欧洲风湿病学培训中能力评估策略的定性研究
该定性研究通过在线焦点小组访谈了五个欧洲国家(丹麦、荷兰、斯洛文尼亚、西班牙、英国)的风湿病学培训师和受训者,探讨能力评估的当前方法与优先事项。研究发现多数小组将提供频繁的形成性反馈列为最高优先,并指出需要改进档案袋评估方法、保护观察反馈时间以及系统化纳入团队合作与职业素养评估。
要点
- 五个欧洲国家在能力评估上存在国家或机构层面的标准化差异。
- 多数焦点小组将提供频繁的形成性反馈作为最高优先事项。
- 需要改进档案袋评估方法、保护观察反馈时间及系统化纳入团队合作与职业素养评估。
核心结论
- 研究呈现了五个欧洲国家风湿病学能力评估的当前实践及培训师与受训者优先事项的 underlying rationale。
- 该工作将为欧洲抗风湿病联盟(EULAR)关于风湿病学培训中能力评估的考虑要点提供信息。
研究设计与样本
- 采用定性方法,在丹麦、荷兰、斯洛文尼亚、西班牙和英国五个国家分别对风湿病学培训师和受训者进行在线焦点小组访谈。
- 共26名参与者(12名培训师,14名受训者)参与了九次在线焦点小组(每国2次,斯洛文尼亚1次联合),总计12小时在线讨论。
- 基于独立问卷回答,由焦点小组制定、修改和验证当前能力评估实践的总结,并使用9钻石技术进行优先排序。
主要发现
- 描述了荷兰、英国的国家级标准化方法以及西班牙、斯洛文尼亚、丹麦的机构级标准化方法。
- 多数小组将向受训者提供频繁的形成性反馈以促进发展作为最高优先事项。
- 多数讨论指出需要改进,特别是在开发贴近临床实践的简化档案袋方法、保护质量观察和反馈的时间,以及采用系统化方法将团队合作和职业素养纳入评估系统方面。
临床怎么用
- 在风湿病学培训中应优先提供频繁的形成性反馈以促进受训者发展。
- 应开发贴近临床实践的简化档案袋评估方法,并保护质量观察和反馈的时间。
- 应采用系统化方法将团队合作和职业素养纳入评估系统。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: To gain insight into current methods and practices for the assessment of competences during rheumatology training, and to explore the underlying priorities and rationales for competence assessment. METHODS: We used a qualitative approach through online focus groups (FGs) of rheumatology trainers and trainees, separately. The study included five countries-Denmark, the Netherlands, Slovenia, Spain and the United Kingdom. A summary of current practices of assessment of competences was developed, modified and validated by the FGs based on an independent response to a questionnaire. A prioritising method (9 Diamond technique) was then used to identify and justify key assessment priorities. RESULTS: Overall, 26 participants (12 trainers, 14 trainees) participated in nine online FGs (2 per country, Slovenia 1 joint), totalling 12 hours of online discussion. Strong nationally (the Netherlands, UK) or institutionally (Spain, Slovenia, Denmark) standardised approaches were described. Most groups identified providing frequent formative feedback to trainees for developmental purposes as the highest priority. Most discussions identified a need for improvement, particularly in developing streamlined approaches to portfolios that remain close to clinical practice, protecting time for quality observation and feedback, and adopting systematic approaches to incorporating teamwork and professionalism into assessment systems. CONCLUSION: This paper presents a clearer picture of the current practice on the assessment of competences in rheumatology in five European countries and the underlying rationale of trainers' and trainees' priorities. This work will inform EULAR Points-to-Consider for the assessment of competences in rheumatology training across Europe.
引用
- Najm A, Alunno A, Sivera F, et al. Strategies for the assessment of competences during rheumatology training across Europe: results of a qualitative study. RMD Open. 2020. PMID: 32641449. doi:10.1136/rmdopen-2020-001183
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。