血管超声诊断巨细胞动脉炎:基于标准化培训项目的可靠性与一致性研究
这项前瞻性、非干预性观察性队列研究在丹麦三个中心纳入112例疑似巨细胞动脉炎(GCA)患者,评估接受标准化培训(含设备调整)的风湿科医生行血管超声的可靠性。以盲法外部专家判读为金标准,GCA总体诊断的观察者间一致率为95-96%,平均kappa值0.88-0.92(95%CI 0.78至0.99),各动脉检查平均kappa 0.86-1.00,结论认为该培训项目或可适用于临床实践推广血管超声。
要点
- 112例疑似GCA患者中,外部专家判读66例存在血管炎改变。
- GCA总体诊断观察者间一致率95-96%,平均kappa 0.88-0.92。
- 颞动脉、面动脉、颈总动脉及腋动脉超声平均kappa 0.86-1.00。
核心结论
- 超声培训项目使受训者在疑似GCA患者中与专家达成极好的一致性,或可适用于临床实践中推广血管超声。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性、非干预性观察性队列研究,在丹麦三个中心纳入112例疑似GCA患者。
- 由5名具有8年以上肌肉骨骼超声经验但此前无血管超声经验的风湿科医生,经含设备调整的标准化培训项目后行超声检查。
- 图像先由操作者判读,随后由盲法外部专家判读作为金标准。
主要发现
- 外部专家判读66例存在血管炎改变,其中45例仅累及颅部血管,14例同时累及颅部和大血管,7例为孤立性大血管炎。
- GCA总体诊断、颅部GCA及大血管GCA的观察者间一致率为95-96%,平均kappa值0.88-0.92(95%CI 0.78至0.99)。
- 颞动脉、面动脉、颈总动脉和腋动脉各动脉超声检查的平均kappa值为0.86-1.00。
关键数值与推荐
- GCA总体诊断观察者间一致率95-96%,平均kappa值0.88-0.92(95%CI 0.78至0.99)。
- 各动脉(颞动脉、面动脉、颈总动脉、腋动脉)超声检查平均kappa值0.86-1.00。
- 外部专家判读66例有血管炎改变:45例仅颅部受累,14例颅部和大血管均受累,7例孤立性大血管炎。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为该超声培训项目或可适用于临床实践中推广血管超声。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the impact of a standardised training programme including equipment adjustment for experienced musculoskeletal ultrasonographers without previous experience in vascular ultrasound (US) on the reliability of US in the diagnosis of giant cell arteritis (GCA). METHODS: In this prospective, non-interventional observational cohort study, patients suspected of GCA were evaluated by US by one of five rheumatologists with long-standing experience in musculoskeletal US (>8 years), trained using a standardised training programme including equipment adjustment. Images of cranial and large vessels were subsequently evaluated first by the performing ultrasonographer and thereafter by a blinded external expert (gold standard). RESULTS: In three Danish centres, 112 patients suspected of GCA were included. According to the external expert, vasculitis changes were seen in 66 patients, in 45 of them with only cranial involvement, in 14 with both cranial and large vessel involvement, while in seven patients isolated large vessel vasculitis was found. The reliability was excellent between the local ultrasonographer and the US expert for the overall GCA diagnosis regarding the diagnosis of cranial and for large vessel GCA, with an interobserver agreement of 95-96%, mean kappa values of 0.88-0.92 (95% CI 0.78 to 0.99). Excellent reliability (mean kappa 0.86-1.00) was also found for the US examination of the individual arteries (temporal, facial, common carotid and axillary). CONCLUSION: The US training programme resulted in excellent agreement between trainees and an expert in patients suspected of GCA and may thus be applicable for implementation of vascular US in clinical practice.
引用
- Chrysidis S, Terslev L, Christensen R, et al. Vascular ultrasound for the diagnosis of giant cell arteritis: a reliability and agreement study based on a standardised training programme. RMD Open. 2020. PMID: 32978303. doi:10.1136/rmdopen-2020-001337
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。