类风湿关节炎前足MRI评分(RAMRIS)效度系统综述:OMERACT滤器评估
该系统综述检索至2018年1月的医学文献,纳入13项研究,评估RAMRIS应用于类风湿关节炎跖趾关节MRI的效度。结果显示,仅骨髓水肿和骨侵蚀有结构效度证据,滑膜炎、腱鞘炎和关节间隙狭窄缺乏证据,区分度数据待完善,可行性无研究,总体效度不足。
要点
- 骨髓水肿和骨侵蚀有结构效度证据,滑膜炎、腱鞘炎和关节间隙狭窄缺乏证据。
- 区分度方面仅可靠性、纵向结构效度和试验区分能力有少量数据。
- 可行性方面无研究,OMERACT滤器评估下前足RAMRIS效度不足。
核心结论
- 根据OMERACT滤器,RAMRIS应用于前足(跖趾关节)的效度在多个方面不足。
- 骨髓水肿和骨侵蚀有结构效度提示,但滑膜炎、腱鞘炎和关节间隙狭窄缺乏结构效度。
- 区分度数据对所有结局均待完善,可行性无研究。
研究设计与样本
- 系统文献综述,检索医学文献数据库至2018年1月。
- 纳入标准为报告RA患者跖趾关节MRI应用RAMRIS且包含至少一个MRI特征和OMERACT滤器至少一个条目的研究。
- 从749篇检索文献中纳入13项研究:9项提供结构效度数据,4项提供区分度数据(3项可靠性、2项纵向结构效度、1项试验区分能力),无可行性数据。
主要发现
- 结构效度:骨髓水肿和骨侵蚀有提示性证据,滑膜炎、腱鞘炎和关节间隙狭窄缺乏证据。
- 区分度:可靠性有3项研究,纵向结构效度有2项研究,试验区分能力有1项研究,所有结局的区分度数据待发展。
- 可行性:无研究提供数据。
关键数值与推荐
- OMERACT滤器包含真实性(面效度、内容效度、结构效度)、区分度(重测信度、试验区分能力、纵向结构效度、意义阈值)和可行性。
- 结构效度在骨髓水肿和骨侵蚀上得到提示,但在滑膜炎、腱鞘炎和关节间隙狭窄上缺乏。
- 区分度数据对所有结局均待完善,可行性无数据。
临床怎么用
- 当前证据不支持将RAMRIS常规应用于前足跖趾关节的MRI评估。
- 临床研究中若使用前足RAMRIS,应优先关注骨髓水肿和骨侵蚀,并注意滑膜炎、腱鞘炎和关节间隙狭窄的效度不足。
- 需进一步研究区分度和可行性,以完善前足RAMRIS的验证。
局限性
- 检索截止至2018年1月,可能未纳入后续研究。
- 纳入研究数量有限(13项),且可行性无研究。
- 区分度数据有限,仅部分结局有研究。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: MRI depicts inflammation and structural damage in rheumatoid arthritis (RA). The validity of MRI-scoring of wrist-joints and metacarpophalangeal-joints according to the RA MRI score(RAMRIS) has been demonstrated. The Outcomes in Rheumatology Clinical Trials (OMERACT) RAMRIS Working Group recently called for validation of the RAMRIS of the metatarsophalangeal (MTP)-joints. Therefore, a systematic literature review was performed to test if the RAMRIS applied to the MTP-joints meets the OMERACT Filter of Truth, Discrimination and Feasibility. METHODS: Medical literature databases up to January 2018 were systematically reviewed for studies reporting on RAMRIS applied to MRI of the MTP-joints in RA. To be included, an article had to contain at least one MRI-feature (synovitis, bone marrow oedema (BME), tenosynovitis, erosion, joint space narrowing (JSN)) and one item from the OMERACT Filter: Truth (face, content and construct validity), Discrimination (test-retest reliability, ability to discriminate in trials, longitudinal construct validity and thresholds of meaning) and Feasibility. RESULTS: Of the 749 retrieved studies, 13 were included, of which 9 provided data on construct validity, 4 on discrimination (3 on reliability, 2 on longitudinal construct validity and 1 on ability to discriminate in trials) and none on feasibility. Construct validity was suggested for BME and erosions, but lacking for synovitis, tenosynovitis and JSN. Data for discrimination remain to be developed for all outcomes. CONCLUSION: According to the OMERACT Filter, the validity of the RAMRIS of the forefeet is insufficient in different aspects. A research agenda was determined.
引用
- Dakkak YJ, van der Heijde DM, Reijnierse M, et al. Validity of the rheumatoid arthritis MRI score applied to the forefeet using the OMERACT filter: a systematic literature review. RMD Open. 2018. PMID: 30713714. doi:10.1136/rmdopen-2018-000796
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。