文献速递类风湿关节炎

类风湿关节炎缓解定义中患者总体评估阈值的优化探索

Testing different thresholds for patient global assessment in defining remission for rheumatoid arthritis: are the current ACR/EULAR Boolean criteria optimal?
PubMed 文献 · Ann Rheum Dis · 2020-02-05

本研究利用六项随机对照试验数据,评估ACR/EULAR Boolean缓解定义中患者总体评估(PGA)不同阈值(1.5至3.0及省略PGA)在早期和established RA中的效用。结果显示PGA阈值提高可增加缓解比例,但与SDAI缓解一致性在PGA≤1.5和2.0时最佳,且不同阈值对12个月影像学进展无影响,但HAQ≤0.5达标比例随阈值提高而下降。

要点

  • PGA阈值1.5 cm与SDAI缓解一致性最高,整数2.0 cm表现相似。
  • 提高PGA阈值至3.0或省略PGA未影响12个月影像学进展。
  • PGA阈值越高,达到HAQ≤0.5功能结局的比例越低。

核心结论

  • 将PGA阈值提高至1.5 cm可使Boolean缓解与基于指数的缓解定义高度一致,整数阈值2.0 cm表现相似。

研究设计与样本

  • 基于六项早期和established RA随机对照试验数据,纳入1680例早期RA和920例established RA患者。
  • 将PGA 0-10评分阈值从1逐步提高至3(步长0.5,Boolean1.5至Boolean3.0),并设置完全省略PGA(BooleanX),在6和12个月评估。
  • 采用kappa、递归分割(CART)和ROC分析评估与SDAI缓解定义的一致性,并探索各定义对1年后功能和影像学结局的影响。

主要发现

  • 6个月时达到Boolean缓解的比例随PGA阈值提高而增加:早期RA从12.4%升至19.7%,established RA从5.9%升至12.3%。
  • 与SDAI缓解一致性最佳出现在PGA阈值1.5和2.0,更高PGA阈值一致性下降;CART显示最佳一致性在PGA≤1.6 cm,PGA≤1.5的敏感性为95%。
  • 6个月时改变PGA阈值不影响12个月影像学进展(Boolean、1.5、2.0、2.5、3.0、BooleanX的平均ꙙsmTSS分别为0.35±5.4、0.38±5.14、0.41±5.1、0.37±4.9、0.34±4.9、0.27±4.7)。
  • 达到HAQ≤0.5的比例随PGA阈值提高而下降:对应上述定义分别为90.2%、87.9%、85.2%、81.1%、80.7%和73.1%。

关键数值与推荐

  • 与SDAI缓解一致性最佳在PGA≤1.5和≤2.0;CART最佳一致性在PGA≤1.6 cm;PGA≤1.5的敏感性为95%。
  • 12个月平均ꙙsmTSS在各Boolean定义间无显著差异(数值见 findings)。
  • HAQ≤0.5达标比例随PGA阈值提高而降低(数值见 findings)。

临床怎么用

  • 在临床实践中,采用PGA阈值1.5 cm或2.0 cm可在保持与SDAI缓解一致性的同时提高Boolean缓解的达标率。
  • 提高PGA阈值可能以功能结局(HAQ≤0.5)达标比例下降为代价,需权衡缓解定义严格性与患者功能状态。

局限性

  • 研究基于随机对照试验数据,结论外推至真实世界需谨慎。
  • 未报告不同阈值对长期(超过1年)结局的影响。
  • 未涉及其他患者报告结局或共病对PGA的影响。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVES: This study aimed to evaluate different patient global assessment (PGA) cut-offs required in the American College of Rheumatology/European League Against Rheumatism (ACR/EULAR) Boolean remission definition for their utility in rheumatoid arthritis (RA). METHODS: We used data from six randomised controlled trials in early and established RA. We increased the threshold for the 0-10 score for PGA gradually from 1 to 3 in steps of 0.5 (Boolean1.5 to Boolean3.0) and omitted PGA completely (BooleanX) at 6 and 12 months. Agreement with the index-based (Simplified Disease Activity Index (SDAI)) remission definition was analysed using kappa, recursive partitioning (classification and regression tree (CART)) and receiver operating characteristics. The impact of achieving each definition on functional and radiographic outcomes after 1 year was explored. RESULTS: Data from 1680 patients with early RA and 920 patients with established RA were included. The proportion of patients achieving Boolean remission increased with higher thresholds for PGA from 12.4% to 19.7% in early and 5.9% to 12.3% in established RA at 6 months. Best agreement with SDAI remission occurred at PGA cut-offs of 1.5 and 2.0, while agreement decreased with higher PGA (CART: optimal agreement at PGA≤1.6 cm; sensitivity of PGA≤1.5 95%). Changing PGA thresholds at 6 months did not affect radiographic progression at 12 months (mean ꙙsmTSS for Boolean, 1.5, 2.0, 2.5, 3.0, BooleanX: 0.35±5.4, 0.38±5.14, 0.41±5.1, 0.37±4.9, 0.34±4.9, 0.27±4.7). However, the proportion attaining HAQ≤0.5 was 90.2%, 87.9%, 85.2%, 81.1%, 80.7% and 73.1% for the respective Boolean definitions. CONCLUSION: Increasing the PGA cut-off to 1.5 cm would provide high consistency between Boolean with the index-based remission; the integer cut-off of 2.0 cm performed similarly.

来源:Ann Rheum Dis,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Studenic P, Felson D, de Wit M, et al. Testing different thresholds for patient global assessment in defining remission for rheumatoid arthritis: are the current ACR/EULAR Boolean criteria optimal? Ann Rheum Dis. 2020. PMID: 32024651. doi:10.1136/annrheumdis-2019-216529

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。