结节病、淀粉样变与干燥综合征主要唾液腺超声特征比较
该研究纳入符合2016 ACR分类标准的干燥综合征患者、经组织学确诊的结节病或系统性AL淀粉样变患者及无唾液腺受累的对照,采用Hočevar方案行主要唾液腺超声并由盲法视频复核。干燥综合征超声评分高于其他组,但结节病和AL淀粉样变与干燥综合征无鉴别性唾液腺特征;对照组无人评分>17,而AL淀粉样变27%、结节病19%评分>17;将Hočevar评分≥17与2016 ACR/EULAR标准并联使干燥综合征敏感性从87%升至98%,串联使特异性从81%升至98%。
要点
- 干燥综合征唾液腺超声评分高于结节病、AL淀粉样变及对照,但后两者与干燥综合征无鉴别性特征。
- 对照组无人Hočevar评分>17,但AL淀粉样变27%、结节病19%评分>17。
- Hočevar评分≥17与2016 ACR/EULAR标准并联提高敏感性至98%,串联提高特异性至98%。
核心结论
- 干燥综合征、结节病和AL淀粉样变共享唾液腺超声特征,可帮助将这些疾病与无系统性风湿病的患者区分。
- 临床医生解读唾液腺超声结果时应仔细考虑这些潜在模仿者。
研究设计与样本
- 连续纳入符合2016 ACR分类标准的成人干燥综合征门诊患者、经任何组织学确诊的结节病或系统性AL淀粉样变患者及无影响唾液腺诊断的风湿科门诊对照。
- 受试者按Hočevar方案行主要唾液腺超声,所得视频片段在盲法下复核。
主要发现
- 干燥综合征的唾液腺超声评分高于其他组,但AL淀粉样变或结节病与干燥综合征之间无鉴别性唾液腺特征。
- 对照组无患者评分高于17(既往建议用于干燥综合征的界值),但AL淀粉样变27%和结节病19%的患者评分高于17。
- 将Hočevar唾液腺超声评分≥17与2016 ACR/EULAR标准并联使干燥综合征敏感性从87%升至98%,串联使特异性从81%升至98%。
关键数值与推荐
- 干燥综合征患者符合2016 ACR分类标准。
- Hočevar唾液腺超声评分≥17为既往建议用于干燥综合征的界值。
- Hočevar评分≥17与2016 ACR/EULAR标准并联:敏感性从87%升至98%。
- Hočevar评分≥17与2016 ACR/EULAR标准串联:特异性从81%升至98%。
临床怎么用
- 解读唾液腺超声时需警惕结节病和AL淀粉样变可模仿干燥综合征的超声表现。
- Hočevar评分≥17并非干燥综合征特异,结节病和AL淀粉样变患者也可出现。
- 将Hočevar评分≥17与2016 ACR/EULAR标准并联可提高干燥综合征敏感性,串联可提高特异性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: While salivary gland ultrasound (SGU) has gained prominence for evaluating Sjögren's syndrome, little information exists on SGU appearance of sarcoidosis and amyloidosis, potential mimics of Sjögren's syndrome. Our goal in this study was to estimate the diagnostic accuracy of major SGU features in differentiating Sjögren's syndrome from sarcoidosis, amyloidosis, and controls. METHODS: We enrolled consecutive adult ambulatory patients with a clinical diagnosis of Sjögren's syndrome fulfilling the 2016 American College of Rheumatology (ACR) classification criteria; we also enrolled patients with a clinical diagnosis of sarcoidosis or systemic immunoglobulin light chain (AL) amyloidosis, with histologic confirmation from any tissue, and rheumatology outpatients without diagnoses affecting salivary glands. Subjects underwent major SGU using the Hočevar protocol, with resulting video clips reviewed blind to clinical diagnosis. RESULTS: Sjögren's syndrome SGU scores were greater than in patients from the other groups, but there were no distinguishing salivary gland features from AL amyloidosis or sarcoidosis. None of the patients in the control group scored higher than 17, a cutoff previously suggested for Sjögren's syndrome, but 27% of patients with AL amyloidosis and 19% with sarcoidosis scored higher than 17. Adding Hočevar SGU scores of ≥17 to the 2016 ACR/European League Against Rheumatism criteria in a parallel scheme increased the sensitivity for Sjögren's syndrome from 87% to 98%, while combining the 2 criteria in series increased specificity from 81% to 98%. CONCLUSION: Sjögren's syndrome, sarcoidosis, and AL amyloidosis share common SGU features that can help distinguish these conditions from patients without systemic rheumatologic disease. Clinicians should carefully consider these potential mimics when interpreting salivary gland US results.
引用
- Law ST, Jafarzadeh SR, Govender P, et al. Comparison of Ultrasound Features of Major Salivary Glands in Sarcoidosis, Amyloidosis, and Sjögren's Syndrome. Arthritis Care Res (Hoboken). 2020. PMID: 31309727. doi:10.1002/acr.24029
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。