日本含针灸推荐临床实践指南的质量评估
结果显示仅3部指南符合GRADE体系,AGREE II总体评估均分4.5分(7分制),领域5适用性得分最低(20%),2部指南的针灸推荐强度被低估。结论认为日本含针灸推荐指南的方法学质量不算高,需各领域专家参与制定与评审。
要点
- 日本含针灸推荐的指南方法学质量整体不高,仅3部符合GRADE体系。
- AGREE II评估中适用性领域得分最低(20%),严谨性领域仅48%。
- 2部指南的针灸推荐强度被判定为低估,部分指南存在AGREE II未涵盖的基本问题。
核心结论
- 日本含针灸推荐的临床实践指南方法学质量不算高。
- 各治疗领域存在技术问题,应由相应专家参与指南制定与评审以传播准确健康信息。
研究设计与样本
- 评估内容包括:是否符合GRADE体系、采用AGREE II评价质量、推荐强度与预设程序的一致性。
主要发现
- AGREE II总体评估均分为4.5分(7点Likert量表)。
- AGREE II领域均分:领域1(范围与目的)77%,领域2(利益相关者参与)54%,领域3(制定的严谨性)48%,领域4(呈现清晰性)78%,领域5(适用性)20%,领域6(编辑独立性)51%。
- 2部指南的针灸推荐强度被判定为低估。
- 部分指南存在AGREE II未考虑的基本问题。
关键数值与推荐
- AGREE II总体评估均分:4.5分(7点Likert量表)。
- AGREE II领域均分:领域1 77%、领域2 54%、领域3 48%、领域4 78%、领域5 20%、领域6 51%。
- 针灸推荐强度被低估的指南:2部。
临床怎么用
- 中医与中西医结合智能体医生在参考日本指南的针灸推荐时,需注意其方法学质量可能不高。
- 应关注指南是否采用GRADE体系及AGREE II评分,尤其是适用性领域得分较低。
- 对推荐强度可能被低估的指南,应结合其他高质量证据综合判断。
局限性
- 部分指南存在AGREE II未涵盖的基本问题。
- 各治疗领域存在技术问题,可能影响指南质量评估的全面性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The quality of clinical practice guidelines (CPGs) should be extensively evaluated. This study aimed to evaluate Japanese CPGs that include recommendations for acupuncture. METHODS: In a literature search, CPGs including recommendations for acupuncture published in Japan until October 2021 were sought. We assessed (1) whether the CPGs were developed in accordance with the Grading Recommendations Assessment, Development and Evaluation (GRADE) system, (2) the quality of the CPGs using the Appraisal of Guidelines for Research and Evaluation (AGREE) II, and (3) whether the strength of the recommendations for acupuncture was consistent with each CPG's predefined procedure. RESULTS: Seventeen CPGs including 23 recommendations in total were identified and assessed. (1) Three CPGs were in accordance with the GRADE system. (2) The mean score of overall assessment using AGREE II was 4.5 on a 7-point Likert scale. The mean domain scores were 77% for domain 1 (scope and purpose), 54% for domain 2 (stakeholder involvement), 48% for domain 3 (rigor of development), 78% for domain 4 (clarity of presentation), 20% for domain 5 (applicability), and 51% for domain 6 (editorial independence). (3) The strength of the recommendations for acupuncture in two CPGs was judged to be underestimated. Some of the CPGs contained elementary problems that were not considered in AGREE II. CONCLUSION: The methodological quality of Japanese CPGs including recommendations for acupuncture was not necessarily high. Since technical issues exist in each field of therapy, the respective experts should be involved in developing and reviewing CPGs to disseminate accurate health information.
引用
- Okawa Y, Yamashita H, Masuyama S, et al. Quality assessment of Japanese clinical practice guidelines including recommendations for acupuncture. Integr Med Res. 2022. PMID: 35340335. doi:10.1016/j.imr.2022.100838
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。