新型荧光光学成像评分系统评估类风湿关节炎手部滑膜炎:有效性与超声一致性
该研究开发并验证了一种新的半定量荧光光学成像(FOI)评分系统——FOIE-GRAS,用于评估手部滑膜炎。结果显示FOIE-GRAS具有良好至优秀的信度,与超声中度一致,反应性良好,且健康对照评分显著低于RA患者。
要点
- FOIE-GRAS是一种可行的半定量FOI评分系统,用于评估RA手部滑膜炎。
- FOIE-GRAS信度良好至优秀(基线ICC 0.76-0.98),与超声中度一致(ICC 0.30-0.54)。
- FOIE-GRAS反应性良好(标准化反应均数>0.80),与DAS28-CRP中度相关。
核心结论
- FOIE-GRAS可可行且可靠地评估RA滑膜炎,与超声和DAS28-CRP中度相关,反应性良好。
研究设计与样本
- 所有FOI图像由两名读者评分,评估扫描间、读者内和读者间信度,以及FOIE-GRAS与超声的一致性和反应性。
主要发现
- FOIE-GRAS将滑膜炎定义为早期增强,评分基于3秒后特定关节区域覆盖程度(0-3分)。
- 基线所有评分的扫描间、读者内和读者间ICC为0.76-0.98(良好至优秀),变化值的ICC为0.65-0.76(中等至良好)。
- FOIE-GRAS总分与超声中度一致(ICC 0.30-0.54),标准化反应均数>0.80(良好),与临床关节评估和DAS28-CRP中度相关。
- 健康对照的FOIE-GRAS评分[中位数1(IQR 0,4)]显著低于RA患者[11(6,19)]。
关键数值与推荐
- FOIE-GRAS滑膜炎定义:早期增强,评分基于3秒后特定关节区域覆盖程度(0-3分)。
- 信度:基线ICC 0.76-0.98,变化值ICC 0.65-0.76;与超声一致性ICC 0.30-0.54;标准化反应均数>0.80。
- 健康对照评分中位数1(IQR 0,4),RA患者11(6,19)。
临床怎么用
- FOIE-GRAS可作为RA手部滑膜炎的可行、可靠评估工具,读片时间约133秒。
- 其与超声和DAS28-CRP中度相关,反应性良好,可用于监测治疗反应。
局限性
- 与超声的一致性仅为中度(ICC 0.30-0.54)。
- 读片时间中位数为133秒,可能影响临床推广效率。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: To develop and validate a new semiquantitative fluorescence optical imaging (FOI) scoring system-the FOI Enhancement-Generated RA Score (FOIE-GRAS) for synovitis assessment in the hand. METHODS: The development of FOIE-GRAS was based on consensus of four experts in musculoskeletal imaging. Forty-six RA patients, eligible for treatment intensification and with ≥1 clinically swollen joints in the hands, and 11 healthy controls were included. FOI, ultrasound and clinical assessment of both hands were obtained at baseline and for RA patients after 3 and 6 months' follow-up. Twenty RA patients had an FOI rescan after 4 h. Synovitis was scored using FOIE-GRAS and the OMERACT ultrasound synovitis scoring system. All FOI images were scored by two readers. Inter-scan, inter- and intra-reader reliability were determined. Furthermore, FOIE-GRAS agreement with ultrasound and responsiveness was assessed. RESULTS: FOIE-GRAS synovitis was defined as early enhancement, and scores were based on the degree of coverage of the specific joint region after 3 s (0-3). Inter-scan, intra- and inter-reader intraclass correlations coefficients (ICC) were good to excellent for all baseline scores (0.76-0.98) and moderate to good for change (0.65-76).The FOIE-GRAS had moderate agreement with ultrasound (ICC 0.30-0.54) for total score, a good standardized response mean (>0.80), and moderate correlation with clinical joint assessment and DAS28-CRP. The median (interquartile range) reading time per FOI examination was 133 (109, 161) s. Scores were significantly lower in controls [1 (0, 4)] than RA patients [11 (6, 19)]. CONCLUSION: The FOIE-GRAS offers a feasible and reliable assessment of synovitis in RA, with a moderate correlation with ultrasound and DAS28-CRP, and good responsiveness.
引用
- Ammitzbøll-Danielsen M, Glinatsi D, Terslev L, et al. A novel fluorescence optical imaging scoring system for hand synovitis in rheumatoid arthritis-validity and agreement with ultrasound. Rheumatology (Oxford). 2022. PMID: 33890623. doi:10.1093/rheumatology/keab377
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。