行政算法识别类风湿关节炎相关间质性肺病的性能
本研究在大型多中心RA登记队列中,利用ICD-9/ICD-10编码、提供者专科及操作日期构建行政算法,以病历复核为标准评估其识别RA相关ILD的性能。结果显示,要求≥2个ICD编码的算法特异性96.0%、PPV 65.5%、κ=0.70;加入肺科诊断或胸部CT+肺功能/肺活检后特异性98.0%、PPV 77.4%、κ=0.75,但敏感性随要求提高而下降。
要点
- ≥2个ICD编码区分ILD特异性96.0%、PPV 65.5%、κ=0.70。
- 加入肺科诊断或CT+肺功能/活检后特异性98.0%、PPV 77.4%。
- 算法要求提高时特异性与PPV改善,但敏感性下降。
核心结论
- 结合ICD编码、提供者专科、诊断测试及排除其他ILD病因的行政算法能准确分类RA相关ILD。
研究设计与样本
- 在大型多中心RA登记队列中,对ICD-9/ICD-10编码筛查阳性者及随机抽样阴性者进行病历复核确认ILD。
- 从退伍军人事务行政数据提取ICD及操作编码、提供者专科和日期构建ILD算法。
- 采用逆概率加权评估算法与病历复核相比的敏感性、特异性、PPV、NPV和κ值。
主要发现
- 病历复核536例RA患者,确认182例(严格定义)和203例(宽松定义)ILD。
- ≥2个住院或门诊ICD编码为最佳区分因素,特异性96.0%、PPV 65.5%、κ=0.70。
- 构建的ICD-9和ICD-10编码集提高特异性至96.8%、PPV至69.5%、κ=0.72。
- 包含肺科医生诊断或胸部CT加肺功能测试或肺活检的算法性能更优,特异性98.0%、PPV 77.4%、κ=0.75。
- 排除其他ILD病因后PPV升至78.5%(对比宽松定义82.4%),敏感性分析中PPV为83.4-86.3%。
关键数值与推荐
- ≥2个ICD编码:特异性96.0%、PPV 65.5%、κ=0.70。
- 优化ICD编码集:特异性96.8%、PPV 69.5%、κ=0.72。
- 加入肺科诊断或CT+肺功能/活检:特异性98.0%、PPV 77.4%、κ=0.75。
- 排除其他ILD病因:PPV 78.5%;宽松定义PPV 82.4%;敏感性分析PPV 83.4-86.3%。
临床怎么用
- 在RA患者中可采用≥2个ICD编码初筛ILD,但需注意PPV有限。
- 结合肺科专科诊断或胸部CT加肺功能/肺活检可提高算法特异性与PPV。
- 排除其他ILD病因有助于进一步提升PPV。
局限性
- 算法要求提高时敏感性下降。
- 研究基于退伍军人事务行政数据,外推需谨慎。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To determine the performance of administrative-based algorithms for classifying interstitial lung disease (ILD) complicating rheumatoid arthritis (RA). METHODS: Participants in a large, multicenter RA registry were screened for ILD using codes from the International Classification of Diseases, Ninth Revision (ICD-9) and the ICD-10. Medical record review confirmed ILD among participants screening positive and a random sample of those screening negative. ICD and procedure codes, provider specialty, and dates were extracted from Veterans Affairs administrative data to construct ILD algorithms. Performance of these algorithms against medical record review was assessed by sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value (PPV), negative predictive value, and kappa using inverse probability weighting to account for sampling methods. RESULTS: Medical records of 536 RA patients were reviewed, confirming 182 (stringent definition) and 203 (relaxed definition) cases of ILD. Initially, we identified ≥2 ICD codes from inpatient or outpatient encounters as optimal discriminating factors (specificity 96.0%, PPV 65.5%; κ = 0.70). Subsequently, we constructed a set of ICD-9 and ICD-10 codes that improved algorithm specificity (specificity 96.8%, PPV 69.5%; κ = 0.72). Algorithms that included a pulmonologist diagnosis or chest computed tomography plus pulmonary function testing or lung biopsy had improved performance (specificity 98.0%, PPV 77.4%; κ = 0.75). PPV increased with exclusion of other ILD causes (78.5%) in comparison with the relaxed ILD definition (82.4%) and in sensitivity analyses (83.4-86.3%). Gains in specificity and PPV with greater algorithm requirements were accompanied by declines in sensitivity. CONCLUSION: Administrative algorithms with optimal combinations of ICD codes, provider specialty, diagnostic testing, and exclusion of other ILD causes accurately classify ILD in RA.
引用
- England BR, Roul P, Mahajan TD, et al. Performance of Administrative Algorithms to Identify Interstitial Lung Disease in Rheumatoid Arthritis. Arthritis Care Res (Hoboken). 2020. PMID: 31421018. doi:10.1002/acr.24043
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。