双能CT与超声单独或联合诊断痛风的准确性前瞻性研究
该前瞻性研究纳入147例门诊痛风疑诊患者,以关节液尿酸盐结晶为金标准,比较双能CT(DECT)与超声单独或联合诊断痛风的准确性。结果显示足踝或膝关节DECT单独诊断的总体准确性最佳,DECT与超声联合或增加关节部位成像未提高总体诊断准确性。
要点
- 足踝DECT诊断痛风敏感度87%、特异度100%、AUC 0.93。
- 膝关节DECT敏感度91%、特异度87%、AUC 0.89。
- DECT联合超声或增加关节成像未提高总体准确性。
核心结论
- 足踝或膝关节DECT单独诊断痛风的总体准确性最佳。
- DECT与超声联合或增加关节部位成像未提高总体诊断准确性。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性收集三级医院风湿免疫门诊数据,共147例患者提供数据。
- 以关节液尿酸盐结晶为金标准,改良2015 ACR-EULAR痛风分类标准为银标准,按足踝和膝关节部位评估DECT与超声单独或联合的诊断准确性。
主要发现
- 147例中48例(33%)行关节液分析,38例尿酸盐结晶阳性,平均症状持续时间9.2年。
- 100例(68%)符合银标准。
- 相比金标准,足踝DECT、足踝超声、膝关节DECT、膝关节超声的敏感度分别为87%、84%、91%、58%。
- 相比金标准,足踝DECT、足踝超声、膝关节DECT、膝关节超声的特异度分别为100%、60%、87%、80%。
- 相比金标准,足踝DECT、足踝超声、膝关节DECT、膝关节超声的AUC分别为0.93、0.72、0.89、0.66。
关键数值与推荐
- 金标准:关节滑液中证实单钠尿酸盐结晶。
- 银标准:改良(排除DECT和超声)2015 ACR-EULAR痛风分类标准。
- 足踝DECT阳性预测值100%、阴性预测值67%;膝关节DECT阳性预测值97%、阴性预测值70%。
- 足踝超声阳性预测值89%、阴性预测值50%;膝关节超声阳性预测值92%、阴性预测值33%。
临床怎么用
- 对于疑诊痛风患者,可优先考虑足踝或膝关节DECT单独检查以提升诊断准确性。
- DECT与超声联合或增加关节部位成像未显示总体诊断准确性增益。
局限性
- 仅48例(33%)行关节液分析,金标准验证样本有限。
- 银标准结果重复验证时数值较低。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To examine the accuracy of dual-energy CT (DECT) vs ultrasound or their combination for the diagnosis of gout. METHODS: Using prospectively collected data from an outpatient rheumatology clinic at a tertiary-care hospital, we examined the diagnostic accuracy of either modality alone or their combination, by anatomical site (feet/ankles and/or knees), for the diagnosis of gout. We used two standards: (i) demonstration of monosodium urate crystals in synovial fluid (gold), and (ii) modified (excluding DECT and ultrasound) 2015 ACR-EULAR gout classification criteria (silver). RESULTS: Of the 147 patients who provided data, 48 (33%) had synovial fluid analysis performed (38 were monosodium urate-crystal positive) and mean symptom duration was 9.2 years. One hundred (68%) patients met the silver standard. Compared with the gold standard, diagnostic accuracy statistics for feet/ankles DECT, feet/ankles ultrasound, knees DECT and knees ultrasound were, respectively: sensitivity: 87%, 84%, 91% and 58%; specificity: 100%, 60%, 87% and 80%; positive predictive value: 100%, 89%, 97% and 92%; negative predictive value: 67%, 50%, 70% and 33%; area under the receiver operating characteristic curve: 0.93, 0.72, 0.89 and 0.66. Combining feet/ankles DECT with ultrasound or knees DECT with ultrasound led to a numerically higher sensitivity compared with DECT alone, but overall accuracy was lower. Similarly, combining imaging knees to feet/ankles also yielded a numerically higher sensitivity and negative predictive values compared with feet/ankles DECT alone, without differences in overall accuracy. Findings were replicated compared with the silver standard, but with lower numbers. CONCLUSIONS: Feet/ankles or knees DECT alone had the best overall accuracy for gout diagnosis. The DECT-US combination or multiple joint imaging offered no additional increase in overall diagnostic accuracy.
引用
- Singh JA, Budzik JF, Becce F, et al. Dual-energy computed tomography vs ultrasound, alone or combined, for the diagnosis of gout: a prospective study of accuracy. Rheumatology (Oxford). 2021. PMID: 33410491. doi:10.1093/rheumatology/keaa923
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。