哪种评分方法最能反映早期中轴型脊柱关节炎的脊柱放射学损伤?DESIR队列的五年结果
基于DESIR队列699例早期中轴型脊柱关节炎患者,比较SASSS、mSASSS、RASSS、BASRI-spine和BASRI-total五种脊柱放射学损伤评分方法的性能。mSASSS和RASSS在捕捉变化信号方面表现最佳,患者方差解释比例均为85%,其他方法为50-55%。mSASSS仍是中轴型脊柱关节炎(包括早期)最敏感和有效的评分方法。
要点
- 五年净变化超过最小可检测变化(>1)的比例:RASSS 17%(17%),mSASSS 12%(12%)。
- mSASSS和RASSS的患者方差解释比例均为85%,其他方法为50-55%。
- RASSS胸段患者方差解释比例不理想,进展评分为46%。
核心结论
- 现有脊柱放射学损伤评分方法在早期中轴型脊柱关节炎中表现良好,mSASSS和RASSS捕捉了大部分变化。
- RASSS额外评估胸椎未见明显增益,mSASSS仍是中轴型脊柱关节炎(包括早期)最敏感和有效的评分方法。
研究设计与样本
- DESIR队列五年脊柱X线片由三名读者评分(取平均值),计算SASSS、mSASSS、RASSS、BASRI-spine和BASRI-total。
- 按照OMERACT filter从真实性、区分度(信度和敏感度)和可行性方面比较各评分方法,共纳入699例患者。
主要发现
- 五年净变化超过最小可检测变化(>1)的比例:RASSS 17%(17%),mSASSS 12%(12%),BASRI-spine和BASRI-total 12%(9%),SASSS 11%(11%)。
- mSASSS和RASSS在捕捉与噪声(负变化)相关的信号(正变化)方面表现最佳。
- 患者方差解释比例在mSASSS和RASSS中最高(五年进展评分均为85%,其他方法为50-55%)。
- RASSS胸段的患者方差解释比例不理想(进展评分为46%)。
局限性
- RASSS胸段的患者方差解释比例不理想(进展评分为46%)。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To compare the performance of different spinal radiographic damage scoring methods in patients with early axial spondyloarthritis (axSpA). METHODS: Five-year spinal radiographs from the DESIR cohort were scored by three readers (averaged) for the calculation of the Stoke AS Spine Score (SASSS), modified Stoke Ankylosing Spondylitis Spine Score (mSASSS), Radiographic AS Spinal Score (RASSS), BASRI-spine and BASRI-total, and following the OMERACT filter, scores were compared according to truth, discrimination (reliability and sensitivity to change) and feasibility. The proportion of patients with a net change > smallest detectable change and >1 was calculated. The proportion of total variance explained by the patient (true variance) was calculated for the change scores as a measure of reliability, using analysis of variance. RESULTS: In total 699 patients were included. Five-year net changes > smallest detectable change (>1) were: RASSS 17% (17%), mSASSS 12% (12%), BASRI-spine and BASRI-total 12% (9%), SASSS 11% (11%). The mSASSS and the RASSS performed the best in terms of capturing the signal (positive change) related to noise (negative change). The proportion of variance explained by the patient was highest for the mSASSS and RASSS (85% for both 5-year progression scores vs 50-55% for other methods). The proportion of patient variance in the thoracic segment of the RASSS was unsatisfactory (46% for progression). CONCLUSION: The existing scoring methods to assess spinal radiographic damage performed well in early phases of axSpA. The mSASSS and RASSS captured most change. There was no clear gain in additionally scoring the thoracic spine for the RASSS. The mSASSS remains the most sensitive and valid scoring method in axSpA, including early phases of the disease.
引用
- Ramiro S, Claudepierre P, Sepriano A, et al. Which scoring method depicts spinal radiographic damage in early axial spondyloarthritis best? Five-year results from the DESIR cohort. Rheumatology (Oxford). 2018. PMID: 30053219. doi:10.1093/rheumatology/key185
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。