dose conditions. Significant differences between high- and low-dose conditions were observed most frequently in studies that used various stimulation intensities (four out of six studies), followed in order by studies that used various numbers of needles (two out of seven studies), and those that used various numbers or frequencies of treatment (none of the three studies). Responses were categorized into symptom changes, physiological changes, experimentally induced pain/stimuli perception, and needling sensation. Stimulation intensity, which is considered one of the most important needling components, might indeed have a great impact on clinical responses to acupuncture.
引用
- Yoon DE, Lee IS, Chae Y, et al. Identifying Dose Components of Manual Acupuncture to Determine the Dose-Response Relationship of Acupuncture Treatment: A Systematic Review. Am J Chin Med. 2022. PMID: 35300569. doi:10.1142/S0192415X22500264
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。