纤维肌痛诊断:大学诊所中纤维肌痛标准与临床医生诊断的不一致
在一项大学风湿病诊所研究中,497例患者完成2010年美国风湿病学会(ACR)纤维肌痛标准自评版,并由风湿科医生依据ICD诊断纤维肌痛。结果显示标准阳性者占24.3%,临床诊断者占20.9%,两者一致性仅κ=0.41,提示临床诊断与标准诊断存在显著不一致。
要点
- 临床医生与标准诊断纤维肌痛的一致性仅为中等(κ=0.41)。
- 医生漏诊49.6%的标准阳性患者,误诊11.4%的标准阴性患者。
- 在类风湿关节炎亚组中,一致性更差(κ=0.32)。
核心结论
- ICD临床诊断与基于标准的纤维肌痛诊断之间存在显著不一致,对基于ICD的研究提出质疑。
研究设计与样本
- 在大学风湿病诊所中,497例患者在常规就诊时完成多维健康评估问卷(MD-HAQ)和2010年ACR纤维肌痛初步诊断标准自评修改版,并由大学风湿科人员评估诊断。
主要发现
- 497例中121例(24.3%)符合纤维肌痛标准,104例(20.9%)获得临床医生ICD纤维肌痛诊断。
- 临床医生与标准诊断的一致性为79.2%,但校正机遇后仅中等(κ=0.41)。
- 医生未识别60例标准阳性患者(49.6%),错误识别43例标准阴性患者(11.4%)。
- 在88例类风湿关节炎(RA)亚组中,κ值为0.32,提示轻微至中等一致性。
- 普遍而言,更高的多症状困扰评分和基于标准的诊断与更异常的MD-HAQ临床评分相关。
关键数值与推荐
- 符合2010年ACR纤维肌痛初步诊断标准自评修改版的患者占24.3%,临床ICD诊断纤维肌痛者占20.9%。
- 临床医生与标准诊断的总体一致性为79.2%,κ=0.41。
- 在RA亚组88例中,κ=0.32。
临床怎么用
- 在风湿科临床中应关注纤维肌痛诊断标准的使用,以减少临床诊断与标准诊断之间的不一致。
局限性
- 原文指出临床医生偏倚、纤维肌痛诊断含义及医生诊断有效性方面存在实质性问题。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: Recent studies have suggested that fibromyalgia is inaccurately diagnosed in the community, and that ~75% of persons reporting a physician diagnosis of fibromyalgia would not satisfy published criteria. To investigate possible diagnostic misclassification, we compared expert physician diagnosis with published criteria. METHODS: In a university rheumatology clinic, 497 patients completed the Multidimensional Health Assessment Questionnaire (MD-HAQ) and the 2010 American College of Rheumatology preliminary diagnostic criteria modified for self-administration during their ordinary medical visits. Patients were evaluated and diagnosed by university rheumatology staff. RESULTS: Of the 497 patients, 121 (24.3%) satisfied the fibromyalgia criteria, while 104 (20.9%) received a clinician International Classification of Diseases (ICD) diagnosis of fibromyalgia. The agreement between clinicians and criteria was 79.2%. However, agreement beyond chance was only fair (κ = 0.41). Physicians failed to identify 60 criteria-positive patients (49.6%) and incorrectly identified 43 criteria-negative patients (11.4%). In a subset of 88 patients with rheumatoid arthritis (RA), the kappa value was 0.32, indicating slight to fair agreement. Universally, higher polysymptomatic distress scores and criteria-based diagnosis were associated with more abnormal MD-HAQ clinical scores. Women and patients with more symptoms but fewer pain areas were more likely to receive a clinician's diagnosis than to satisfy fibromyalgia criteria. CONCLUSION: There is considerable disagreement between ICD clinical diagnosis and criteria-based diagnosis of fibromyalgia, calling into question ICD-based studies. Fibromyalgia criteria were easy to use, but problems regarding clinician bias, meaning of a fibromyalgia diagnosis, and the validity of physician diagnosis were substantial.
引用
- Wolfe F, Schmukler J, Jamal S, et al. Diagnosis of Fibromyalgia: Disagreement Between Fibromyalgia Criteria and Clinician-Based Fibromyalgia Diagnosis in a University Clinic. Arthritis Care Res (Hoboken). 2019. PMID: 30724039. doi:10.1002/acr.23731
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。