在线自我转诊工具与医生转诊策略用于早期识别高概率中轴型脊柱关节炎患者的比较
该研究纳入361例背痛患者,比较在线自我转诊(OSR)工具与柏林医生转诊工具对中轴型脊柱关节炎(axial SpA)的识别效果。OSR组axial SpA比例为19.4%,医生转诊组为39.2%;OSR组患者更多为HLA-B27阴性、女性及放射学阴性阶段,但两组疾病负担相似。在保持原始策略敏感性至少90%的约束下,优化OSR工具需满足≥2项炎症性背痛(IBP)参数加≥1项其他SpA参数(除两个主干参数外)。
要点
- OSR组axial SpA比例为19.4%,高于慢性背痛中假设的5%患病率。
- 医生转诊组axial SpA比例为39.2%,高于OSR组。
- 优化OSR策略需≥2项IBP参数加≥1项其他SpA参数(除主干参数外)。
核心结论
- 尽管医生转诊策略表现更好,但自我转诊患者中axial SpA比例(19.4%)明显高于慢性背痛中假设的5%患病率。
- 基于数据驱动方法,若除主干参数外还需至少两项IBP参数加一项额外SpA参数,OSR策略的表现可进一步改善。
- OSR工具可在专科中心作为医生转诊策略的补充,以改善早期诊断并提高对axial SpA的认识。
研究设计与样本
- 研究纳入背痛患者,若满足OSR工具要求或由医生使用柏林转诊工具转诊则入选。
- 专科中心的风湿科医生对所有患者进行结构化评估,最终诊断axial SpA或无axial SpA。
- 共纳入361例连续患者,其中180例通过OSR,181例通过柏林转诊工具。
- 研究尝试在原始策略敏感性至少90%的约束下最大化特异性,以优化OSR工具。
主要发现
- 自我转诊组35例(19.4%)最终诊断为axial SpA,医生转诊组71例(39.2%)最终诊断为axial SpA。
- 与医生转诊工具来源的axial SpA患者相比,OSR组的axial SpA患者更常为HLA-B27阴性、女性,且更常处于放射学阴性阶段。
- 两组axial SpA患者的疾病负担相似。
- 根据预设选择标准,识别出≥2项IBP参数加≥1项其他SpA参数(除两个主干参数外)的优化组合。
关键数值与推荐
- OSR组axial SpA比例为19.4%(35/180),医生转诊组为39.2%(71/181)。
- 优化OSR工具需满足≥2项IBP参数和≥1项其他SpA参数(除两个主干参数外),并保持敏感性至少90%。
临床怎么用
- OSR工具可在专科中心与医生转诊策略联合使用,以改善早期诊断并提高对axial SpA的认识。
- 对于自我转诊的背痛患者,若满足≥2项IBP参数加≥1项其他SpA参数(除主干参数外),可考虑进一步评估axial SpA。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: The diagnostic delay in axial spondyloarthritis (axial SpA) remains unacceptably high, with one of the reasons being a late referral. Structured physician-based referral programs are able to improve early diagnosis, but lack of implementation is still an issue. The objective of this study was to evaluate an online self-referral (OSR) tool for patients with back pain and to compare it to an established physician-based referral tool. METHODS: Patients with back pain were included if they either fulfilled the requirements of the OSR tool or were referred by a physician using the Berlin referral tool. Rheumatologists in the specialized center performed a structured assessment in all patients that resulted in the final diagnosis of axial SpA / no axial SpA. Furthermore, we attempted to optimize the OSR tool in terms of maximizing the specificity constrained by a sensitivity of at least 90% of the original strategy. RESULTS: 361 consecutive patients (180 via the OSR and 181 via the Berlin referral tool) were included in the study. A total of 35 patients (19.4%) in the self-referral group and 71 patients (39.2%) in the physician-referral group were finally diagnosed with axial SpA. Axial SpA patients from the OSR group were more often HLA-B27 negative, females, and were more frequently at a non-radiographic stage as compared to axial SpA patients who came via the physician-based tool. Both groups had, however, a similar disease burden. According to the pre-defined selection criterion we identified an optimized combination of ≥2 IBP parameters and ≥1 other SpA parameters (in addition to both stem parameters). CONCLUSIONS: Despite the better performance of the physician-based referral strategy, the proportion of axial SpA among self-referred patients (19.4%) was clearly higher than the assumed 5% prevalence of axial SpA in patients with chronic back pain. Based on our data driven approach the performance of the OSR strategy could be further improved if at least two IBP parameters plus one additional SpA parameter had to be present in addition to the stem parameters. The OSR tool can be used in specialized centers in addition to a physician-based referral strategy to improve early diagnosis and to increase awareness of axial SpA.
引用
- Proft F, Spiller L, Redeker I, et al. Comparison of an online self-referral tool with a physician-based referral strategy for early recognition of patients with a high probability of axial spa. Semin Arthritis Rheum. 2020. PMID: 32911279. doi:10.1016/j.semarthrit.2020.07.018
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。