类风湿关节炎登记研究中功能与疾病活动度缺失数据的插补方法比较
结果显示,插补基线缺失值时LME3和MICE能正确估计缓解率和低疾病活动度率;插补随访缺失值时NAO对平均疾病活动度及缓解率的估计偏倚最小,且不受失访偏倚影响。
要点
- 插补基线缺失数据时,LME3和MICE可正确估计缓解率与低疾病活动度率。
- 插补随访缺失数据时,NAO对平均疾病活动度和缓解率的估计偏倚最小。
- 上述结果不受失访偏倚存在与否的影响。
核心结论
- 在大型活动性RA患者登记研究中,随访缺失数据可考虑使用NAO等简单方法插补,基线数据可使用混合效应回归或多重插补。
研究设计与样本
- 缺失值按随机删除或按预测的失访偏倚删除两种方式生成。
- 插补方法包括:向前插补(LOCF、线性向前外推)、双向插补(NAO、线性外推、多项式外推)和多体模型(LME3、MICE)。
主要发现
- 插补基线缺失值时,所有方法均同等程度低估真实值,但LME3和MICE正确估计了缓解率和低疾病活动度率。
- 插补6、12或24个月随访缺失值时,NAO对平均疾病活动度和相应缓解率的估计偏倚最小。
- 失访偏倚的存在未影响上述结果。
关键数值与推荐
- 功能评估采用健康评估问卷(HAQ)。
- 疾病活动度评估采用疾病活动度评分-28(DAS28)和临床疾病活动度指数(CDAI)。
- 插补性能通过插补后平均结局值、缓解率和低疾病活动度率与真实值的差异评估。
临床怎么用
- 在大型活动性RA登记研究中,插补随访缺失数据可优先考虑NAO等简单方法。
- 插补基线缺失数据可考虑使用混合效应回归(如LME3)或多重插补(如MICE)。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To compare several methods of missing data imputation for function (Health Assessment Questionnaire) and for disease activity (Disease Activity Score-28 and Clinical Disease Activity Index) in rheumatoid arthritis (RA) patients. METHODS: One thousand RA patients from observational cohort studies with complete data for function and disease activity at baseline, 6, 12 and 24 months were selected to conduct a simulation study. Values were deleted at random or following a predicted attrition bias. Three types of imputation were performed: (1) methods imputing forward in time (last observation carried forward; linear forward extrapolation); (2) methods considering data both forward and backward in time (nearest available observation-NAO; linear extrapolation; polynomial extrapolation); and (3) methods using multi-individual models (linear mixed effects cubic regression-LME3; multiple imputation by chained equation-MICE). The performance of each estimation method was assessed using the difference between the mean outcome value, the remission and low disease activity rates after imputation of the missing values and the true value. RESULTS: When imputing missing baseline values, all methods underestimated equally the true value, but LME3 and MICE correctly estimated remission and low disease activity rates. When imputing missing follow-up values at 6, 12, or 24 months, NAO provided the least biassed estimate of the mean disease activity and corresponding remission rate. These results were not affected by the presence of attrition bias. CONCLUSION: When imputing function and disease activity in large registers of active RA patients, researchers can consider the use of a simple method such as NAO for missing follow-up data, and the use of mixed-effects regression or multiple imputation for baseline data.
引用
- Mongin D, Lauper K, Turesson C, et al. Imputing missing data of function and disease activity in rheumatoid arthritis registers: what is the best technique? RMD Open. 2019. PMID: 31673410. doi:10.1136/rmdopen-2019-000994
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。