EULAR/eumusc.net类风湿关节炎诊疗标准:35个欧洲国家患者与风湿科医生对重要性与实施差距的横断面分析
该研究基于EULAR/eumusc.net制定的20条以用户为中心的RA诊疗标准(SoCs),在35个欧洲国家分别调查1873例患者和1131名风湿科医生对每条标准的重要性、实施水平及障碍的评分(0-10分),计算实施差距。结果显示,从超过20%患者角度看,20条标准中有19条存在实施问题,而医生角度仅10条;患者报告的最常见障碍为部分标准缺乏相关性(71%)和专业人员时间有限(66%)。
要点
- 20条RA诊疗标准中,超过20%患者认为19条存在实施问题,医生仅认为10条有问题。
- 患者报告的最常见实施障碍为部分标准缺乏相关性(71%)和专业人员时间有限(66%)。
- GDP较低国家和非欧盟国家的风湿科医生更可能在20条标准中的15条报告问题性差距。
核心结论
- 在RA诊疗的多个关键方面报告了许多问题性实施差距,需要更多努力实施EULAR诊疗标准。
研究设计与样本
- 横断面调查设计,在50个欧洲国家中拟对患者和风湿科医生进行调查,实际有26个国家提供1873例患者数据、31个国家提供1131名风湿科医生数据。
- 调查内容为每条诊疗标准的重要性、实施水平及障碍(仅患者)评分(0-10分,10最高),并计算实施差距(0-100,最大差距)。
主要发现
- 从超过20%患者角度看,20条诊疗标准中有19条存在问题;从医生角度看,仅10条标准存在问题。
- GDP较低国家和非欧盟国家的风湿科医生在20条标准中的15条更可能报告问题性差距,而患者间几乎无差异。
- 患者报告的最常见实施障碍为部分标准缺乏相关性(71%)和专业人员时间有限(66%)。
关键数值与推荐
- 诊疗标准共20条,覆盖16个诊疗领域,以用户为中心制定。
- 问题性差距定义为差距≥30且重要性≥6且实施<6;强障碍定义为障碍评分≥6。
- 实施差距计算为(10减实际实施评分)乘以重要性评分,范围0-100,100为最大差距。
临床怎么用
- 风湿免疫科医生应关注患者视角中实施不足的诊疗标准,尤其需评估标准的相关性和专业时间限制对实施的影响。
- 在GDP较低和非欧盟国家,医生应更重视识别并改善RA诊疗标准的实施差距。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: As part of European League against Rheumatism (EULAR)/European Musculoskeletal Conditions Surveillance and Information Network, 20 user-focused standards of care (SoCs) for rheumatoid arthritis (RA) addressing 16 domains of care were developed. This study aimed to explore gaps in implementation of these SoCs across Europe. METHODS: Two cross-sectional surveys on the importance, level of and barriers (patients only) to implementation of each SoC (0-10, 10 highest) were designed to be conducted among patients and rheumatologists in 50 European countries. Care gaps were calculated as the difference between the actual and maximum possible score for implementation (ie, 10) multiplied by the care importance score, resulting in care gaps (0-100, maximal gap). Factors associated with the problematic care gaps (ie, gap≥30 and importance≥6 and implementation<6) and strong barriers (≥6) were further analysed in multilevel logistic regression models. RESULTS: Overall, 26 and 31 countries provided data from 1873 patients and 1131 rheumatologists, respectively. 19 out of 20 SoCs were problematic from the perspectives of more than 20% of patients, while this was true for only 10 SoCs for rheumatologists. Rheumatologists in countries with lower gross domestic product and non-European Union countries were more likely to report problematic gaps in 15 of 20 SoCs, while virtually no differences were observed among patients. Lack of relevance of some SoCs (71%) and limited time of professionals (66%) were the most frequent implementation barriers identified by patients. CONCLUSIONS: Many problematic gaps were reported across several essential aspects of RA care. More efforts need to be devoted to implementation of EULAR SoCs.
引用
- Meisters R, Putrik P, Ramiro S, et al. EULAR/eumusc.net standards of care for rheumatoid arthritis: cross-sectional analyses of importance, level of implementation and care gaps experienced by patients and rheumatologists across 35 European countries. Ann Rheum Dis. 2020. PMID: 32873554. doi:10.1136/annrheumdis-2020-217520
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。