文献速递其他结缔组织病

甲襞毛细血管镜检查能否帮助预测系统性硬化症的远期结局:一项系统文献综述

Does nailfold capillaroscopy help predict future outcomes in systemic sclerosis? A systematic literature review.
PubMed 文献 · Semin Arthritis Rheum · 2018-02-14

本系统综述检索EMBASE和MEDLINE,纳入18项成人系统性硬化症纵向研究,评估甲襞毛细血管镜(NC)对疾病进展和生存的预后价值。多数研究(17/18,94%)报告基线NC表现与临床结局正相关,但偏倚风险中高,尤其混杂因素调整不足;作者认为NC演变可能更能预测疾病进展。

要点

  • 17/18(94%)研究报告基线NC表现与数字溃疡、生存、疾病进展、钙质沉着、皮肤进展、肺动脉高压等结局正相关。
  • QUIPS工具显示偏倚风险中高:混杂因素和统计分析各13/18,预后因素测量10/18。
  • 作者认为NC演变可能是更重要的疾病进展预测因素,可能影响NC在常规纵向评估中的未来应用。

核心结论

  • 与混杂和统计分析相关的高水平潜在偏倚使关于NC在SSc中预后作用的结论难以得出。
  • 有强证据支持NC异常(尤其毛细血管丢失)与疾病严重程度(尤其血管表现如DU、钙质沉着和PAH)相关。
  • NC表现的演变可能代表更重要的疾病进展预测因素,可能对NC在SSc常规纵向评估和管理中的未来应用有重要启示。

研究设计与样本

  • 系统文献综述,标准化检索EMBASE和MEDLINE,纳入报告NC对疾病进展和/或生存预后价值的成人SSc纵向研究。
  • 排除非英文、非原创研究、动物研究、非成人研究和非全文报告(PROSPERO 2017:CRD42017071719)。
  • 因研究设计、预后因素测量和结局高度异质性,采用定性数据合成;用QUIPS偏倚风险工具评估研究质量,由2名评审独立完成选择、提取和评估。

主要发现

  • 942篇检索文章中18项研究符合纳入标准。
  • 17/18(94%)研究报告基线NC表现(采用多种定性、半定量和定量NC终点)与临床结局正相关,包括DU发生/愈合、生存、疾病进展(Medsger疾病严重度量表域)、钙质沉着、皮肤进展、PAH和/或「心血管事件」复合分析。
  • QUIPS工具显示潜在偏倚中高风险:研究参与6/18、研究失访3/18、预后因素测量10/18、结局测量5/18、混杂因素13/18、统计分析13/18。
  • 跨研究最重要的潜在偏倚来源是对潜在混杂因素调整不足,例如评估未来DU发生的研究中未充分调整既存DU疾病。
  • 近期工作提示NC演变是SSc疾病进展的重要预测因素。

临床怎么用

  • 作者认为NC异常(尤其毛细血管丢失)与疾病严重程度(尤其DU、钙质沉着和PAH等血管表现)之间的关联有强证据支持。
  • 作者认为NC表现的演变可能代表更重要的疾病进展预测因素,可能对NC在SSc常规纵向评估和管理中的未来应用有重要启示。

局限性

  • 研究设计、预后因素测量和研究结局存在广泛异质性, necessitating定性数据合成。
  • QUIPS工具识别出研究参与(6/18)、研究失访(3/18)、预后因素测量(10/18)、结局测量(5/18)、混杂因素(13/18)和统计分析(13/18)存在中高潜在偏倚风险。
  • 研究质量限制了从这些研究得出结论的强度。
  • 跨研究最重要的潜在偏倚来源是混杂因素调整不足,例如评估未来DU发生的研究中未充分调整既存DU疾病。
  • 与混杂和统计分析相关的高水平潜在偏倚使关于NC在SSc中预后作用的结论难以得出。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Nailfold capillaroscopy (NC) is an important diagnostic tool in systemic sclerosis (SSc). Confirmation of NC as a prognostic factor could facilitate earlier intervention and slow disease progression in SSc. We undertook a systematic literature review to evaluate the prognostic value of NC in predicting SSc disease progression. METHODS: Standardised searches of EMBASE and MEDLINE were undertaken to identify longitudinal studies of adult subjects with SSc reporting the prognostic value of NC for any aspect of disease progression and/or survival. Non-English, non-original research, animal studies, non-adult studies and non-full length reports were excluded from the analysis (PROSPERO 2017:CRD42017071719). Wide heterogeneity in study design, prognostic factor measurement and study outcomes necessitated a qualitative data synthesis. The "QUality In Prognosis Studies" (QUIPS) risk-of-bias tool was used to assess study quality. Study selection, data extraction and risk-of-bias assessment were each undertaken independently by 2 reviewers and consensus reached where necessary. RESULTS: Of 942 retrieved articles, 18 studies fulfilled the inclusion criteria. The majority of studies (17/18, 94%) reported positive associations between baseline NC appearances (using a variety of qualitative, semi-quantitative and quantitative NC endpoints) and clinical outcomes including digital ulcer (DU) occurrence/healing, survival, disease progression (using domains of Medsger disease severity scale), calcinosis, skin progression, pulmonary arterial hypertension (PAH), and/or a composite analysis of "cardiovascular events". Application of the QUIPS tool identified a moderate-high risk of potential bias in 6/18 studies for study participation, 3/18 studies for study attrition, 10/18 for prognostic factor measurement, 5/18 for outcome measurement, 13/18 for confounders and 13/18 for statistical analyses. Study quality limited the strength of the conclusions drawn from these studies. The most important source of potential bias across the studies was insufficient adjustment for potential confounders; such as existing DU disease in studies evaluating future DU occurrence. Recent work suggests NC evolution is an important predictor of disease progression in SSc. CONCLUSIONS: High levels of potential bias relating to study confounding and statistical analysis make it difficult to draw conclusions regarding the prognostic role of NC in SSc. There is strong evidence supporting an association between NC abnormalities (particularly capillary loss) and disease severity (particularly vascular manifestations such as DU, calcinosis and PAH). Evolution of NC appearances may represent a more important predictor of disease progression which could have important implications for the future use of NC in the routine longitudinal assessment and management of SSc.

来源:Semin Arthritis Rheum,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Paxton D, Pauling JD. Does nailfold capillaroscopy help predict future outcomes in systemic sclerosis? A systematic literature review. Semin Arthritis Rheum. 2018. PMID: 29602558. doi:10.1016/j.semarthrit.2018.02.005

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。