系统性硬化症指端溃疡超声成像:系统文献综述与验证步骤
该研究通过系统文献综述评估超声用于系统性硬化症(SSc)皮肤溃疡的验证程度,检索Cochrane Library、Web of Science和PubMed至2020年4月1日,纳入6篇文献。结果显示超声对SSc皮肤溃疡具有表面效度、内容效度、标准效度、反应性和合理可行性,但结构效度、信度和区分度仍需进一步验证。
要点
- 超声评估SSc皮肤溃疡已部分验证,具备表面、内容、标准效度及反应性。
- 仍需进一步验证结构效度、信度和区分度。
- 可行性在多项研究中得到展示。
核心结论
- 超声用于SSc皮肤溃疡的评估已获得部分验证,具备表面效度、内容效度、标准效度、反应性和合理可行性。
- 仍需进一步验证结构效度、信度和区分度。
研究设计与样本
- 系统文献综述,检索Cochrane Library、Web of Science和PubMed从建库至2020年4月1日的文献。
- 纳入标准为年龄超过16岁的SSc患者、使用超声机器评估SSc相关皮肤溃疡的手稿,排除动物模型、非SSc疾病和静脉性溃疡的论文。
- 由两名独立评估者提取数据,分歧时咨询第三作者。
主要发现
- 共识别308篇手稿,其中6篇发表的手稿/海报符合纳入/排除标准并被提取。
- 发现表面效度。
- 三项研究制定了跨患者的SSc溃疡超声定义(内容效度)。
- 一项研究评估了超声图像与临床评估之间的一致性。
- 一项研究显示了标准效度,且超声检测到SSc皮肤溃疡对治疗的反应性改善(对变化的敏感性)。
临床怎么用
- 超声可作为评估SSc皮肤溃疡的部分验证工具,具有表面、内容、标准效度和反应性及合理可行性。
- 在临床应用中需注意其结构效度、信度和区分度尚未充分验证。
局限性
- 仅纳入6篇文献,证据基础有限。
- 结构效度、信度和区分度尚未验证。
- 检索截止至2020年4月1日,可能未涵盖后续研究。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION/BACKGROUND: Skin ulcers are a complex array of clinical manifestations of systemic sclerosis (SSc) and are often difficult to treat. However, the definition of SSc-skin ulcers has to date not been promising, demonstrating poor reliability and accuracy. There are emerging data that ultrasound has significant potential to evaluate SSc-skin ulcers. OBJECTIVE: To perform a systematic literature review (SLR) to understand the degree to which ultrasound of SSc skin ulcers has been validated according to OMERACT criteria. METHODS: In a SLR, we investigated the Cochrane Library, Web of Science and Pubmed databases for manuscripts from inception to 1st April 2020. Inclusion and exclusion criteria included manuscripts on SSc patients aged over 16 years, performing SSc-related skin ulcer evaluation with ultrasound machines. Papers on animal model, diseases other than SSc, venous ulcers were excluded. Data extraction used a uniform case report form which collected data on patient demographics, disease activity, description of the ultrasound machine and procedures and the degree to which domains of validity were fulfilled. Manuscript evaluation and extraction was performed by two independent assessors, with a third author being consulted in case of disagreement. RESULTS: amongst 308 manuscripts that were identified, 6 published manuscripts/ posters fulfilled the inclusion/exclusion criteria and were extracted. Face validity was found. Three studies developed an US definition of SSc-ulcers across patients (content validity); one study evaluated the concordance between US image and clinical assessment. Criterion validity was shown by one study and ultrasound detected improvement (sensitivity to change) of SSc-skin ulcer in response to therapy. Feasibility was demonstrated by US use for skin ulcers in multiple settings (the 6 manuuscripts/posters). CONCLUSION: This systematic literature review shows that ultrasound for skin ulcers in SSc has been partially validated. It has face, content, criterion validity, responsiveness and reasonable feasibility. Further validation for construct validity, reliability and discrimination is required.
引用
- Suliman YA, Bruni C, Hughes M, et al. Ultrasonographic imaging of systemic sclerosis digital ulcers: A systematic literature review and validation steps. Semin Arthritis Rheum. 2021. PMID: 33677309. doi:10.1016/j.semarthrit.2021.02.008
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。