早期银屑病关节炎疾病活动度指标的比较
本研究基于荷兰西南部早期银屑病关节炎(PsA)队列(DEPAR),在诊断后1年内比较了DAS28、DAPSA、CPDAI、PASDAS、GRACE和MDA的反应度和纵向效度。结果显示PASDAS和GRACE在反应度上最优,且与MDA一起与健康相关生活质量(HRQOL)、生产力和残疾的纵向演变关联最强;DAS28、DAPSA和CPDAI的反应度和纵向效度较差。
要点
- PASDAS反应度最高(ES 1.00,SRM 0.95),DAPSA最低(ES 0.73,SRM 0.71)。
- PASDAS和GRACE最能区分不同总体健康状态。
- GRACE与HRQOL和生产力纵向演变关联最高,其次为PASDAS、MDA、DAPSA、DAS28,CPDAI最低。
核心结论
- PASDAS和GRACE在反应度上优于其他指标,且与MDA一起与HRQOL、生产力和残疾的纵向演变关联最强。
- DAS28、DAPSA和CPDAI的反应度和纵向效度多数较差,可考虑用PASDAS或GRACE替代连续指标DAPSA。
研究设计与样本
- 使用荷兰西南部早期PsA队列(DEPAR)数据,比较诊断后1年内常用疾病活动度指标的反应度和纵向效度。
- 反应度采用效应量(ES)、标准化反应均数(SRM)及不同总体健康状态间的区分度评估;纵向效度采用混合模型检验与HRQOL、生产力和残疾的关联。
主要发现
- 反应度最高为PASDAS(ES 1.00,SRM 0.95),最低为DAPSA(ES 0.73,SRM 0.71),DAS28、CPDAI和GRACE居中。
- 总体健康差异的区分度以PASDAS和GRACE最佳;DAS28或CPDAI无法区分报告总体健康稳定或恶化的患者;DAPSA区分度优于DAS28和CPDAI但劣于PASDAS和GRACE。
- HRQOL和生产力纵向演变与低疾病活动度的关联以GRACE最高,依次为PASDAS、MDA、DAPSA、DAS28,CPDAI最低。
关键数值与推荐
- PASDAS:ES 1.00,SRM 0.95;DAPSA:ES 0.73,SRM 0.71。
- 总体健康区分度:PASDAS和GRACE最佳,DAPSA优于DAS28和CPDAI但劣于PASDAS和GRACE。
- 与HRQOL和生产力纵向演变的关联强度排序:GRACE > PASDAS > MDA > DAPSA > DAS28 > CPDAI。
临床怎么用
- 在早期PsA常规诊疗中,评估疾病活动度可优先考虑PASDAS或GRACE。
- 若拟替代连续指标DAPSA,可考虑选用PASDAS或GRACE。
- DAS28和CPDAI对总体健康稳定或恶化患者的区分能力有限,解读时需谨慎。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: To compare responsiveness and longitudinal validity of Disease Activity Score 28 (DAS28), Disease Activity index for PSoriatic Arthritis (DAPSA), Composite Psoriatic Disease Activity Index (CPDAI), Psoriatic ArthritiS Disease Activity Score (PASDAS), GRAppa Composite scorE (GRACE) and Minimal Disease Activity (MDA) in usual care PsA patients, within 1 year after diagnosis. METHODS: Data collected in the Dutch southwest early PsA cohort (DEPAR) were used. Responsiveness was assessed using effect size (ES), standardized response mean (SRM), and discrimination between different general health states. Longitudinal validity was tested using mixed models with outcomes health-related quality of life (HRQOL), productivity and disability. RESULTS: Responsiveness was highest for PASDAS, with ES 1.00 and SRM 0.95, lowest for DAPSA, with ES 0.73 and SRM 0.71, and in between for DAS28, CPDAI and GRACE. Differences in general health were best discriminated with PASDAS and GRACE. Patients reporting stable or worsening general health could not be distinguished by DAS28 or CPDAI. Discrimination was better using DAPSA, but worse than when using PASDAS and GRACE. Longitudinal evolvement of HRQOL and productivity had the highest association with low disease activity according to GRACE, followed by PASDAS, MDA, DAPSA, DAS28, with the lowest association for CPDAI. CONCLUSION: PASDAS and GRACE were superior with respect to responsiveness, and together with MDA best related to longitudinal evolvement of HRQOL, productivity and disability. Responsiveness and longitudinal validity of most outcomes were inferior for DAS28, DAPSA and CPDAI. As alternatives to the continuous measure DAPSA, use of PASDAS or GRACE should be considered.
引用
- Wervers K, Luime JJ, Tchetverikov I, et al. Comparison of disease activity measures in early psoriatic arthritis in usual care. Rheumatology (Oxford). 2019. PMID: 31211399. doi:10.1093/rheumatology/kez215
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。