结缔组织病非药物干预的电子健康适用性:范围综述与描述性分析
本研究通过范围综述方法,系统梳理了系统性红斑狼疮(SLE)和系统性硬化症(SSc)患者非药物干预的内容、可行性及电子健康适用性。共纳入119篇文献,干预内容以多组分干预和物理锻炼为主,结局聚焦身体功能与张口度,未发现混合性结缔组织病相关干预。结果表明需发展个体化、多组分的非药物干预,并可通过电子健康形式提供。
要点
- SLE干预主要关注物理功能,SSc干预关注张口度和物理能力。
- 未发现针对混合性结缔组织病的非药物干预研究。
核心结论
- SLE和SSc的非药物干预内容因身体结构、活动限制和参与限制的差异而高度多样。
- 结果强调需要个体化、多组分的非药物干预,并可作为电子健康干预提供。
研究设计与样本
- 范围综述,检索8个数据库(2020年7月),纳入119篇文献。
- 使用TIDieR清单提取干预内容,采用桑基图和描述性统计分析。
主要发现
- 单一干预包括物理锻炼(SLE 16项,SSc 17项)、教练/咨询(SLE 11项,SSc 0项)和教育(SLE 2项,SSc 3项)。
- 主要结局涉及身体功能(SLE 1项,SSc 15项)、SSc张口度(4项)和身体能力(SLE 2项,SSc 1项)。
- 未发现混合性结缔组织病的干预研究。
关键数值与推荐
- 纳入119篇文献中,SLE研究24项(21.2%)来自美国,8项(7.1%)来自巴西;SSc研究16项(14.2%)来自美国,5项(4.4%)来自巴西,12项(10.6%)来自意大利。
- 物理锻炼单一干预:SLE 16项(14.2%),SSc 17项(15.0%)。
- 教练/咨询:SLE 11项(18.0%),SSc 0项(0%)。
- 教育:SLE 2项(1.8%),SSc 3项(2.7%)。
临床怎么用
- 临床可参考多组分和物理锻炼为主的非药物干预模式,为SLE和SSc患者制定个体化方案。
- 电子健康形式可作为非药物干预的潜在交付方式,需结合疾病特异性限制设计。
局限性
- 未报告混合性结缔组织病的非药物干预研究,证据覆盖不全。
- 干预内容异质性大,难以直接比较不同干预的效果。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: Non-pharmacological interventions support patients with connective tissue diseases to better cope with and self-manage their diseases. This study aimed to map existing evidence on non-pharmacological interventions in patients with systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE), systemic sclerosis (SSc) and mixed connective tissue diseases regarding content, feasibility and potential suitability in an e-health setting. METHODS: A literature search was performed in eight different databases in July 2020. The intervention's content was extracted using the 'Better reporting of interventions: template for intervention description and replication (TIDieR) checklist and guide'. A Sankey diagram and descriptive statistics were used to analyse the data and illustrate the relationships between the interventions. RESULTS: Of 8198 identified records, 119 papers were eligible. One hundred and four of them (87.4%) were conducted between 2000 and 2020, mainly in the USA (SLE n=24 (21.2%), SSc n=16 (14.2%)), Brazil (SLE n=8 (7.1%), SSc n=5 (4.4%)) and Italy (SLE n=0 (0%), SSc n=12 (10.6%)). Fifty-two studies (SLE n=24 (21.2%), SSc n=28 (24.8%)) used multicomponent interventions. The single interventions were physical exercises (SLE n=16 (14.2%), SSc n=17 (15.0%)), coaching/counselling (SLE n=11 (18.0%), SSc n=0 (0%)) and education (SLE n=2 (1.8%), SSc n=3 (2.7%)). Primary outcomes focused on physical function (SLE n=1 (0.9%), SSc n=15 (13.3%)), mouth opening in SSc (n=4 (5.9%)) and physical capacity (SLE n=2 (1.8%), SSc n=1 (0.9%)). No interventions for mixed connective tissue disease were found. CONCLUSION: There was a great variety in the intervention's content due to differences in body structure, activity limitations and participation restrictions in SLE and SSc. These results highlight the need for personalised, multicomponent, non-pharmacological interventions, which could be delivered as e-health interventions.
引用
- Ritschl V, Ferreira RJO, Santos EJF, et al. Suitability for e-health of non-pharmacological interventions in connective tissue diseases: scoping review with a descriptive analysis. RMD Open. 2021. PMID: 34326205. doi:10.1136/rmdopen-2021-001710
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。